viewpoint diversity
The liberal educational ideal of including and civilly exchanging a range of differing opinions; Hitz argues it still celebrates the holding of opinions rather than genuine inquiry.
As defined in Zena Hitz on Lost in Thought
Other definitions
Intentional inclusion of people with diverse ideological, political, and methodological perspectives in institutions charged with truth-seeking, such as universities and media, to prevent groupthink and maintain institutional functioning
UBC Phil Lind Initiative 2023 Presents: Jonathan Haidt
Where it comes up · 7
- UBC Phil Lind Initiative 2023 Presents: Jonathan Haidt6 claims
- 119 | Musa al-Gharbi on the Value of Intellectual Diversity3 claims
- 368 - Freedom Censorship2 claims
- 431 - What Is Happening On College Campuses2 claims
- Greg Lukianoff2 claims
- Zena Hitz on Lost in Thought1 claim
- 350 - Sharing Reality1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 17Search all claims for “viewpoint diversity” →
- When records are comparable, individuals reasonably prefer hiring an ideological ally over someone they disagree with; this is a normal impulse, but when virtually everyone in a left-skewed field makes the same calculation, certain perspectives get systematically locked out of the academy even though no single decision was illegitimate.119 | Musa al-Gharbi on the Value of Intellectual Diversity
- Viewpoint diversity should be understood as an instrumental good valuable for increasing knowledge and engaging society, not as an absolute good pursued for its own sake; this implies some viewpoints legitimately fall outside its scope, though deciding which must be worked out by intellectual communities responsive to their needs.119 | Musa al-Gharbi on the Value of Intellectual Diversity
- The constitution of knowledge requires three things together: free thought/inquiry, the discipline of fact (rules governing who may claim something as fact and under what circumstances), and diversity of viewpoint—because if everyone in a room shares the same ideological and epistemic assumptions, no learning occurs since they cannot see each other's biases; the first symptom of insufficient viewpoint diversity is when everyone treats a genuinely contentious claim as not even contestable.350 - Sharing Reality
- Even liberal viewpoint diversity celebrates a false god—opinionating, the mere holding of viewpoints—because forming an opinion has little to do with inquiry; the point of learning is not settled opinion but to go down a path of inquiry to somewhere unknown, so free inquiry is more valuable than the free exchange of opinions.Zena Hitz on Lost in Thought
- Three urgent structural changes are necessary to navigate the coming chaos: (1) End closed-party primaries and replace with open primaries and final-five voting to break the power of partisan primary voters who reward extremism; (2) Restore viewpoint diversity in institutions (universities, media, government) so that institutions can function as truth-seeking rather than political machines; (3) Reform child-rearing practices and raise the age of internet adulthood to 16 to restore childhood autonomy and protect teen mental healthUBC Phil Lind Initiative 2023 Presents: Jonathan Haidt
- Replacing the single ideologically-aligned professor with co-taught classes featuring professors who fundamentally disagree (on the Cornel West / Robert George model at Princeton, now being adopted at Dartmouth) is a more intellectually healthy way to develop nimble academic minds than a model implying there are right and wrong answers to every complex moral question.368 - Freedom Censorship
- Universities should be intentional about hiring libertarians, people of strong religious faith related to their scholarship, and traditional conservatives—effectively an affirmative action program for conservatives—because lived experience and ideological diversity improve teaching and inquiry, even though this proposal angered both left and right.431 - What Is Happening On College Campuses
- Although political correctness appeared to fade as a public concern by the mid-1990s, the viewpoint diversity of professor hirings actually plummeted in the late 1990s and got much worse precisely while people had taken their eye off the ball.368 - Freedom Censorship
- People are naturally drawn to epistemic institutions (journalism, academia, social sciences, arts) if they are born with a personality predisposition toward openness to experience, which correlates with left-leaning or progressive values, creating an institutional imbalance where left-wing worldviews dominate knowledge-generating institutions and lack conservative viewpoint diversity.UBC Phil Lind Initiative 2023 Presents: Jonathan Haidt
- Universities must be institutions devoted to truth-seeking through dialogue between people with different viewpoints, not political power bases; the fundamental purpose of a university traces back to Plato's Academy and the goal of arriving at truth through dialogue, which cannot happen without viewpoint diversity.UBC Phil Lind Initiative 2023 Presents: Jonathan Haidt