verger
A lay assistant who helps the vicar or priest with church duties in Anglican churches.
As defined in Mike Munger on Profits, Entrepreneurship, and Storytelling 12/12/2011
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “verger” →
- The Verger's large fortune, made in small increments from cheap, convenient tobacco with repeat business (customers walking half a block instead of four), was evidence that people valued what he provided. He made money by filling a need no one was aware of, which is a discovery, not a choice among known policy options A or B that Congress could debate.Mike Munger on Profits, Entrepreneurship, and Storytelling 12/12/2011
- The key argument against nationalizing is dynamic. Profit incentives drive search for cheaper methods and new products. Decisions such as closing shops when tobacco was found harmful, or spacing shops every 12 blocks instead of every 3, are made through consumers' choices rather than central decisions. Free entry by competitors will erode the Verger's profits over time, while his 10 shops may gain Walmart-style purchasing economies of scale. All this dispersed information is solved by letting people pursue profit.Mike Munger on Profits, Entrepreneurship, and Storytelling 12/12/2011
- Against nationalizing the Verger's shops: autonomy is the more persuasive objection, since otherwise everyone must constantly hire lawyers to justify their property against state power. In addition, subjecting him to a continuing profit test shows he is providing what people want at a cost below their willingness to pay. Once the government provides the service, that information is lost.Mike Munger on Profits, Entrepreneurship, and Storytelling 12/12/2011
- Against nationalization: autonomy is a presumption, and removing it creates a world where everyone constantly has to justify their property. Crucially, subjecting the Verger to a continuing profit test reveals whether he provides a service people value above its cost; once government provides it, that information is lost.Mike Munger on Profits, Entrepreneurship, and Storytelling 12/12/2011
- Devil's-advocate challenge: once the Verger has discovered where tobacco shops belong, the government could nationalize the shops and lower prices to pass the discovery's benefit to the public. The argument is that he has already earned £100,000, is now charging more than cost, and taking only future benefits would barely discourage future entrepreneurs. Governments literally do this with alcohol.Mike Munger on Profits, Entrepreneurship, and Storytelling 12/12/2011
- Somerset Maugham's 'The Verger' (published 1929, republished 1936 in Cosmopolitan): Foreman, a verger at St. Peter's, Neville Square, for 20 years (from age 17 to 37), was fired by a new vicar for being illiterate despite doing his job well, because it was embarrassing for the church. He then noticed a long street with no tobacconist, opened a shop with his savings, and applied a simple rule of opening where there was no tobacconist within three or four blocks. Within 15 years he had ten shops and £100,000 in profits.Mike Munger on Profits, Entrepreneurship, and Storytelling 12/12/2011