
Mark Helprin on Copyright 06/29/2009
What this covers
Mark Helprin, a novelist, talks with EconTalk host Russ Roberts about his book Digital Barbarism. Roberts presses him as an economist at several points. They begin with the book's "how to live" theme, which Roberts compares to Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments. Smith also warned that gadgets and material things are false roads to serenity. The copyright argument then turns on a historical sketch. Western culture began with monasteries, church and crown licensing, and the printing press let private individuals live by selling copies. Queen Anne's statute protected that arrangement.
The economic objections get the most scrutiny. Helprin answers the present value argument, which comes from Macaulay's 1841 speech, by pointing to inheritance and to people who work for descendants and even strangers. Roberts offers counterweights. Authors' royalty is a small share of a book's price, so long copyright would not raise prices much. He also suggests readers' preference for originals may limit the feared remixing, since no one buys an altered Oliver Twist. Helprin notes that copyright already excludes plots, ideas and titles and allows parody. He adds that the European states American opponents admire protect authors' moral rights more strongly than the United States does. A Braille exemption serves as a side example of compelled, uncompensated use.
The conversation then widens. Roberts separates Hayek's price-system cooperation from the hive mind, and ties the collectivist pull to the wish to extend family norms to society. Helprin defends the Luddites as starving workers rather than machine-haters, and develops perverse adaptation through people tethered to their BlackBerries. Roberts adds a related complaint about education, where stuffing children with facts is mistaken for teaching them to think. He closes on how his own children still read.
Mark Helprin argues that copyright should be kept and even extended, mainly to protect an author's control over the integrity of the work rather than for royalties. In his view, weakening copyright in the digital age would push culture back toward an institutional model in which writers depend on patrons and lose their individual voice. He ties the anti-copyright movement to a broader collectivist 'hive mind' bias and to a 'perverse adaptation' in which humans and their works are reshaped to suit machines.
- The present-value argument (Macaulay) is false because people work for heirs and for a legacy beyond their own lives.
- Authorial control, not money, is copyright's core value; without it, anyone who can reproduce a work can alter or misattribute it.
- The Statute of Anne moved culture from institutional patronage to the self-supporting individual voice, and costless digital replication threatens to reverse that shift.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Helprin's book has a strong 'how to live' theme resembling Adam Smith's Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759). Smith warned against the false appeal of gadgetry and material things as false roads to serenity and meaning, ironic given how people usually view Smith. Roberts links this to Helprin's critique of machines and the 'acceleration of tranquility'.
“Adam Smith in the theory of moral sentiments warns against the false appeal of both gadgetry in 1759”
The semi-socialist European states that American copyright opponents admire have stronger copyright protections and much stronger authors' moral rights (droit d'auteur) than the United States.
“all the the sort of semi-socialist states in Europe that the people who are against copyright here admire have have understood this and they have stronger copyright protections and stronger... droit d'auteur”
Roberts distinguishes Hayekian cooperation from the 'hive mind'. Through the price system, people cooperate without knowing it and pool dispersed knowledge without conscious direction to produce value. That is glorious, but the people invoking a 'hive mind' mean something broader than market cooperation.
“Hayek and his insights into how people cooperate without knowing that they're cooperating with each other through the price system”
Part of the collectivist impulse reflects Hayek's insight that people want to extend the mores and norms of the family to society as a whole, an impulse that has a grip on us we have trouble shaking off.
“this desire to extend the mores and norms of the family to a to society as a whole”
'Perverse adaptation' is when we mold ourselves to the requirements of machines rather than adapting machines to us. People walking down the street thumbing BlackBerries, constantly connected, have conformed to the machine's potential and neglected the constant human needs for reflection, rest and stillness. The result is people reduced to 'bundles of tropisms'.
“This is what I call perverse adaptation. When we mold ourselves to the requirements of the machine rather than vice versa.”
The deepest value of copyright is authorial control, not money. Without legally backed control, whoever can reproduce a work can change it at will, creating a 1984-like nightmare in which anyone can attribute anything to anybody, as already happens on the internet. Helprin values his ability to say something and keep it as said far more than any royalties.
“If if you don't have control of what you write then it can be changed. And that is the most dreadful thing. It's a nightmare. It's like 1984.”
Western culture originally followed a corporate-institutional model, dependent on monasteries, the church and the state, with monks copying manuscripts and royal licenses to print. The printing press enabled a shift to the individual voice, because private persons could support themselves by selling mass-produced copies. Unauthorized reprinting threatened that living and would have pushed culture back to patronage. Queen Anne's statute protected authors' incentives, making the self-supporting individual voice a pillar of democracy.
“culture was dependent upon monasteries, the church, and the state”
People tend to model the brain on the most advanced technology of the day; now it is 'like a computer'. Because computers are loaded with code and commands, we stuff children with facts thinking it makes them smart. It doesn't: it crowds their brains without teaching them to think, and it confuses information with wisdom even though information has never been more available to a curious person.
“we often confuse information with wisdom and we often confuse the stuffing of facts into a young mind with knowledge”
The Luddites have been given a bad rap. They were not against machines in general; they were starving because power looms put them out of business, which made their reaction understandable even though they were ultimately wrong. They were also violently repressed, like the Pullman strikers.
“the Luddites were given a very poor rap. they were not against machines in general”
Copyright hardly gives absolute control. Titles, plots, ideas, concepts and processes cannot be copyrighted, so anyone can use and build on them; this must be so because there are only about 100 basic plots. Parody of a work, even one closely based on it, is also specifically excepted from copyright protection.
“You can't copyright a title. You can't copyright a plot. You can't copyright... an idea a process a concept”
By law, any written work can be reproduced in Braille or recorded editions for the blind, marketed through channels for the blind, with no royalties paid. Helprin notes the inconsistency: Congress imposed this on authors, yet ophthalmologists still charge blind patients and the government taxes blind people. He does not object to the exemption itself, but it is not a voluntary transaction.
“everything anyone writes can be used by the blind in in Braille or in recorded editions... and they they no no royalties need be paid”
Applied to literary works, perverse adaptation means opening up substance to rapid transmission, replication, storage, compression, alteration and piecing apart, just to suit machines' new capacities. Machines should instead 'tiptoe around' what is inadequately called 'content', treating it with deference: not seizing, replicating, dismantling or reconstructing it at will. More generally, we have made the machine our master rather than mastering it.
“open it up more and more to rapid transmission, replication, storage, compression, alteration, piecing apart, so as adapt to to adapt it to the new capacities of machines is perverse”
The present-value argument originates with Macaulay's 1841 speech to the House of Commons opposing a bill to extend copyright beyond the author's death; until then, copyright generally ended when the author died. Macaulay argued that Samuel Johnson would have preferred a plate of shin of beef to a posthumous extension, which would not have moved him to write one more essay, poem or bon mot.
“This is argument was first put forth by Macaulay in his famous speech to the House of Commons in 1841”
A common practical argument against extending copyright is that the present value to the author of benefits that arrive so many years in the future is so small that it cannot meaningfully affect incentives.
“an extension of the length isn't necessary because the present value of of future benefits to the author so many years in the future is so small that that that it's not practically significant”
There may be inherent market restraints on harmful alteration without copyright. Readers want the original: an altered Julius Caesar wouldn't sell under Shakespeare's name, and there are no popular alternate-ending versions of Oliver Twist. The romanticized remix may rarely happen in reality.
“There no there no versions of Oliver Twist where he uh the ending turns out differently... People want to read the original.”
Roberts suggests there are natural market restraints on altering out-of-copyright works. People want the original and would know that a rewritten Julius Caesar was not Shakespeare's. Many works, such as Oliver Twist, are out of copyright, yet no altered-ending versions circulate, so the feared remix culture may rarely materialize.
“There no there no versions of Oliver Twist where he the ending turns out differently... People want to read the original.”
Roberts' children read eagerly at night until he makes them turn off the light. He attributes this partly to his wife and him being readers and partly to allowing almost no television, with no cable. Even though the culture is destructive of reading and contemplation, individuals and families can maintain them.
“I attribute that partially to the fact that my wife and I both read, and partially the fact that we don't let them watch television”
The present-value argument is false, Helprin argues, because people, especially those past a certain age with children, work for what their descendants will enjoy, not only for their own consumption. Inheritance is recognized in every civilization across cultures for exactly this reason, so posthumous copyright does affect incentives.
“everyone who works in life works and particularly when you get past a certain age and you have children, you you are concerned with not with what you yourself enjoy, but with with the people who follow you”
Although cooperation is essential to civilization and every artist draws on a culture built by many people over thousands of years, any great, seminal or lasting artistic work essentially comes from the synthesis in one mind, heart and soul. Collaborative forms exist (movies by necessity, co-authors like Will and Ariel Durant or Collins and Lapierre, orchestras), but Mozart's concertos came from 'this one little guy'. Without the individual there is nothing, because no hive mind exists.
“anything that that of real real value that comes in an artistic sense comes out of one person, essentially”
People look beyond their own deaths to benefit even strangers, not only relatives, and not only in monetary ways. Helprin's example is someone who carefully reduces their carbon footprint for future people who will never know they did it, which contradicts Macaulay's premise that people don't care what happens after they die.
“someone who who is very assiduous about reducing what he calls his carbon footprint for the benefit of people whom he doesn't know”
Beyond envy, Roberts sees the hive-mind impulse as related to a naive romanticism about unity, such as the 'one government' idea of everyone working together, evident in the recent election. He calls this a false god: people have different goals and aspirations, and Helprin adds that forcing everyone toward one purpose means hammering dissenters into the mold, which leads to death and tyranny.
“this idea that somehow that we'd be united, which is a false god”
The standard defense of limited copyright is that after expiry, competition lowers prices and balances the monopoly, as with patents. Roberts counters that the author's royalty is a surprisingly small share of a book's price, which most people don't realize. Shakespeare's heirs still receiving royalties would therefore not raise prices much, and the price would still be limited by the demand curve.
“the royalty part of a book is surprisingly small. Most people, I think, are very unaware of that. They think that the author makes, oh, at least half of the cover price”
Opening the substance of literary and artistic works to rapid transmission, replication, storage, compression, alteration and piecing apart, in order to suit the new capacities of machines, is perverse adaptation. Machines should 'tiptoe around' what is inadequately called 'content' and treat it with deference, not seizing, replicating or reconstructing it at will.
“The machines should adapt to what they serve, not vice versa. They should be made to to in effect tiptoe around what is inadequately very inadequately called content”
Digitalization, which allows instantaneous replication at virtually no cost, threatens to move us back to the corporate-institutional model, both culturally and politically. Every writer would have to be someone's employee and pass through overseers' filters. Academic freedom shows the problem: to earn tenure one must walk down certain channels before becoming free, and Helprin argues no such universal test should gate expression.
“Digitalization... instantaneous replication at virtually no cost, threatens to move us back to the previous model, both cultural and political.”
Helprin nonetheless accepts that copyright should not be perpetual. The founders, following Queen Anne's original statute, decided that for the public benefit intellectual works cannot be locked up forever and should be protected only for a limited time as a stimulus to creation. He regards this balance between public access and creators' rights as sensible, because intellectual property differs from material property.
“the founders said for the for the benefit of the public, intellectual works cannot be locked up forever. So, we will give copyright protection in order to stimulate them, which is what Queen Anne said”
Literary copyright is not a monopoly in any sense, any more than growing a cabbage in your garden gives you a monopoly on cabbages. A real monopoly would have to cover books as a category. An author's book competes with literally millions of others, so he cannot freeze or set its price; nobody would pay $100 or $500 for his paperback when millions of others cost $15.
“It is not a monopoly in any sense of the word any more than you would have a monopoly over selling a cabbage that you grew in your garden.”
Standard author royalties are 7.5% of retail for paperbacks, 10% for most hardcovers, and 15% for established authors. Because royalties are so small, price competition after copyright expiry does not come mainly from cutting out the author's share; there is much more elasticity on the retail and publishing side.
“the normal royalty is for to the author is 7.5%... For most books hardcover it's 10% if you're established you get 15% of the retail price”
There is an asymmetry between creators and other producers. Someone who builds a flour mill, car dealership, hotel or even Google can leave ownership to heirs in perpetuity. Seventy years after an author's death, by contrast, the legal protection over everything the author built is removed and the heirs lose control and ownership.
“even for instance Google, which is a business that can be left in shares of it or ownership in perpetuity to people. And what I do because 70 years after my death... will then be removed”
Since its inception, copyright has followed a consistent pattern of longer terms and stronger enforcement, particularly in Europe but throughout the world. Helprin calls this part of 'the onward march of civilization'.
“the strengthening of copyright and the extension of it has been the pattern since its original inception. Particularly in Europe... This is part of the onward march of civilization.”
Helprin is very pessimistic that great writing is dying, replaced by the sensational and visual, and he rejects the idea that this is a short-run phenomenon. His evidence: the Sam's Club book aisle shrank to about 25% of its size within two years and holds only junk; Random House went from 12 imprints to three; and his former publishers Harcourt and Houghton Mifflin stopped publishing new books. With far fewer slots, pressure to make money drives publishers to the lowest common denominator.
“now the book aisle is now about 25% the extent of what it was 2 years ago”
Longer copyright terms change what creators make, not just how much. Knowing that they or their heirs will benefit over the long term gives authors the courage and incentive to look beyond a 10-, 20- or 30-year horizon and make lasting works, rather than flowing with the currents of fashion.
“I'll look beyond the current horizon, 10 years, 20 years, 30 years, and that I'll make something of value that's lasting. And it will give... the courage and incentive not just to flow in the currents of fashion.”
Helprin wrote speeches for politicians anonymously and without compensation, only expressing policies he had formulated himself. When the White House wanted to use parts of one speech, he refused any changes not made by him, citing copyright, since anything is copyrighted when written. Despite the power of the presidency, they could do nothing, which shows copyright protecting a weak author against a powerful institution.
“Not a single word in that speech is going to be changed unless I change it.”
At about 14, Helprin waited at the 79th Street Marina garage to ask Aristotle Onassis, then probably the richest man in the world, to donate his fortune to the United Nations; Onassis said 'No' and drove away. Helprin admits his real motive was vanity: he pictured himself being loved and worshipped at the UN for arranging it with someone else's money. He says many people's politics today stop at this adolescent stage, wanting everyone to work together so that everyone will love them for their goodness.
“I had the idea at age 14 or so that I would go to Aristotle Onassis and ask him to donate his money to the United Nations”
Copyright should be at least as long as it is now, not reduced (some opponents want it reduced to nothing), and it should even be extended further.
“I am saying that it should be at least what it is and not reduced as the opponents of copyright want it to be, and some of them even to nothing. And I'm saying it should even be extended”
The pervasive 'hive mind' and 'art is a dream of the commons' rhetoric papers over an incapacity. Helprin reads it as a confession by those who cannot create great work themselves, who therefore want a world where others cannot do it as readily and deny recognition and protection to those who can.
“I think it's pervasive because I think that what it represents is the the papering over of an incapacity.”
From an early age through university, students are taught with a bias for the collective that writing is a collaborative exercise. Helprin's children did group 'writing webs': they brainstormed, wrote, edited one another's work and then submitted it to the teacher, which he likens to a little Soviet factory floor. Critics of his op-ed wrote to him that 'we have a hive mind', reflecting a hostility toward individual rights.
“they're taught that writing is a collective exercise... They have what they call a writing web.”
The collaborative bias has moved up the channels: younger editors at newspapers, magazines and even book publishers now believe writing is collaborative and freely rewrite submissions. When Helprin started at The New Yorker in the 1960s, no one would dare change a comma without the author's consent; now newspaper pieces sometimes come back unrecognizable and badly written.
“When I first started out at the New Yorker in the in the 60s no one would dare change a comma without your consent.”
In the 1980s a magazine paid for and heavily edited a piece by Helprin, publishing it under his name so badly written that he felt shame. Using copyright, he sued; the magazine published an apology in The New York Times, paid his legal fees and a sum of money, and gave him a lifetime subscription. Without copyright, publishers would be all-powerful over writers' texts.
“I sued the magazine. They published an apology in the New York Times. They paid my legal fees.”
Shakespeare is a misleading test case: after 400 years his imprimatur is set and he is the meter stick of the English language. Works that are more current and less deeply established are far more vulnerable to being changed.
“Shakespeare has had 400 years in which the the the imprimatur has been set”
Helprin's novels Winter's Tale and A Soldier of the Great War were in hardcover print for more than 25 years. Under new pressures, the publisher moved them to print-on-demand: a buyer pays $40 and Helprin gets 30 cents, too small a share to affect the book's competitiveness.
“you will pay $40 for that book. I get 30 cents.”
The desire to hammer people into one mold seems to grow in those at the top, a danger that utopians tend to ignore.
“Besides the hammering, there's the desire to hammer, which seems to grow when you are at the top”
Helprin never wanted to be on the internet and could do without it, but must be on it because everyone else is. The fear of missing out and being left behind drives overuse, and he believes we are now way overdoing it, even though it has its uses.
“I never ever wanted to be on the internet. I can do without it, but I have to be on it because everyone else is on it.”
Roberts thinks the worries about the internet can be overdone, given glorious benefits like the quickness of communication. He acknowledges it can be destructive to the spirit: he stopped using email on his phone because he kept checking it instead of talking to his wife.
“I don't use it for email, which puts me in a very small group because I found myself checking it all the time and not talking to my wife”
We now do things far too fast and without thinking; 'life is not a video game'. The instantaneous online responses to Helprin's article illustrate this, and while speed sometimes helps, it is generally not a good thing.
“we tend to do things way too fast now... life is not a video game”
Intellectual property issues are hard to think about carefully because physical and intellectual property have important features in common but also important differences, which produces a wide range of opinions.
“they're hard issues because physical property and intellectual property have something in common and but they're also something that's different between them”
Patents are an entirely different creature from copyright. Helprin's argument covers all forms of copyright (music, art, photography, architecture) but focuses on literary works and excludes patents.
“I also mean to to extend the the my purview to all forms of copyright, although not patents, because patents are really an entirely different creature.”
The Creative Commons school holds that copyright inhibits the creation of art, and that it is a monopoly and a tax. Helprin says this school made his article a cause célèbre.
“the people of the Creative Commons school, who have been brought up to believe that copyright is actually an inhibition to the creation of of art... That it's a monopoly and then it's a tax.”
Humans are adaptive, which is how we survived and progressed, and machines present a huge adaptation challenge. They are faster, feel nothing and can do extraordinarily complex tasks we can't. Yet even the most complex machine multiplied tenfold is nothing compared to the complexity of a human being at the chemical, biochemical and mechanical levels; machines outclass us only in certain areas.
“if you take the the most complex machine that's ever been devised, and you multiply it times 10, it's... not even a a jot compared to the complexity... of a human being”
Roberts suggests the decline in serious, contemplative writing, displaced by the sensational, visual and instant, may be only a short-run cultural response to the dramatic change in access to information.
“I wonder how much of that worry which I share some of uh though maybe just a short-run phenomenon”
Helprin rejects the 'Luddite' charge. He studied communications theory in the 1960s with a former head of Bell Labs, has used PCs since 1981, and wrote Winter's Tale in great part as a meditation on the beauty of machines. Like any new power, the internet is magnificent if disciplined; the problem is abuse, distortion and complete surrender to it.
“I got my first PC in 1981”
It is ironic that advocates of world government are also, rightly, the people most hostile to the idea of empire, since the two are essentially the same thing.
“The people the people who who believe in world government are also people who who rightly are most hostile to the idea of empire.”
The standard view holds that copyright gives total control during its term and that expiration lets competitors print the work. On this view the resulting competition lowers prices, balancing the monopoly element, as with patents, against wider dissemination of the work.
“that's good uh because there's going to be competition that will lower the price, and so we're going to balance, as we do with patents, we're going to balance the monopoly part”
Despite being a Wall Street Journal columnist for 25 years, Helprin took only one economics-related course in his life, a tutorial with Tom Schelling on game theory and nuclear strategy, whom he calls a great and creative mind.
“it was a tutorial with Tom Schelling about game theory and nuclear strategy”
Rather than respond in kind on the internet, which he thought purposeless, Helprin modeled himself on Texas Ranger Frank Parker, who won about 40 gunfights by waiting for one precisely aimed shot. He spent two years writing a book as his considered answer.
“rather than respond on the internet, which was I thought was purposeless, I I very patiently wrote a book. And it took 2 years”
Shakespeare would remain open to parody even if still under copyright, as shown by Monty Python's Shakespeare sketches and 'all of Shakespeare in half an hour'. For other, less established works, however, authorial right and control are extremely important.
“Shakespeare's open would be open to parody even if it were protected by copyright.”
The intense, emotional reaction to Helprin's mild op-ed shows that copyright touches a deep cultural nerve, and the vehemence itself is a signal about current cultural currents.
“you obviously touched a deep nerve and as you observe in the book it it tells us something about the cultural currents”
Internet critics reacted to the op-ed's title without reading the article. The reaction spread 'like poison ivy, but quicker' in an uncivil way and made Helprin the villain of people who want to abolish copyright.
“the title was read by the type of person who doesn't read the article, and it spread like poison ivy, uh but quicker, on the internet”
The vehemence, anger and bile of copyright opponents is a signal about broader cultural currents. Roberts asks why Helprin finds the hive-mind ethos so threatening to creativity and property.
“how much vehemence there is, uh, on the other side, how much anger and bile and, um, and it's, um, it it's a signal. It tells us something about the world”
The New York Times titled Helprin's op-ed 'A Great Idea Lasts Forever, Why Shouldn't Its Copyright?', which misrepresented his position. Ideas cannot be copyrighted, and he has never favored perpetual copyright. He proposed an extension of perhaps 10 or 20 years, matching the last extension of 20 years, yet people who reacted only to the title cast him as the villain of the anti-copyright movement.
“I know very well that you can't copyright ideas, although a lot of people don't know that. And I was never in favor... of a perpetual copyright”
Helprin says he was more than instrumental in persuading Bob Dole to resign the Senate majority leadership and his Senate seat while running for president. He wrote Dole's resignation speech, which caught everyone's imagination and was not edited. He also wrote Dole's acceptance speech, essentially the Republican platform, in January, but campaign staff 'monkeyed with it'.
“I was, um, more than just instrumental in persuading him to resign from the Senate majority leadership and from the Senate while he was running for president.”
High politicians treat speechwriters with little respect, the way King Farouk might have treated a waiter, seeing them as mere prettifiers of what they say.
“high politicians treat speech writers sort of the way King Farouk might have have treated a waiter”
When the iPhone launched, citing a Washington Post report, people waited in line for 24 hours or more in heat and rain. Some called it a new paradigm of human existence, crowds cheered each buyer, and people exchanged addresses to discuss their iPhone experiences. Helprin calls this demeaning to human beings.
“people lined up and stayed overnight... for 24 hours or more in line to get the new iPhone”
Helprin has more than 600 copyrighted publications, with hundreds more pirated in China and elsewhere. He regards this body of copyrights as his life's legacy to his children, just as others build businesses to leave to theirs.
“I know I don't know certainly more than 600 copyrighted publications and there are hundreds which are pirated actually, you know, stolen in China”
Helprin wrote political speeches for years in 'deep anonymity,' never taking compensation and only expressing policies he himself had formulated. He was publicly identified as the writer only twice, both times by Bob Dole.
“Always from deep anonymity. Uh always without any compensation whatsoever. I never took a penny.”
Helprin says the Times had been unhappy with him for about 25 years, after he had been its darling for 10 to 15 years before that.
“The New York Times has been not happy with me for various reasons which are irrelevant here. it's been about 25 years”