Machiavelli and Hobbes ejected spirit from human nature
Plato's tripartite soul (appetite, reason, spirit) included spirit, whose ends were social goods like thumos, glory, recognition, and belonging, and antiquity through Aristotle and Christian natural law treated social participation as an end in itself; Machiavelli broke this by treating social participation merely as an instrumental means to appetite/self-preservation, and Hobbes codified it by grounding the state's legitimacy in protecting self-preservation, thereby obscuring spirit as a fundamental human end.