
Charles Murray on Coming Apart
What this covers
This Uncommon Knowledge interview at the Hoover Institution has host Peter Robinson question Charles Murray about Coming Apart. Murray's two test neighborhoods are Belmont, the affluent Boston suburb where Mitt Romney lives, and Fishtown, a white working-class Philadelphia neighborhood. He tracks them on marriage, work, religiosity, and crime. Marriage among working-class adults aged 30 to 49 fell from 84% in 1963 to 48% in 2010, while the upper-middle class held near 84%. By 2008, one in eight Fishtown men in their 30s and 40s was neither working nor looking for work. Murray puts violent crime in Fishtown at about 4.7 times its 1960 level. The conversation closes with the personal score on his "bubble quiz."
The causes Murray offers are structural. He describes a college sorting machine that turned Harvard from a school of rich kids into one of smart kids between 1952 and 1960, along with the rising market value of cognitive ability. Both concentrate talent in a new upper class. He also argues that the 1960s liberalization hit both communities, but Belmont recovered by the mid-1980s because it had more to lose. Robinson adds data on declining civic participation and recalls the 1963 Motion Picture Code as a marker of a shared moral baseline.
The talk then moves to the stakes. Murray draws on the founders' view that the Constitution needs a virtuous population, on Aristotle's account of happiness through family, faith, community, and vocation, and on Arnold Toynbee's idea that a declining civilization's dominant minority loses confidence in its own values. He compares this to Rome, which he says lost its Republic centuries before the fall. Contested claims include his argument that the welfare state strips men of dignity as providers, his call to say plainly that unmarried births harm children independent of income, and his charge that the new elite has abdicated its duty to set moral standards. He also contrasts the American model of local self-help with the European welfare-state alternative.
Murray argues that America has experienced a catastrophic divergence between upper-middle-class (Belmont) and working-class (Fishtown) communities since 1963, driven by assortative mating, educational sorting, and market returns to cognitive ability, resulting in the loss of a shared civic culture and the virtues required for self-governance.
- Marriage rates in working-class communities collapsed from 84% to 48% while remaining stable in upper-middle class at 84%, indicating fundamental cultural divergence
- The college sorting machine and homogamy (assortative mating of high-IQ individuals) concentrate talent and wealth in the upper class while draining it from working-class communities
- The civic culture and social capital that sustained American self-governance—rooted in family, faith, community, and meaningful work—are eroding in working-class Fishtown, threatening the democratic project
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Marriage rates among high school educated blue collar workers ages 30-49 declined from 84% in 1963 to 48% in 2010, while marriage rates in the upper-middle class remained stable at around 84%, representing an unprecedented sea change in a central cultural institution with no precedent in human history over such a short period.
“if you had a high school educated Blue Collar person in 1963 who was ages 30 to 49 the odds were 84% that he was married... in 2010 you are down to 84% for the upper middle class which is still quite high you're down to 48% for the white working class I mean that is that's that's that is a sea change in a central cultural institution that has almost no precedent that I know of”
By 2008, in Fishtown (white working class), one out of eight males in their 30s and 40s were not working or looking for work, even during the 1990s when jobs were plentiful everywhere, indicating these are not men unable to find jobs but rather men who have opted out of the labor market.
“by that time about 1 hour out of eight males white males in Fishtown was not even looking for work they were out of the labor market including during the 1990s when jobs were everywhere these are not guys who are saying boy I'd really like to get a job they're guys who are living off their girlfriends or off their parents or off their siblings”
Every vital civilization has a dominant creative minority that sets the tone and expresses confidence in its own rightness, while declining civilizations have a dominant minority that has lost confidence in its own rightness and values (per historian Arnold Toynbee).
“every vital civilization uh and I'm drawing actually on the work of Arnold Toby here... he says look the the the sign of a growing culture a vital culture is a dominant uh creative minority as he calls it who uh set the set the tone and the rest of the society follows along and they this this uh creative minority is confident it's energetic uh and then when you have a declining civilization the creative minority becomes a dominant minority still runs the country but it no longer has the confidence in its own rightness”
The founders of the United States were unanimous in saying that the Constitution will not work with just any kind of population; the population must possess certain virtues, particularly: integrity of marriage, industriousness, religiosity, and plain American honesty.
“the founders were unanimous in saying this Con institution will not work with just any kind of population the population must possess certain virtues and this was virtues virtues this is not just one or two Founders who said this they all did and they also focused on four uh that were crucial uh all of them agreed there were others that they you know had in the list but these four were Central uh the Integrity of marriage uh industriousness religiosity uh and plain American honesty”
Aristotle's concept of happiness (eudaimonia) means lasting and justified satisfaction with life as a whole, which is achieved through four domains: family, faith, community, and vocation (work or meaningful causes).
“if you take happiness seriously as a concept and I use Aristotle as my guide for that you're talking about lasting and Justified satisfaction with life as a whole and you ask yourself now what is it that gives people lasting and Justified satisfaction with life and a whole and it has been my argument that I've been writing about for many years that basically you've just got four domains within which that happen happens and those are Family Faith uh community and vocation”
The increasing market value of brains—the phenomenon that very high cognitive ability is worth vastly more in contemporary markets than in previous eras—has created a new upper class that pulls away from people of average and below-average intelligence.
“it is simply a lot more valuable let's say to have uh very high ability in mathematics uh than it used to be I mean what could you do if you a pure mathematician in the 1920s you could become a college professor teach I will give you a whole lot of Quant funds that will make you rich beyond your wildest dreams if you're a fine pure mathematician today”
Religious people account for about half of all social capital in America, and even more social capital comes from religious people because religious people are more likely to be engaged in secular forms of social capital than non-religious people.
“Robert putam says about half of all Social Capital comes directly from the religious population and even more comes from it because religious people are more likely to be engaged in secular forms of Social Capital than non-religious people”
By 2010, religiosity in both Belmont and Fishtown had declined significantly, with the proportion of people reporting regular church attendance and strong faith affiliation down to one out of eight in Fishtown, making them increasingly seen as oddballs.
“by the time you get to 2010 you're looking at a proportion of people who report that they both attend church regularly and have a strong affiliation with their faith that is down to one out of eight people in Fishtown which means really they're such a small minority at that point they're increasingly seen as oddballs”
The college sorting machine, beginning in the 1950s, transformed elite universities from places filled with rich kids and a few smart ones (like Harvard in 1952) into places filled with smart kids and a few rich ones (Harvard by 1960), with Harvard freshmen's average SAT verbal scores rising more than 100 points over that period.
“Harvard in 1952 was a place with a lot of rich kids and a few Smart Ones by 1960 was a place with a lot of smart kids and a few rich ones... the average Harvard freshman's sat verbal score went up by more than 100 points over uh that period”
The Motion Picture Code of 1963 enforced strict moral standards, explicitly discouraging abortion, forbidding depiction of unmarried couples in the same room, and condemning premarital sex—representing the shared moral baseline that was enforced even in entertainment.
“quote the subject of abortion shall be discouraged Ed shall never be more than suggested and when referred to shall be condemned close quote taken for granted you also did not show unmarried couples uh sleeping in the same room or another any other way uh suggest that premarital sex was okay”
Voting in presidential elections has declined 22% from 1960 to 1996, attendance at public meetings on town/school affairs down 35% from 1973 to 1994, service as club/organization officer down 42% from 1973 to 1994, and PTA membership down 61% from 1960 to 1997—these declines are concentrated in Fishtown, not evenly distributed.
“voted in the presidential election down 22% from 1960 to 1996 attended a public meeting on town or School Affairs down 35% from 1973 to 1994 served as an officer of some club or organization you talk about the Elks and uh rotary and so forth local organiz down 42% from 73 to 94 percentage of parents with children under age 18 who are members of the PTA down 61% from 1960 to 1997”
A cultural shift is necessary wherein it becomes standard in conversation and journalism to truthfully state that births to unmarried women cause problems for children's future lives independent of poverty and parental education, without demonizing the women involved.
“we have to have for something like births to unmarried women sort of as a natural statement that journalists make when they write articles about problems of disadvantaged neighborhoods or whatever that in fact being born to unmarried women causes all sorts of problems for the children in their future life independently of poverty and independently of parent parental education that ought to that has to be in the air not you don't have to demonize women who have babies out of telling the truth”
In 1963, when you lost a job or had a rough patch, neighbors would step in and help with money and other resources through informal mutual aid networks—social capital that no longer exists in Fishtown today.
“the guy next door is has had a rough patch uh has lost his job is looking for a new job and the neighbors step in and help sometimes with money uh where where all sorts of problems are solved without the bureaucracies”
Marvin Olasky's book The Tragedy of American Compassion documents the incredible inventory of organizations in New York City (Protestant churches, Catholic societies, Jewish organizations, secular groups) providing education and support to disadvantaged children in the 19th and early 20th centuries, demonstrating the depth of voluntary civic engagement.
“the Marvin oasi in his book The Tragedy of American compassion I published many years ago has this wonderful compilation of organizations in New York City uh from the churches from the Protestant churches and it's talking about dozens of centers for educating disadvantaged children of you can go through it's just an incredible inventory of things that were done”
American exceptionalism was based on two central claims: (1) America as the land of opportunity where you could make something of yourself and your children could live better lives, and (2) the unique American ability to solve problems and help each other at the local level, which is so rare globally it is nearly unique.
“why is it that people all over the world looked at the United States and said we were different well some aspects were the land of opportunity you can go to the United States you could make something of yourself uh and uh your children could live a better life than than you did but another aspect of this exceptionalism was people would look at us and see the way that Americans solved problems and helped each other at the local level and it was very close to Unique”
Rome took its initial downward step 500 years before the Barbarian invasions and fall of the empire—when Caesar became the first emperor and Rome lost its Republic—not in material terms (Rome remained wealthy and powerful) but in terms of what Romans treasured, making it a tragedy that no amount of Imperial Splendor could redeem.
“Rome took quote its initial downward step its loss of the Republic when Caesar became the first emperor was that loss important I'm continue to quote you not in material terms Rome of course remained an empire for five cent it grew it grew it got richer but for Romans who treasured their Republic it was a tragedy that no amount of Imperial Splender could redeem”
The Bell Curve, published 18 years before Coming Apart, established as a thesis that there is an increasing market value of brains in the advanced West and Asia, a phenomenon that has permeated these regions over the intervening period.
“the central thesis of the bell curve which dick karnstein and I published almost 18 years ago long are you kidding I would 18 yeah it's 18 years and and that is simply a phenomenon that has permeated uh the advanced West and for that matter the advanced uh Asian countries”
Elite universities that claim to prioritize diversity are actually factories producing a new upper class, and this is problematic not because the meritocratic principle is wrong but because its unintended consequence is to concentrate talent and advantage in one class.
“the elite schools at which the enshrined value is diversity are in fact factories producing a new upper class yeah and the problem is that a lot of what they're doing is admirable in the following sense if you are a bright kid from a disadvantaged background whether you're white or black or Asian or whatever uh the odds are you're not only going to go to college you're going to go to a really good college that's good... but it produces these unintended outcomes that are also very powerful”
The 1960s cultural liberalization (sexual revolution, divorce, cohabitation) happened in both Belmont and Fishtown, but the upper-middle class straightened out around the mid-1980s while working-class communities did not, reflecting that the upper-middle class had resources and future opportunities to rebound from foolish behavior while Fishtown did not.
“marriage in Belmont declined until about mid1 1980s and then it stabilized... it's as if the upper middle class kids had a real great time during the 60s and during the 1970s it got a little Sleazy and maybe they began to wonder whether this is really the right way to spend your life and they straightened out... they had the same experience in the 60s and 7s but the social norms there did collapse uh the stigma against such a thing as having a baby out of wedlock went away and women in Fish Town didn't have nearly the same kind of future to protect”
When marriage collapsed and families fractured in Fishtown, it enabled crime to flourish because the informal social monitoring and enforcement that once kept crime in check—'neighbors keeping eye' on children—disappeared, and today violent crime in Fishtown is about 4.7 times higher than it was in 1960.
“when you have social capital the doors don't have to be locked the uh kids can't play alone in the street anymore and whereas New York City is a good example of Life becoming really much safer for the upper middle class in the cities but had never been dangerous to the upper middle class in the suburbs uh in in the fish towns crime is still about well violent crime is about 4.7 times higher than it was in 1960”
When a man lives under a welfare system that guarantees his children will be cared for regardless of his contribution, his status as provider disappears, which removes from him a major source of meaning and dignity.
“if that same man lives under a system that says the children of the woman he sleeps with Will be taken care of whether or not he contributes then that status goes away”
The hollow elite—the new upper class—are dysfunctional in their own way as the new lower class, not personally or as families (where they are successful) but in having abdicated their responsibility to set and promulgate moral and cultural standards.
“my proposition is that the hollow Elite... is as dysfunctional in its way as the new lower class is in its way personally and as families its members are successful but they have abdicated their responsibility to set and promulgate standards”
Western Europe developed an alternative to the American model: an advanced welfare state providing personal freedom in all life areas except economic ones, and prominent academics and Democratic Party leaders believe America should embrace this model.
“over the course of the 20th century Western Europe developed an alternative to the American model the advanced welfare state that provides a great deal of personal freed in all areas of life except the economic ones you write that more and more Americans including quote prominent academics and the leaders of the democratic party close quote believe we should embrace the European model”
Belmont and Fishtown represent two distinct neighborhoods: Belmont refers to an affluent suburb of Boston (where Mitt Romney lives), with all residents having attended college and working in prestigious jobs, while Fishtown refers to a white working-class neighborhood in Philadelphia that has existed since the Revolutionary era.
“Belmont refers to um Belmont Massachusetts which is an affluent suburb of Boston whereas it turns out I didn't know this Mitt Romney lives uh and Fishtown refers to a neighborhood in Philadelphia that's been a white workingclass neighborhood probably since the revolution”
A man holding a menial job and supporting a wife and children is doing something authentically important with his life and should take deep satisfaction from that and be praised by his community for doing so.
“a man who is holding down a menial job and thereby supporting a wife and children is doing something authentically important with his life he should take deep satisfaction from that and be praised by his community for doing so”
For institutions like family, faith, community, and vocation to be rich and vital, they must have things that won't get done unless the institution does them—they must have responsibility and stakes that matter for the institution to be meaningful.
“in order for a person to pursue happiness those institutions of meaning if you want to use that phrase have to be rich and vital well how is it that a family is Rich and the family structure is Rich and vital it's because the family has things that won't get done unless the family does them there has to be responsibility placed on the institution called the family to make it rich and vital same thing goes with Community same thing goes with with all of them”
In 1963, workforce participation for adult men was effectively universal (excluding those with legitimate incapacity), and non-work was a moral failing: a man not working and not seeking work at ages 30-40 was considered 'a bum' by his family and community.
“if you were a guy and you were in your 30s and 40s you either were working or you were looking for work or you had better have a really good excuse like being completely totally physically incapacitated... if you weren't working and not looking for work at that age group you were a bum your your parents would tell you that your siblings would tell you that your wife if you had one would be appalled”
The decline of the working class cannot be primarily attributed to either union decline (left narrative) or feminism (right narrative) because regardless of which is true, a 35-year-old man sitting home during a time of abundant jobs is exhibiting a problem—a fundamental loss of industriousness.
“let's let's say that the left is completely right and that we have demoralized men out there you know they've lost their the the manufacturing jobs and the rest and they're stuck with this lousy set of jobs suppose the right is completely right and the an argument says it's it's feminism which de destroyed the male role that's I don't care which one is right if you have a 35-year-old man uh who was sitting at home in a time when jobs are plentiful everywhere it doesn't make any difference whether he's demoralized because of the loss of labor unions or demoralized because of feminism he's still sitting at home”
Between 70-80% of students who score over 700 on the SAT are from the upper-middle class, not because of test prep courses but because the upper-middle class now dominates the smartest kids in America.
“the percentages in the book it's either in the high 70% or the low 80% of kids who get those High SAT scores are from the upper middle class and it's not because they take test prep courses uh it is simply a reflection of the degree to which uh the upper middle class is beginning to dominate the smartest kids”
Before any policy solution can work, there must be a cultural shift in which people in the upper-middle class super-zips (wealthy, educated enclaves) confront whether they really want their children growing up as hothouse flowers unaware of the richness of American life outside their bubble.
“before we even have a chance at a solution we have to have a cultural shift in our attitude toward what's going on that means for example for the people encapsulated in their enclaves they are super rich super well educated enclaves with their own culture the super Zips super zip super zip they've got to figure out do you really want your children to grow up as hot house flowers do you really want your children to be unaware of this Rich panoply of life that is out there in America”
The social trust remaining in Fishtown may be insufficient to sustain traditional American neighborliness and local problem-solving, making a revival of civic culture difficult.
“the big question is is whether the remaining levels of social trust in Fishtown are enough to sustain anything approaching the traditional expectations of American neighborliness and local problem solving it is hard for me Charles Murray to Envision a Revival”
New York City's transformation from high-crime neighborhoods in the late 1980s/1990s to a safer upper-middle-class experience demonstrates that revival of civic life is possible, contrasting with the persistent violence in Fishtown where crime remains 4.7 times higher than it was in 1960.
“violent crime is about 4.7 times higher than it was in 1960 it's come down a little but it's qualitatively different and worse than it was in the 1960s”
The book deliberately does not explain what caused the decline of working-class norms—whether it is the collapse of labor unions, the rise of service economy part-time work, or feminism—because the data about the breakdown itself should be understood first before engaging in left-right political fights about causation.
“and what accounts for these wonderful kinds of Social Capital Robert putam says about half of all Social Capital comes directly from the religious population and even more comes from it because religious people are more likely to be engaged in secular forms of Social Capital than non-religious people so you're looking at a real mess focused on Fishtown not inma coming apart quote the big question is is whether the remaining levels of social trust in Fishtown are enough to sustain anything approaching the traditional expectations of American neighborliness and local problem solving”
Obamacare and other specific healthcare policy debates are ancillary to the core dynamics Murray is describing; they twiddle at the margins rather than addressing the fundamental institutional and cultural problems that drive working-class decline.
“you don't want to be dragged into the current mud fight yeah no but you know Obamacare is ancillary to the kinds of things I'm talking about as I think a lot of is a symptom yeah it's it's a symptom of the increasing welfare state but whether Obamacare is repealed or not reped field is going to twiddle at the margins with the kinds of Dynamics I'm talking about”
In 1963, America had a common civic culture transcending rich and poor that was the direct descendant of the civic culture the founders set up with the Constitution, but this is no longer the case today.
“there were things that we had in 1963 that we are in danger of losing irrevocably and that is what is known as America's Civic culture because in 1963 we had a common Civic culture transcending rich and poor uh that was the direct descendant of the Civic culture that the founders set up uh with the Constitution”
Contemporary child-rearing teaches children to be 'nice' (avoiding moment-to-moment trouble) rather than 'good' (pursuing long-term virtue requiring self-discipline, foresight about consequences, and experience of remorse for wrongdoing), representing a fundamental collapse of moral education.
“we teach them to be nice we teach them to share their toys not to hit each other and so forth the idea that being good is a thing that you aim toward with all of the self-discipline the thinking ahead to long-term consequences and the rest that being good requires the remorse which you rightly experience when you've done something bad something something bad um all of these things are are not part of the raising of our children we want them to be nice being nice is a way of moment to moment not creating trouble it is not a way of inculcating standards of behavior that will get you through tough times”
When Queen Victoria wrote in her diary 'I will be good,' she exemplified the moral seriousness of Victorian society—the understanding that 'being good' requires self-discipline, thinking ahead to long-term consequences, and the remorse that comes from wrongdoing.
“Queen Victoria we have in her Diaries one of the first Diary entries after she becomes Queen at the age of 18 she writes I will be good I will be good”
Harvard Square has transformed from a lower-middle-class neighborhood (in the early 1960s) into an enclave of boutique shops, fine restaurants, and luxury cars, reflecting how the new upper class takes over surrounding areas and establishes cultural dominance.
“go to Harvard Square now and believe me what you find is not a Five and Dime Store outside the gates of Harvard Yard you find lovely little Boutique shops and every kind of restaurant you can imagine and Lovely Hotel every parking meter taken by alus or a Mercedes”
Murray explicitly rejects several policy solutions: a system of mandatory national service (drafting young people to mix with each other), renewal of military draft, or government regulation forcing cultural integration of Belmont and Fishtown—not merely from libertarian principle but because program evaluation evidence shows such policies won't work.
“it is not a system of domestic service where we draft all young people and send them out to mix with each other that won't work uh it's not a renewal of the draft it's not government regulations of you're not going to force these two cultures to mix yeah it it's not a matter of just me being a Libertarian and and horrified by that prospect it's a matter of me who made his livings the program evaluation evaluator saying ain't going to work”
The trends that Murray describes in Fishtown—collapse of marriage, industriousness, religiosity, and social capital—indicate the virtues required for self-governing communities are slipping toward a tipping point beyond return, at which point America will have a permanent lower class that is sizable and no longer participating in American institutions.
“the trends that I describe in Fishtown are in effect saying that the virtues required to be a self-governing community are slipping toward a Tipping Point beyond return and at that point we will have a permanent lower class that is different in kind from a lower class that the United States has had before in that it is both sizable and it is no longer participating in American institutions”
In contemporary society, nonjudgmentalism has become dominant: college campuses refuse to engage students in discussions of right and wrong, instead using language like 'appropriate and inappropriate' or 'relative to the situation,' indicating the loss of confidence in moral and ethical standards.
“we are now in the age of nonjudgmentalism uh you go to any college campus and you try to engage the students there in a discussion of right and wrong and excuse me Dr Murray you mean appropriate and inappropriate in appropriate or you know relative to the situation”
Raising a family, supporting yourself, being a good friend and neighbor, learning what you can do well and doing it excellently, and maintaining a framework that enables these things represents what the American project is fundamentally about.
“raising a family supporting yourself being a good friend and a good neighbor learning what you can do well and then doing it as well as you possibly can providing the best possible framework for doing those things is what the American project is all about”
Creation of an extensive welfare state far beyond the current one will become unavoidable if the working class becomes non-participating, creating a cycle where the upper class must subsidize a permanent underclass.
“it's also going to induce the creation of an extensive welfare state far beyond the one we have now”
Students who were rejected by Harvard and Yale but had good enough test scores and credentials to get in have been tracked in follow-up studies and do just about as well as students who were actually admitted to Harvard and Yale, suggesting the prestige and cost of elite degrees is overstated.
“we also know from other studies that kids who get turned down by Harvard and Yale but had test scores and things good enough to get in they've been tracked and they do just about as well as the kids who got into Harvard and Yale”
The new upper class has developed a distinctive culture that differs from the rest of America in nearly everything: television consumption (35 hours per week for average Americans vs. zero or DVDs/Downton Abbey for upper class), body weight, type of beer consumed, child-rearing practices, and cultural taste, creating a separate world from the working class.
“you have a culture which differs from the rest of America in just about anything you can name uh TV the average American watches 35 hours of TV a week uh in the new upper class that's they like to brag off and they don't even even have a TV anymore or if they do they use it to watch DVDs or Downtown Abbey or uh the newsour... I could list everything from the average weight of members of new upper class compared to the average weight of Americans they're much skinnier uh to uh the kind of beer they drink to the way they raise their children there is a distinctive culture”
Non-Latino whites are used as the base population for analysis not because problems are confined to that group but because using this single-race group concentrates attention on the actual cultural problems rather than attributing them to African-American communities or illegal immigration issues.
“I'm going to be talking about social problems and when you do that when you include everybody the natural response is to say well maybe Murray's really talking mostly about problems that are located in the African-American Community or perhaps it's a problem of illegal immigration and the non Latino whites as the base of your number MERS concentrates the Mind wonderfully right uh in terms of coming to grips with these problems which I think it has succeeded in doing judging from the reaction to the book anyway”
It is very rare to find cultures with strong traditions of hospitality to strangers or guests, but it is extremely rare to find cultures in which people who simply happen to live near each other voluntarily help each other, making this nearly unique to America and essential to American identity.
“you know there are all sorts of cultures that have very strong traditions of hospitality to strangers uh or Hospitality to guests period you try to find cultures in which people who just happen to live near each other voluntarily help each other that is really rare um in fact it's so rare that I I think the word unique is really close to applicable”
The British upper-middle class in the 19th century had tremendous verve and self-confidence, propagandized the whole country into buying into their system of morals, which allowed Britain to manage rapid urbanization while experiencing falling crime—but by the 1930s they lost self-confidence.
“the British upper class no not the aristocracy the the upper middle class uh it's the colonels not the general victorians they propagandized the whole country into buying into their system of morals and and as a result you had this incredibly rapidly urbanizing society which actually experienced falling crime during the same period of its most dis ating urbanization”
The danger to the American project is not external threat but the loss of the framework through which people can pursue happiness—the civic, family, faith, and vocational institutions that enable meaningful life.
“when I say that the American project is in danger that's the nature of the loss I have in mind the loss of the framework through which people can best pursue happiness”
The Civic culture and shared institutional participation in America are irreplaceable; once lost, they cannot be recovered, and the loss will mean that the universality of being American—the embrace that was intended for all people—will be gone.
“but it also is going to induce the creation of an extensive welfare state far beyond the one we have now... something very fundamental to the common the universality of of being an American the the Embrace that it that it intended to have of all people that'll be gone and that is going to be a huge loss”
In 1963, church attendance among Americans was very high, with about 50% reporting they had attended a worship service in the preceding week, representing the apex of religiosity in the United States.
“we know for the whole population uh it was about 50% said said they had attended a worship service in the preceding week that'll give you a sense of the degree of religiosity that existed then”
Alexis de Tocqueville's Democracy in America describes America's civic culture and emphasizes that Americans form associations at the drop of a hat, a characteristic that conforms to and exemplifies the kind of American civic culture that existed through the 20th century.
“the famous quote about Americans forming associations the drop of a hat Tok Phil's democracy essentially describes America's Civic culture”
The book's thesis is fundamentally about how we need to think about the nature of the problem, not about immediate concrete policy implications; Murray hopes the book starts hundreds of thousands or millions of conversations about the nature of the divergence.
“there is almost no direct immediate concrete policy implication of the book there are huge implications for how we need to think about the nature of the problem... I think of the book as starting the conversation or I'd like to think that it starts hundreds of thousands or millions of conversations”
Murray moved to a town of 170 people, which exemplifies practical action upper-middle-class people can take to expose themselves and their children to the broader American experience (though he acknowledges this extreme measure is not necessary).
“I did it by moving to a town of 270 people that worked pretty well no I'm sorry 170 people that worked pretty well but you don't have to be that extreme”
Charles Murray experienced the civic culture firsthand in small-town Iowa (15,000 people) and this civic culture also existed in neighborhoods of large cities—urbanization does not prevent civic culture, but other causes are eroding it.
“I lived in smalltown iow what smalltown Iowa 15,000 people and and I experienced exactly that kind of of Civic culture that existed there but I want to emphasize Peter it also existed in neighborhoods and large cities uh so it's not urbanization that prevents this from happening”
A scoring test that measures whether someone is inside the 'new upper class bubble' by asking about TV habits, celebrity knowledge, and manual labor experience can be used to assess how completely someone is embedded in upper-class culture.
“in coming apart you have a wonderfully engaging and amusing test self test do you do this do you do that have you seen this television program can you identify this pop star have you ever held a job that caused a body part to her at the end of day”
The upper middle class refers to the top 20% of the population by income, not the elite, and is the group exhibiting the cultural characteristics Murray describes in the book.
“I'm not talking about the elite which I think some later segments we will talk about I'm talking about the top 20% of the population”
David Brooks wrote in the New York Times that he would be shocked if there is another book this year as important as Coming Apart, suggesting the book's significance was recognized by mainstream media at publication.
“David Brooks of the New York Times quote I'll be shocked if there's another book this year as important as Charles Murray's coming apart”