Fishtown
A fictional working-class community (named after Fishtown, Philadelphia) representing the white working class, characterized by high school education, blue-collar or low-level service work, collapsing marriage rates, declining religiosity, and loss of civic participation.
As defined in Charles Murray on Coming Apart
Where it comes up · 1
- Charles Murray on Coming Apart12 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “Fishtown” →
- By 2008, in Fishtown (white working class), one out of eight males in their 30s and 40s were not working or looking for work, even during the 1990s when jobs were plentiful everywhere, indicating these are not men unable to find jobs but rather men who have opted out of the labor market.Charles Murray on Coming Apart
- By 2010, religiosity in both Belmont and Fishtown had declined significantly, with the proportion of people reporting regular church attendance and strong faith affiliation down to one out of eight in Fishtown, making them increasingly seen as oddballs.Charles Murray on Coming Apart
- Voting in presidential elections has declined 22% from 1960 to 1996, attendance at public meetings on town/school affairs down 35% from 1973 to 1994, service as club/organization officer down 42% from 1973 to 1994, and PTA membership down 61% from 1960 to 1997—these declines are concentrated in Fishtown, not evenly distributed.Charles Murray on Coming Apart
- In 1963, when you lost a job or had a rough patch, neighbors would step in and help with money and other resources through informal mutual aid networks—social capital that no longer exists in Fishtown today.Charles Murray on Coming Apart
- When marriage collapsed and families fractured in Fishtown, it enabled crime to flourish because the informal social monitoring and enforcement that once kept crime in check—'neighbors keeping eye' on children—disappeared, and today violent crime in Fishtown is about 4.7 times higher than it was in 1960.Charles Murray on Coming Apart
- The 1960s cultural liberalization (sexual revolution, divorce, cohabitation) happened in both Belmont and Fishtown, but the upper-middle class straightened out around the mid-1980s while working-class communities did not, reflecting that the upper-middle class had resources and future opportunities to rebound from foolish behavior while Fishtown did not.Charles Murray on Coming Apart
- Belmont and Fishtown represent two distinct neighborhoods: Belmont refers to an affluent suburb of Boston (where Mitt Romney lives), with all residents having attended college and working in prestigious jobs, while Fishtown refers to a white working-class neighborhood in Philadelphia that has existed since the Revolutionary era.Charles Murray on Coming Apart
- The social trust remaining in Fishtown may be insufficient to sustain traditional American neighborliness and local problem-solving, making a revival of civic culture difficult.Charles Murray on Coming Apart
- The book deliberately does not explain what caused the decline of working-class norms—whether it is the collapse of labor unions, the rise of service economy part-time work, or feminism—because the data about the breakdown itself should be understood first before engaging in left-right political fights about causation.Charles Murray on Coming Apart
- New York City's transformation from high-crime neighborhoods in the late 1980s/1990s to a safer upper-middle-class experience demonstrates that revival of civic life is possible, contrasting with the persistent violence in Fishtown where crime remains 4.7 times higher than it was in 1960.Charles Murray on Coming Apart