What this covers

This EconTalk conversation pairs Michael Munger with host Russ Roberts and works through the question of profit by way of stories, some historical and some invented. One is Radford's account of a 1944 German POW camp, where prisoners with identical Red Cross parcels but different tastes drifted from gift-giving to trade. A camp Padre who bought in cheap markets and sold in dear ones stands in as the arbitrage case. Another is a fictional verger who gets rich selling tobacco from many convenient shops. The talk also reaches back to Aquinas on the just price and to an 11th-century mangere, a merchant who describes his own trade.

The range is wider than the opening argument suggests. Munger sets out the Rawls versus Nozick dispute, in which Rawls treats talents as morally arbitrary and Nozick grounds profit in ownership of oneself and one's labor. Roberts adds a Buchanan-style point that the relevant knowledge does not exist until the market process creates it. They take up the paradox of zero profits, in which the claim that no $20 bills lie on the sidewalk) depends on someone having been the first to pick one up. Munger also offers the joke as personal advice: distrust any apparent sure thing. He rejects Gordon Gekko's "greed is good" as a misreading of capitalism, which he says defends the price system and consumer choice rather than greed.

The contentious turns come with Occupy Wall Street and the 2008 crisis. Munger grants the protesters some sympathy because society confuses profits with rents, and he calls Goldman's pre-2008 gains rent-seeking from implicit government backing of creditors. Roberts presses the same point against Lloyd Blankfein's "God's work" remark. Smaller digressions include Islam's favorable view of trade, which Munger ties to Muhammad's own career as a trader, and the way people accept large gains in house prices when everyone charges the going rate.

Sharpest takeaway

Munger and Roberts argue that genuine economic profits come from correcting errors in how resources are allocated, so profits earned without fraud or coercion are evidence of value created for others. They contend that efforts to confiscate 'excess' profits fail on autonomy and entitlement grounds and destroy the information and incentives the price system provides. They distinguish these real profits from rents obtained through government privilege, such as Wall Street's implicit bailout guarantees.

  • Profit arises from spotting and fixing resource misallocations (Jobs, the Verger's tobacco shops, the POW-camp Padre), and voluntary exchange guarantees the profit is smaller than the value created
  • Rawlsian desert-based arguments for capping profits ignore that the knowledge being rewarded did not exist beforehand and is created by the market process; Nozickian entitlement plus the information role of profit tests is the better standard
  • Rent-seeking profits, like those enabled by implicit government guarantees of creditors before 2008, are indistinguishable from real profits to the investor but harmful to society; the fix is to stop making such promises

The claims · ranked60 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.86

In R.A. Radford's account of a 1944 German POW camp, where everyone received identical Red Cross parcels but had different preferences, prisoners quickly found gift-giving both undesirable and unnecessary. In Radford's words, 'goodwill developed into trading as a more equitable means of maximizing individual satisfaction'. Because exchange was repeated every month, trade proved more equitable than gifts.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“goodwill developed into trading as a more equitable means of maximizing individual satisfaction”

0.80

Thomas Aquinas, in the Summa Theologica, asked whether it is a sin to sell something for more than it is worth (the just price doctrine). Setting aside fraud, coercion, and information asymmetry, the hard case is a merchant who honestly represents his goods and makes a large profit because buyers bid against each other. Aquinas made an exception for merchants: their dealings were a region of civil life where the usual moral questions don't apply. That is only a tepid endorsement.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“Thomas Aquinas had asked in I think question 74 of Summa Theologica is it a sin to sell something for more than it is worth”

0.80

The $20-bill joke is valuable personal advice. When you think you have inside information, a bargain, or a sure-thing investment, your first thought should be that the opportunity probably isn't there: someone likely already took it, or someone is trying to sell you something by implying it exists.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“your first thought should be and really this is wonderful advice be careful it be it probably isn't there someone probably picked up that easy twenty dollar bill before you saw it”

0.80

Some sympathy with Occupy Wall Street is warranted because society has confused profits with rents. Profits come from producing something others want at a price above its cost. Rents come from investing in government policies such as protection, price floors, and barriers to entry, which may be more profitable in an accounting sense but produce nothing for society.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“we have created a society which under some circumstances has confused profits with rents so profits are what you do when you produce something that somebody else wants to buy ... rents are when you invest in government policies for protection for price floors for various entry barriers”

0.80

Banning the Padre so that A and B trade directly and keep his slice fails, because A and B cannot find each other in a large camp. Moreover, as Radford noted, the Padre's arbitrage across parts of a new camp with ununified prices drove prices together: selling where prices were high and buying where they were low. He picked up the $20 bill, after which no bill remained, and later prices were unified through a posted bulletin board.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“problem with that is a and B can't find each other in the big camp”

0.80

The key argument against nationalizing is dynamic. Profit incentives drive search for cheaper methods and new products. Decisions such as closing shops when tobacco was found harmful, or spacing shops every 12 blocks instead of every 3, are made through consumers' choices rather than central decisions. Free entry by competitors will erode the Verger's profits over time, while his 10 shops may gain Walmart-style purchasing economies of scale. All this dispersed information is solved by letting people pursue profit.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“all those decisions all that information that's dispersed is solved by letting people pursue profit”

0.80

Good defenders of capitalism do not defend greed; they defend the price system. Prices provide information about the scarcity of resources, making it easier to see how to correct mistakes, and they provide decentralized motivation. Moving a resource from a low-valued use to a higher-valued one makes the seller, the buyer, and the entrepreneur all better off. The objection 'you don't need all that profit' implies someone else already has the information about how much is needed and where resources should go.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“what we defend instead is that what the price system does is provide information about the scarcity of resources so that we can ... calculate how to correct mistakes”

0.80

The 11th-century mangere's self-description gives a timeless economic defense of the middleman. At great personal risk, including shipwreck, he brings silk, gems, gold, garments, pigment, and wine not produced locally. He does not change the goods and sells them dearer than he bought them in order to feed his family, which is exactly how an economist would defend the merchant's role.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“I ascend my ship with my merchandise and I sail over the sea ... sometimes I suffer shipwreck with the loss of all my things”

0.80

The Verger's large fortune, made in small increments from cheap, convenient tobacco with repeat business (customers walking half a block instead of four), was evidence that people valued what he provided. He made money by filling a need no one was aware of, which is a discovery, not a choice among known policy options A or B that Congress could debate.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“he had made a large amount of money on very small increments by giving people what they wanted”

0.78

The source of profits is correcting errors. The economy is full of maladjustments: divergences between what is actually produced and what a consumer-sovereignty-oriented society would produce with its existing physical capital, labor, and mental resources. That ideal allocation is unobservable and unknowable to anyone, and entrepreneurs profit by reallocating resources to produce more value than they cost.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“the source of profits is correcting errors the the economy around us is full of errors and what I mean by errors is a maladjustment the divergence between what we're actually producing and what we ... should produce”

0.78

The Padre case is fundamental to the Rawls–Nozick debate. How can redistributive taxation be justified if every individual voluntary, informed, non-coerced transaction that made a person rich also benefited the counterparties? The Padre acted as a broker between A and B, who would have gained from trading but never met. His slice must by definition be less than the total value created, because he can profit only if both A and B are made better off.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“how can there be a justification for redistributed taxation taking from the wealthy and giving to the poor if every individual transaction that made me rich actually creates benefits for the poor”

0.78

A deep point that is hard to appreciate: ex ante the relevant knowledge does not exist. As James Buchanan argued, it is the market process itself that creates the knowledge; the knowledge is not given to participants in advance.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“it's the process that creates the knowledge the knowledge is and given to the participants”

0.78

Goldman's pre-2008 gains were rent-seeking: investing in the political process to enlist the government as a cosigner on all loans ('if I win I keep it, if I lose somebody else pays'). The solution is not to claw profits back after the fact but to never make such promises. Once authorities have the power to make such deals, it is rational for firms to 'invest' in politics. From the investor's perspective rent-seeking and profits are indistinguishable, but from society's perspective they differ greatly. These perverse incentives increased misallocation rather than correcting it.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“rent-seeking basically investing in the political process in this case to enlist the government as a cosigner on all loans if I win I get to keep it if I lose somebody else will pay”

0.76

Economists care about replacement cost or market price rather than historical cost. When Roberts bought a Washington DC house, the seller was asking ten times what he had paid 25-35 years earlier. No one considered that gouging, because it was the going market price for comparable houses, which shows people accept large gains when everyone charges the same.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“the owner who had bought the house about 30 years before ... had paid 1/10 of what he was charging me”

0.76

The paradox of zero profits is that the equilibrium claim that no $20 bills lie around relies on someone having been the first to pick them up. Profit opportunities vanish only because someone notices and seizes them.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“that's the sort of paradox of zero profits right”

0.76

The paradox of zero profits: the economist claims there are no profit opportunities in equilibrium, but the reason none remain is that someone had to be the first to see and grab each one. The equilibrium argument therefore relies on the very entrepreneurs it says cannot profit.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“there has to be a first person and that's what the Economist is relying on that's the sort of paradox of zero profits”

0.73

Unlike much of Christian Europe (and to some extent Confucianism), Islam viewed trade favorably because Muhammad was a trader. This is part of why the Islamic world flourished between roughly 800 and 1200, with more trade than Europe had at the time.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Michael Munger

“Mohammed was a traitor so it was it was okay trade was okay in the Islamic world oh that's part of the reason why the Islamic world flourished for a long time between 800 and 1,200”

0.73

Counterpoint: Lloyd Blankfein of Goldman Sachs reportedly said they deserved their profits because they were 'doing God's work' allocating capital to its highest use. But trillions flowing into housing were not a highest use. Those profits likely came from public policy that let Wall Street firms borrow heavily rather than use equity, while lenders were imprudent because they expected to be repaid. Almost none of the creditors and bondholders lost money after 2008, so those profits were not well earned.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“Lloyd Blankfein who's the head of Goldman Sachs said well we're entitled to our profits because quote we're doing God's work”

0.72

Gordon Gekko's 'greed is good' speech is a mischaracterization of capitalism. Capitalism does not celebrate greed; it takes self-interest as a given and celebrates consumer sovereignty, so any defense that starts from 'greed is good' is wrong.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“capitalism does not celebrate greed capitalism takes greed as a given and celebrates consumer sovereignty so anything that starts with greed is good is wrong”

0.72

The best answer to Rawls is Robert Nozick's. Requiring that you 'deserve' rewards all the way down to primeval origins is too high and silly a standard. Instead, a liberal society adopts a presumption of personal autonomy: you own yourself and your labor unless you harm others. You may not morally deserve the profit, but you are entitled to it, because market societies accept that people who act and create value reap the reward. It is a question of ownership and property, not moral desert.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“Robert Nozick's answered to Rawls was of course it's too high a standard ... we could settle on something intermediate which is you're entitled to it”

0.72

John Rawls argued in A Theory of Justice that we do not deserve the character, effort, or intelligence that lead us to perform well. These come from parents and a genetic lottery and are morally arbitrary, so talents are in effect collectively owned. People should keep only what is necessary to motivate them to do what is good for society. This widely held view underlies policies like excess profits taxes on oil companies: 'take away half and that'll still motivate them'.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“Rawls says you got those from your parents you want a genetic lottery those are morally arbitrary we may decide that you get to keep some of it but only the only what is necessary to motivate you”

0.72

Entitlement to profit rests on the presumption that one is helping others, not just oneself. In a zero-sum world where a warrior amasses wealth by plunder, superior natural or inherited strength would not justify the gains. Justification ultimately has to come down to making other people better off.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“if life were a zero-sum game and if by engaging my skills say as a warrior I was able to amass well wealth and and goods by by plunder ... we'd say well that's not moral”

0.72

Provided there is no fraud and no coercion, a merchant's profit is prima facie evidence that he is giving a large benefit to people who voluntarily buy what he brought. He is performing a public service and should be celebrated, not tepidly tolerated.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“the fact that this man the man Kier is making profits is prima facie evidence that he's giving a huge benefit to people who are voluntarily buying the stuff that he brought back provided there's no fraud and no coercion”

0.72

Provided there is no fraud and no coercion, the fact that a trader makes profits is prima facie evidence that he is giving a large benefit to the people voluntarily buying from him. Such a trader is doing a public service and should be celebrated, not given a tepid endorsement.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“the fact that this man the man Kier is making profits is prima facie evidence that he's giving a huge benefit to people who are voluntarily buying the stuff that he brought back provided there's no fraud and no coercion”

0.71

John Stuart Mill in his 1848 Principles of Political Economy wrongly separated production from distribution. He held that production must be organized capitalistically for efficiency, but that once things exist society can distribute them however it likes. This assumes what must be proved, namely that the goods would exist regardless. Maladjustments from not letting creators capture profits will metastasize back into production and distribution decisions.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“John Stuart Mill in 1848 his principles of political economy tried to make a distinction between production and distribution”

0.70

Steve Jobs died with an estate reportedly worth about $6.6 billion, of which $4.4 billion was Disney stock from selling Pixar and only about $2.2 billion came from Apple. That fortune is a trivial fraction of the value he created through Pixar, the iPod, the iPad, and the Mac, so society captured most of the surplus. Critics who say he got too much are often reading about his death on devices that wouldn't exist without him.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Russ Roberts

“he dies in his States reportedly worth about six point six billion dollars four point four billion of that is Disney stock that he got from selling Pixar”

0.69

A consistent desert theory would say even Jobs's hard work came from character bred and raised by his parents and so should be collectively owned. Insisting on desert means nobody ever owns or deserves anything and everything becomes a collective decision. That creates two problems: incentives (constant litigation or lobbying Congress over who gets what) and information (a committee would have looked at personal computers, said nobody wants that, and turned them down).

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“insisting on desert means nobody ever owns or deserves anything and we're making collective decisions we've raised two problems with that one is the incentive problem ... the second is information”

0.69

The main argument against confiscatory (high) tax rates is not efficiency effects but power effects: the distortions from having to argue constantly about rewards. The incentive problem and the political distortion cannot really be separated.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“my main argument against confiscatory taxation ... isn't so much the efficiency effects but the power effects the distortions that that are going to occur”

0.69

Against nationalization: autonomy is a presumption, and removing it creates a world where everyone constantly has to justify their property. Crucially, subjecting the Verger to a continuing profit test reveals whether he provides a service people value above its cost; once government provides it, that information is lost.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“subjecting him to a continued profit test means that he's actually providing the service that people want”

0.69

Against nationalizing the Verger's shops: autonomy is the more persuasive objection, since otherwise everyone must constantly hire lawyers to justify their property against state power. In addition, subjecting him to a continuing profit test shows he is providing what people want at a cost below their willingness to pay. Once the government provides the service, that information is lost.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“subjecting him to a continued profit test means that he's actually providing the service that people want at a cost that's lower than the amount they're willing to for it once the government starts to provide it we no longer have that information”

0.68

The value of Jobs's ideas could not have been known in advance: he tried several times to sell his ideas about personal computers to HP, and they said 'who is ever going to buy this?'. This shows that entrepreneurial awareness detects opportunities that established firms and committees miss.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Michael Munger

“one of the articles I wrote for you some time ago he tried several times to sell his ideas about personal computers to HP and they said you're kidding”

0.66

The incentive effects of taxation are of unknown magnitude. Economists who favor low taxes often invoke large incentive effects, but there is no good evidence beyond armchair theorizing. Lowering one profession's wage clearly shifts people out of it, but if all high-skilled after-tax wages fell, it is not obvious the world would be dramatically poorer. Hedge fund managers without a billion dollars might not work much less hard.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“I think the incentive effects are of unknown magnitude economists who want to defend low rates of Taxation small levels of government will often invoke large incentive effects ... I don't think there's any good evidence for it other than our armchair theorizing”

0.65

Even if a $1 billion payout exceeds what is needed for motivation, giving the state power to allocate rewards moves us from a world of justice into a world of rent-seeking and power. There is also no workable way to pick the 'right' number or to enforce it.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“once you give the power to the state to allocate the rewards you are going to not be in the world of justice like you hope you're going to be in the world of Ren seeking and power”

0.65

Devil's-advocate challenge: once the Verger has discovered where tobacco shops belong, the government could nationalize the shops and lower prices to pass the discovery's benefit to the public. The argument is that he has already earned £100,000, is now charging more than cost, and taking only future benefits would barely discourage future entrepreneurs. Governments literally do this with alcohol.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“what we should do is we should take away his franchises and run them through the government as state owned tobacco shops and lower the price”

0.61

Per Steven Kaplan, in a recent year the top 25 hedge fund managers earned about $25 billion in total, an average of $1 billion each, in a skewed distribution where the top 5 earned more than $5 billion. The average person's reaction is that this is surely more than enough to motivate them.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Russ Roberts

“the top 25 hedge fund managers earned in total the top 25 and 25 billion in that year ... the top 5 earned more than 5 billion but the average of the top 25 was a billion apiece”

0.54

Somerset Maugham's 'The Verger' (published 1929, republished 1936 in Cosmopolitan): Foreman, a verger at St. Peter's, Neville Square, for 20 years (from age 17 to 37), was fired by a new vicar for being illiterate despite doing his job well, because it was embarrassing for the church. He then noticed a long street with no tobacconist, opened a shop with his savings, and applied a simple rule of opening where there was no tobacconist within three or four blocks. Within 15 years he had ten shops and £100,000 in profits.

normativeestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“his rule is pretty simple he can't read or write but he walks around neighborhoods and the place where there's no tobacconist for three or four blocks he opens”

0.54

Profits feel more objectionable when a seller has the only orange than when there are 40 competing sellers who all incurred costs. Under competition, sellers are seen as entitled to a profit but do not earn the monopoly-level profit, which raises the philosophical question of what anyone deserves.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“if you've got the only orange somehow it does feel different than if there's 40 armed sellers all of whom have gone to the car to the trouble of going to get them”

0.51

Because we cannot know enough to set prices right, an agnostic position means accepting that profit levels in some areas will look obscene and cannot be justified on any moral claim.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“agnostic position where we just don't know enough to set prices right means that we're often going to accept levels of profits in some areas that just look obscene and in fact cannot be justified on any sort of moral clay”

0.50

Proposals to cut out the middleman and profit are persuasive because they seem to promise lower prices. Such proposals are often bootleggers-and-Baptists coalitions: direct beneficiaries, such as smokers wanting cheaper tobacco, claim the policy serves justice or society at large.

causalestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“it's a bootleggers and Baptists argument yeah there are always the direct beneficiaries of this they're going to describe that it's good for society at large”

0.50

In Radford's POW camp, a Padre started with a tin of cheese and five cigarettes and, by buying low and selling high, returned with a complete Red Cross parcel plus his original goods. Since there was no production in the camp, he left less for everyone else, and prisoners condemned this as 'sharp practices'.

normativeestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“a Padre who started off round the camp with a tin of keys and five cigarettes and returned to his bed with a complete Red Cross parcel in addition to his original cheese and cigarette”

0.48

An entrepreneur who pays himself $3,000 a month from his business has a $3,000 profit to the accountant and the taxman. If he could earn about $5,000 as an employee elsewhere, he is actually making negative economic profit, a loss. He might stay anyway if he loves the work and has a cushion, but generally it is not a going concern.

normativeestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“an entrepreneur who starts a business and is able to pay himself a salary of say three thousand dollars ... those are negative economic profits because the ultra could have done something more valuable with his or her time”

0.47

'Desert' (with one s, from Old French 'deserte', what one merits as reward or punishment) is a different word from 'dessert' (from 'desservir', to clear the table) and from 'desert' (to abandon, from 'deserter'). The phrase is properly 'just deserts', not 'just desserts'.

definitionestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“so it's actually three different French words words for very similar English words”

0.47

The idea that The Wealth of Nations says greed is good because competition channels it toward consumers is a caricature of Adam Smith. Smith understood people to be self-interested, but he did not regard greed in its everyday sense as a virtue.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“the idea that somehow the wealth of nations is about greed being good because it gets channeled by competitions help consumers is is not a Smithee an idea it's a caricature”

0.47

The name Munger derives from the 11th-century Anglo-Saxon word 'mangere', meaning merchant of the lowest sort. It appears in a c. 1050 Psalter text, translated in Sharon Turner's 1836 three-volume history of the Anglo-Saxons, in which a merchant defensively describes his risky voyages to bring foreign goods.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“in anglo-saxon in the 11th century it was a word called mang dear ... which meant merchants of just the lowest sort”

0.47

Radford describes a Padre who toured the camp with a tin of cheese and five cigarettes and returned with a complete Red Cross parcel plus his original goods. Because there is no production, he left less for everyone else, and the camp viewed this 'sharp practice' as evil and parasitic.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“a Padre who started off round the camp with a tin of keys and five cigarettes and returned to his bed with a complete Red Cross parcel”

0.42

George Stigler told a story of University of Chicago economists who spotted an apparent arbitrage: wheat priced differently per ton in the US and England. They bought US wheat to sell in England, only to discover that a British ton is not the same as an American ton. Stigler called it 'the most expensive lunch' he ever heard of, showing that even Chicago economists fall for apparent free lunches.

normativeestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“George Stigler used to tell the story that there was this arbitrage opportunity ... only to discover that a ton and it's not the same as a ton of states”

0.40

Accounting profit is revenue minus labor and material costs. Economic profit also subtracts the opportunity-cost return on capital, including the owner's time. Zero economic profit therefore means earning exactly the next-best alternative return: with $1,000 invested and a 10% market return, a $100 accounting profit is zero economic profit.

definitionestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“for the economists you have to include in your costs the rate of return that you would get on your capital so a zero zero profit condition means that the person who's invested their money gets exactly the opportunity cost rate of return”

0.40

Work effort matters as much as gifts. Jobs's sister's eulogy chronicled his relentless work, and many gifted people don't use their gifts while many with average gifts contribute more through intensity. As Roberts's eighth-grade teacher said, it is better to have a half-gallon capacity filled to the top than a gallon capacity filled only to a quart.

normativeestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“my eighth-grade teacher Miss kaneen used to say it's better to have a 1/2 gallon capacity and fill it to the top and to have a gallon capacity to only fill it up to a quart”

0.40

In neoclassical competitive equilibrium there are no economic profits, because competition drives price down to the cost of production. To the neoclassical economist, asking 'what is the source of profit' is therefore nearly a nonsense question, yet the real economy plainly exhibits profits that matter.

definitionestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“the new classical economist would say it's a nonsense question because there's generally no such thing the only way you can have profits is a rate of return that's above the competitive rate of return”

0.39

Steve Jobs's genius with the iPod was to recognize how people wanted to buy and listen to music before they knew it themselves. He corrected a resource misallocation and profited from it, though he could have been wrong and lost money, as he was with the Apple III, which was a disaster.

normativeestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Munger

“the genius of Steve Jobs in some ways was to say here's the way people want to buy music they don't know it but if we do it we correct this mistake”

0.39

Many academic colleagues, including politically left ones, had 100% of their money in the stock market in 2007-2008 and now cannot retire because they thought it was a sure thing. People are psychologically prone to believing in sure things: claims like 'this has never gone down' or 'it averages 10% over 100 years' exploit the excitement of a free lunch.

normativeestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Munger

“how many of my colleagues themselves in some cases were quite politically left actually had a hundred percent of their money invested in the stock market in 2007-2008 and now they can't retire”

0.39

Repeated gift-giving can lock in misallocation. People who once collected themed knick-knacks keep receiving them long after losing interest, because givers treat the theme as an easy gift.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“everyone realizes oh this is easy now I can find an easy gift for them ... a person gets tired of that decides to drop the hobby ... but they keep getting those gifts”

0.36

Eating a tin of carrots when someone else would give you chocolate for it is a misallocation. The Padre only corrected such errors, so his profit-motivated activity is no justification for calling his gains prima facie evil and confiscating them.

normativecontestednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Michael Munger

“all that the Padre did was correct errors all he did was pick up the $20 bill”

0.35

Real opportunities like the Pet Rock exist but are rarely recognizable in advance; most people would have refused such a pitch. If you think you have inside information you are almost certainly wrong, and a pitch like Bernie Madoff's promise of triple returns with no risk is a lie.

normativeestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Munger

“I'm gonna leave that 20 bill 20 dollars on the ground thank you”

0.35

Jobs was motivated by profits but not solely: also by fame, commitment to an artistic vision, and many other things.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Munger

“he was motivated by profits but not solely yes he was motivated by fame yeah Fame a commitment to an artistic vision”

0.35

Hostility toward traders' profits has persisted for centuries and may be partly cultural and partly hardwired into us.

causalcontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Russ Roberts

“that attitude really hasn't changed I think I don't know where it comes from exactly it may just it some of its cultural maybe some in some dimension hardwired into us”

0.33

The 1050 mangere document is timeless because it defends a merchant exactly as a modern economist would. He is a pure middleman providing transportation, openly charging the most he can get rather than a cost-based fee.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Russ Roberts

“it's a remarkable document because it's timeless ... it's exactly the way an economist at least would defend the role of a merchant”

0.32

Guaranteeing Wall Street firms' losses so that they kept profits while the public made good on losses is hard to beat as a bad policy.

normativecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Michael Munger

“they got profits we made good on their loss it's hard to think of a worse policy”

0.30

Profits have become a bad word in public discourse, for example among Occupy Wall Street protesters, although profits have always received a mixed welcome depending on where they come from.

factualestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Munger

“profits have they've kind of become a bad word it's something that the people in Occupy Wall Street and around the country have are angry about”

0.27

Not all financial professionals today do productive things, but many hedge fund managers do something valuable.

factualcontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Michael Munger

“I'm willing to admit that people would still be hedge fund managers assuming they do something valuable which I think many of them do not all financial folks these days are doing productive things but many do”