present value argument
The argument that money received far in the future is worth so little today, once discounted, that extending copyright decades after death gives authors no meaningful incentive
As defined in Mark Helprin on Copyright 06/29/2009
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 2 of 2Search all claims for “present value argument” →
- The present-value argument originates with Macaulay's 1841 speech to the House of Commons opposing a bill to extend copyright beyond the author's death; until then, copyright generally ended when the author died. Macaulay argued that Samuel Johnson would have preferred a plate of shin of beef to a posthumous extension, which would not have moved him to write one more essay, poem or bon mot.Mark Helprin on Copyright 06/29/2009
- The present-value argument is false, Helprin argues, because people, especially those past a certain age with children, work for what their descendants will enjoy, not only for their own consumption. Inheritance is recognized in every civilization across cultures for exactly this reason, so posthumous copyright does affect incentives.Mark Helprin on Copyright 06/29/2009