
John Bogle on Investing 4/9/2007
What this covers
This is a conversation between Russ Roberts and Jack Bogle, and much of it is Bogle's own history. It starts with his 1951 Princeton senior thesis, which concluded that mutual funds could claim no superiority over the market averages. It then moves to his firing as head of Wellington Management Company and his failed proposal to "mutualize" its funds. The directors let him run only administration, and Bogle describes using the index fund, partly inspired by Paul Samuelson, as a somewhat "disingenuous" route into investment management. The first fund was mocked as "Bogle's Folly" after an offering aimed at $150 million raised only $11 million. It later grew into the world's largest mutual fund.
The practical advice covers more than stocks. Bogle says about 98% of bond funds are not worth owning, because the bond market is homogeneous and managers can subtract value through costs more easily than they can add it. He recommends short or intermediate maturities, and says a long-horizon bond investor should "pray every night" for higher rates. On money market funds, he notes a near-perfect correlation between low cost and high return, and he cites Information Asymmetry to explain why expensive ones survive. He says individuals should leave hedge funds to tax-exempt endowments with the resources for due diligence. He also describes his own 60/40 bond-and-stock portfolio, held at Vanguard and checked once a year under his Don't Peek rule.
The conversation turns contentious on governance. Bogle argues that institutional agents, who hold most US stock, behave as traders rather than owners, and that government should require a "fiduciary society" and support rules like Sarbanes-Oxley. Roberts objects that markets punish dishonest firms and that compliance costs favor large corporations over small, innovative ones. Bogle also makes the contested claim that earnings track GDP, so managers can ignore economic data.
John Bogle argues that investing should mean owning businesses at the lowest possible cost rather than trying to beat the stock market. Because of the 'relentless rules of humble arithmetic,' costs and investors' own performance-chasing behavior take most of the market's return, which makes low-cost index funds, and active funds built to resemble them, the rational choice. He also argues that a capitalism run by agents and managers must be pushed back toward fiduciary duty to owners.
- Investors as a group earn the market return before costs, so a typical 2.5% fund cost turns an 8% market into 5.5%, and over a lifetime roughly 80% of the return goes to the financial system.
- Past performance does not persist: the top funds of 1996-99 ranked near dead last afterward, and fund investors lag their own funds by about 3 points a year through bad timing.
- About 70% of US stock is held by institutional agents who trade rather than govern, so the 'agency society' must become a 'fiduciary society'.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Under the 'relentless rules of humble arithmetic', investors as a group earn the market's return before costs, for example 8%, and lose to it by the amount of their costs. Typical mutual fund costs of about 2.5% a year turn an 8% market into 5.5% for the average fund investor. Compounded over a lifetime, about 80% of the return goes to the financial system and 20% to the investor, even though the investor put up 100% of the capital and took 100% of the risk.
“compounded over a lifetime, that means that about 80% of the investors' return goes to the financial system, and 20% goes to the investor”
Even a good fund that beats the market will underperform about one year in three. Investors pour money in after the two good years and pull it out after the bad one, which means buying at the high and selling at the low and destroys their returns.
“A good fund is going to underperform one year out of three. ... after the two good years, the money pours in, and after the one bad year, the money pours out.”
In money market funds, where all firms hold essentially the same portfolios, the correlation between low cost and high return is about .99. High-cost money funds still survive because of information asymmetry: sellers know things buyers do not and withhold information that makes them look bad.
“the correlation is 99 between low cost and high return in the money market area cuz we're all on the same portfolios”
Individual investors should let others buy hedge funds. Individuals' accounts are taxable and hedge funds are very tax-inefficient. The endowments and pension funds that use hedge funds successfully pay no taxes, have infinite time horizons, and have resources for due diligence: Princeton's $13-14 billion endowment reportedly spends 400 hours selecting a single hedge fund manager.
“Princeton University Investment Company that runs the endowment there and 13 to 14 billion dollars uh spends 400 hours in selecting a hedge fund manager”
Investors should ignore the stock market, which Bogle calls 'a giant distraction' that focuses attention on daily prices and market expectations. Investing is really about owning businesses and collecting the return on capital that businesses have always earned, through earnings that grow with the economy and dividends that are paid out.
“I don't think people should pay any attention to the stock market. I call it in the book a giant distraction.”
Past success alone is no reason to expect future success. You can look back and find strategies that worked in the past for no reason that will hold in the future. Bogle was confident in indexing because he knew why it had worked: it was at least as diversified as the average fund but cost less.
“you can look back and see things that work in the past with no reason at all I can work in the future. Right. But indexing, it worked in the past because ...”
A truly long-term bond investor with a 25-30 year horizon should 'pray every night' for interest rates to rise. Higher rates raise the reinvestment rate, and the temporary fall in principal recovers as quality bonds mature at par value.
“the one thing you should be praying for every night is for interest rates to go up. Because the reinvestment rate in your bond portfolio will also go up.”
Bogle used the index fund, inspired partly by Paul Samuelson's article 'Challenge to Judgment', as a way to get Vanguard into investment management despite the board's restriction. He argued that an index fund needs no manager and is administrative work. He admits the move was somewhat 'disingenuous', but it worked.
“it also gave me a vehicle to get into investment management uh for Vanguard, because the index, I as I argued to the board, didn't need a manager”
Fund flows follow a conventional pattern. A fund is small during the years it builds a good record. Investors notice around year seven and pour money in, and returns then revert to average or worse. As a result, the typical fund investor earns about 3 percentage points a year less than the typical fund.
“the typical fund investor uh does about earns about three percentage points per year less than a typical fund”
'Performance comes and goes, but costs go on forever.' It is easy to see who did well yesterday but impossible to know who will do well tomorrow. Investors are terrible fund pickers primarily because they look backward.
“Performance comes and goes, but costs go on forever, just like clockwork.”
Bogle keeps about 60% of his portfolio in bonds and 40% in stocks, all at Vanguard, and says he will never change it. He follows a self-imposed 'first rule: don't peek' and looks at his portfolio only once a year, even though he reads the financial pages daily.
“I'm about 60% in in bonds and about 40% in stocks. I'll never change that ... the first rule is don't peek.”
'Performance comes and goes, but costs go on forever.' Everyone knows who did well yesterday, but nobody knows who will do well tomorrow, and investors are poor fund pickers mainly because they look backward.
“Performance comes and goes, but costs go on forever, just like clockwork.”
The fundamental precepts of Vanguard's unique mutual structure, in which funds are run for their own shareholders, have never been copied by other fund groups.
“To start a unique company that still hasn't used fundamental precepts of mutual mutual fund group have yet to be copied.”
Bogle's guidance on bond maturities has two parts. For a cash reserve with no immediate needs, use a short-term bond fund: it fluctuates, but over a few years its higher return will outweigh the fluctuations compared with a money market account. For somewhat more risk, an intermediate-term fund is preferable, because the record shows only a small premium for long-term funds, which may not be worth the price volatility.
“I like the intermediate-term bond fund because the record shows you get a small premium from a long-term bond fund, but it may well not be worth the hassle”
The first index fund was derided as 'Bogle's Folly'. Its underwriting, launched shortly after the 1973-74 market decline of about 50%, aimed to raise $150 million but raised only $11 million, too little to buy all 500 stocks. Bogle refused to return the money, and the fund later grew to $185 billion, the largest mutual fund in the world.
“the underwriters thought they could raise $150 million, and and they raised $11 million”
Vanguard grew out of a politicized situation in which Bogle was fired as CEO of Wellington Management. He proposed to 'mutualize' the Wellington funds so they would be run for their own shareholders rather than for management company shareholders. The directors refused, but let him run only administration, meaning shareholder records, fund accounting and legal compliance, and barred him from marketing and investment management.
“not make mutual funds the captives of a management company ... but rather to mutualize those uh Wellington mutual funds and have them run for the benefit of their own shareholders”
The 10 best-performing mutual funds of the 1996-99 bull market, out of about 800 funds, ranked roughly 790th to 800th in the three years that followed, when the market went down. Performance chasing in inflated markets is therefore the investor's worst enemy.
“those top 10 funds ranked very roughly from 790th to 800th, dead last”
Market discipline over corporations fails because owners are no longer owners. Nearly 70% of US stock is held by financial institutions acting as agents, which do not engage in corporate governance. Instead they trade pieces of paper and care mainly whether CEOs meet earnings expectations, which are usually met fairly but sometimes by foul means.
“Nearly 70% of all stock in America is not held by direct owners, but by financial institutions.”
Over long periods, corporate earnings per share grow at about the same pace as the economy, roughly 6% nominal for each. Economics and business are therefore highly correlated, while economics and the stock market are not, so portfolio managers are right to ignore GDP data.
“we have 6% roughly nominal growth in our economy and we have a 6% nominal growth in corporate earnings so economics and business are correlated, highly correlated. Right. But economics and the stock market are not.”
About 98% of all bond funds 'aren't worth the powder to blow them to smithereens'. The bond market is homogeneous: in a 7% market, investment-grade managers cluster at 6-8% gross returns, so managers have little ability to add value but great ability to subtract it through costs.
“about 98% of all bond funds aren't worth the powder to blow them to smithereens”
Capitalism has moved from an 'ownership society' of direct owners, which is gone for good, to an 'agency society' whose agents do not serve their principals, the mutual fund owners and pension beneficiaries. Bogle says what is needed is a 'fiduciary society', with government requiring rather than running it: investment fiduciaries' first obligation would be to serve their beneficiaries and act as owners engaged in corporate governance.
“We have an agency society where the agents are not serving their principals ... So, we need a fiduciary society.”
Roberts disagrees: dishonesty is better corrected in the marketplace, where investors and consumers punish dishonest firms. Both markets and regulation are imperfect, so the question is which works better. Regulation also favors large corporations, which can spread fixed compliance costs over large sales, while smaller firms struggle to comply, an unseen effect that may hurt innovation.
“they have the ability to spread those fixed costs of compliance across a large number of sales. Smaller firms find it much harder to comply, and so I worry that there's an unseen effect of of hurting innovation”
Bogle sets out the arithmetic of a typical bond fund's costs. With a portfolio yielding about 5%, a typical 5% sales load wipes out the first year's income. Roughly 1% in annual expenses plus about 0.25% in hidden transaction costs then reduce the 5% return to about 3.75%. To compensate, high-cost funds take on riskier bonds.
“when you buy a bond fund from your broker, you've just said goodbye to your first ... year of income”
Bogle's hand-built spreadsheets for the board showed that the average mutual fund lagged the S&P 500 by about 1.3% a year. Over 25 years, that gap meant $1 million grew to about $26 million in the index versus about $17 million in the average fund.
“a million dollars invested at in the index with that 1.3% differential, uh in the index grew to something like $26 million, and in the average mutual fund uh grew to something like $17 million”
Traditional 'owners' capitalism' has been displaced by 'managers' capitalism', in which managers, accountants and lawyers work in league to reward managers. Corporate directors have failed to stand up on option plans, backdated options, executive compensation and financial engineering.
“what I call managers capitalism, where managers and the accounting firms and the lawyers all kind of in league to make sure the managers are rewarded has gotten in the way of traditional owners capitalism”
In his 1951 Princeton senior thesis on the mutual fund industry, Bogle wrote that 'mutual funds can make no claim to superiority over the market averages'. He observed that funds of that era, which were mostly middle-of-the-road and lower-cost, delivered roughly the market return minus their costs.
“Mutual funds can make no claim to superiority over the market averages. I.e., funds can't beat the indexes.”
Hedge funds are extremely diverse: some are market-neutral with virtually zero price risk, some are leveraged so highly 'it would curl your hair', some are run by charlatans and some by the most respected investors in America. The most respected managers are closed to new money because, as Warren Buffett says, 'a fat wallet is the enemy of superior returns'.
“the ones run by the most respected investors in America uh are not taking any more money uh because they realize that as Warren Buffett says, a fat wallet is the enemy of superior returns”
Economics suggests that publicly available information is already embodied in stock prices. The best bet is therefore not to seek an edge by picking stocks but to invest in the whole market, especially since the transaction costs of trading punish investors, which favors buy-and-hold.
“publicly available information is embodied in the prices of stocks and your best bet then is to not look for an edge by picking the the stocks”
Investing is 'simple but not easy', like dieting. It consists of blocking and tackling: getting asset allocation right, keeping costs low, matching risk to your ability to bear it, diversifying, and investing for the long term.
“investing is all about blocking and tackling ... Getting your asset allocation right and making sure your costs are low. Making sure your risks are commensurate with your ability to deal with risk. Diversifying, investing for the long term.”
Bogle forecasts that the typical mutual fund investor's real return over the coming decade could be zero, before the extra taxes funds impose. A typical fund might return 5.5%, investor timing would subtract about 3 points to leave about 2.5%, and expected inflation of about 2.5% would erase the rest.
“your real return for the typical mutual fund investor in the coming decade could be zero”
Sarbanes-Oxley was needed because large corporations lacked financial controls. Even General Motors, usually the 'gold standard' of accounting, had just announced control errors requiring it to restate about five years of earnings.
“we needed a Sarbanes-Oxley bill. I don't even think question about that.”
Bond investors should first narrow the field to the lowest-cost bond funds offered by reputable fund organizations, and only then choose among them. Vanguard runs its bond funds at about 15 basis points (0.15%) a year, and few managers can consistently overcome a large cost differential.
“Vanguard runs our bond funds for around 15 basis points a year, 0.15 of 1%. And uh nobody can beat that.”
Bill Miller's run of beating the S&P 500 for 14-15 straight years, with Amazon as his largest holding, is what pure randomness would predict among thousands of managers. Roberts doubts Miller had inside information or better instincts, and notes the run ended the previous year.
“He was one of thousands, as you might predict in a random world where there is no edge to be gained by actively managing funds, but by random pure randomness one fund manager will outperform”
Bogle regrets that although Vanguard forced the industry to pay attention to costs, it has not forced the industry to lower them very much. There is a modest price war in index funds and money market funds, but not much beyond that.
“we certainly have forced the industry to pay attention on cost but we don't seem to have forced the industry to get its cost down very much”
Bogle's strategy for active funds was to give them the characteristics that make indexing attractive. That meant no sales load, management fees negotiated down 'until the manager almost walks out of the room', managers who invest long-term with low turnover to cut transaction costs and taxes, a discrete market sector for each manager (e.g., Windsor as large-cap value), and multiple managers per fund.
“my strategy was to make the actively managed funds uh have the same characteristics that make indexing so attractive”
A study over roughly the last decade found the average hedge fund returned about 9% a year. The Wellington Fund, a balanced stock-and-bond fund, returned about 9.4% with less volatility and far greater tax efficiency, without the glamour or the inflows of about $100 billion every three or four months that hedge funds attract.
“the average hedge fund had a return of I think it was 9% uh per year ... the Wellingham Fund produces a return of 9.4% I think is the number with less volatility”
Bogle's greatest impact, in economic terms, is that by closing the gap between before-fee and after-fee returns he drew more money into capital markets. That has made more business and innovation financially viable. The effect is real but unmeasurable, which explains the gap between his reputation and his actual achievements.
“more money has gone into capital markets than otherwise would because you've closed the gap between before and after fee returns”
Sarbanes-Oxley enforcement has been too weak. The Public Company Accounting Oversight Board 'hasn't done very much' to discipline accountants. The provision requiring CEOs to disgorge option profits after earnings are restated (for example, from $2 to $1 a share, with the stock at $20 instead of $10) has, as far as Bogle knows, not been enforced to any significant degree.
“the law calls for disgorgement of the profit that you made ... as far as I know that practice that that has not been enforced in any significant degree”
Roberts says people who grew up in the Depression, like his parents (born 1930 and 1932), can be emotionally biased against stocks even when they intellectually understand their virtues. His parents prefer junk bonds, which are also very risky.
“intellectually, I think he understands the virtues of it, but emotionally, it's very hard for him to get over that childhood”
Using several managers within a style produces average results: 'the average value manager is average'. Despite his hopes of picking above-average managers, Vanguard's managers are on average about average. Vanguard wins by about 1.5 percentage points a year simply by removing sales commissions, high expense ratios and turnover costs.
“we can win by about 1 and 1/2 percentage points a year. This is clearly shown in the record.”
A bond fund with a long average maturity, about 20 years in Roberts' friend's case, is not 'safe money'. It carries substantial interest-rate risk: if rates rise, its principal value falls.
“He thought that was his safe money. But he was taking a great deal of risk that interest rates would rise, that the principal asset value of that holding would go down”
In the fund business, marketing/distribution and investment management are the two functions that determine success or failure. Efficient administration is a necessary condition but not a sufficient one for growth.
“those were the two key functions, marketing and investment management, uh that determine whether you succeed or fail. Yes, of course you have to be an efficient administrator, uh but that's not a driver”
Market convergence toward better products happens faster where quality is transparent. The slow adoption of low-cost funds reflects how hard it is for consumers to observe fund quality.
“in other areas uh where quality is more transparent it does happen closer to overnight”
The roughly 100,000 security analysts ought to be challenging corporations on questionable practices, for example asking where a company got the 8.5% return it assumes on its pension plan. They are not doing so.
“I think there are 100,000 security analysts, should be saying to these corporations, "Look, this is wrong and that's wrong. Tell me where you got that 8.5% return on your pension plan that you're assuming."”
Bogle chose the mutual fund industry as his thesis topic after finding an article in the December 1949 issue of Fortune, because he wanted a subject no one had written a thesis on. He says the overriding influence of economics on him was that it led him into the investment business.
“I stumbled across uh the December 1949 issue of Fortune magazine, uh where there was an article about an industry that I had never heard of before, the mutual fund industry.”
Economics is really about human behavior and the choices people make, and financial choices are only one subset of those choices. Popular culture wrongly equates economics with the stock market.
“economics is is really about human behavior and the choices we make and of course the financial choices we make are one subset of those”
'Never think you know more than the market. Nobody does.' The record shows that portfolio managers as a group, including Vanguard's own, do not know more than the market.
“Never think you know more than the market. Nobody does.”
In markets where quality is more transparent, competitive change happens much closer to overnight than in the fund industry.
“in other areas uh where quality is more transparent it does happen closer to overnight”
Vanguard pioneered 'series' bond funds defined by maturity, so each investor knows exactly what kind of bonds they are buying. The series runs from short-term (about 2 years average maturity) to intermediate (about 8 years) to long-term (about 15-16 years), across municipals, corporates and treasuries.
“we created here quite a few years ago uh series bond funds, uh and no one had ever done it that way before”
Vanguard kept its actively managed funds rather than going all-index. When the index fund launched, Vanguard had about $2 billion in active funds against $11 million in the index fund. Bogle felt it would be presumptuous to convert satisfied shareholders, such as holders of the Wellington Fund, a balanced fund operating since 1928, into an index fund they had not chosen.
“after the index fund offering, we had $2 billion of actively managed funds and $11 million of index funds”
The 1973-74 market decline of about 50% was the same kind of decline as the 2000-2002 bear market.
“just starting to recover a little bit from the '73-'74 50% decline. Same kind of decline we just experienced in uh 2000-2002”
The enduring appeal of active management is the argument that one need not accept the average: by picking smart managers from the right-hand tail who have beaten the S&P 500 repeatedly, one could beat the index, making index funds 'for suckers'. Roberts considers this argument wrong but seductive.
“I'm going to pick the smart managers. I'm going to go out and pick people from the right-hand tail who have successfully beaten the S&P 500.”
Investors tend to treat their portfolios like the sports page, checking the box scores every morning, which is a bad habit for investing.
“we're used to the sports page. We like to look up the box scores every morning”
One thing economics is good for is understanding that index mutual funds are probably the best investors can do.
“one of the things it's good for is is understanding that index mutual funds are um probably the best you can do”
Paul Samuelson wrote in the introduction to his 1951 economics textbook that the problem with free competition and capitalism, like the problem with Christianity, is that it has never actually been tried. Bogle says this remains as true today as it was then.
“the problem with free competition and capitalism like the problem of Christianity is that it's never actually been tried”
Bogle says luck has played an enormous role in his life and that one shouldn't be proud of luck, only feel lucky about it. Creating the first index fund 'didn't require any genius'; he simply made the most of the opportunities that came to him.
“luck has played an enormous enormous role in my life. And one shouldn't be proud of luck. One should feel lucky about luck”
Business complaints about Sarbanes-Oxley focus almost entirely on Section 404's internal-control requirements. Those compliance costs will fall over time, and Bogle supports streamlining genuinely onerous controls, but laws are harder to change than regulations.
“there are very few complaints, even in the business community, about Sarbanes-Oxley except uh for the complaint about Section 404 ... Those costs will go down with time.”
Although he does not intuitively like government intervention, Bogle argues that businesses cannot simply say 'we did wrong and we'll fix it ourselves'. When the private system isn't working, government must be brought in, a point he says even Alexander Hamilton would have accepted.
“I think there's a point at which even Alexander Hamilton, as I point out in my book, would have agreed with this. If if the private system isn't working, we got to bring the government in.”
Vanguard has been the 'Walmart' of the fund industry: its focus on cost has forced competitors to pay attention to costs.
“Vanguard's really been the Walmart uh of its industry in the sense that it's it's focused on costs has forced its competitors to pay attention to that”
Bogle distrusts boards that strive for unanimous decisions, because unanimity tends to produce the lowest common denominator.
“I'm not so much on unanimous decisions, cuz I think you get lower common denominator”
Bogle's family fortune, built by his grandfather, vanished in the Depression, so he grew up having to earn what he got. He calls this an 'unfair advantage' over most others in his line of work.
“we had a a nice little family fortune based on my grandfather's success as a businessman ... and it vanished in the depression”
The growth of hedge funds works in the opposite direction from the push to lower costs. Hedge funds are taking some of the better managers while charging much higher fees on the promise of higher returns.
“hedge funds are stealing some of the better managers. Uh but they also charge a much higher fee, uh promising higher returns”
Underwriters lose interest the day after an underwriting closes; the issuer is on its own.
“the day after the underwriting is over, they have forgotten you”
In this business 'time is money'. The longer it takes to convert the world to low-cost investing, the more investors lose along the way, so Bogle would like the change to happen overnight, though it won't.
“time is money in this business. So the more time it takes to convert the world to this more intelligent way of investing uh ... they lose money on the way”
Roberts names Bogle's senior thesis and Fred Smith's thesis on overnight express delivery as the two most important senior theses ever written in America.
“It now joins uh Fred Smith's thesis on overnight express delivery ... as as the two most important senior theses ever written in America”
Roberts thinks the glass is half full: the corporate scandals were a bad set of episodes, but the system is doing pretty well overall.
“I think the glass is half full. I think it's it's we're doing pretty well. But uh it was a bad episode set of episodes.”
Bogle uses rare positive feedback, such as letters from investors daily and almost no negative letters in about 25 years, as an indicator of how much his principles have helped people.
“the number of negative letters I get from people, I can't remember the last time I got one, maybe 25 years ago”