Zena Hitz on Lost in Thought
What this covers
Zena Hitz, a philosopher at St. John's College, joins Russ Roberts on EconTalk to discuss her book Lost in Thought and defend learning for its own sake—the pursuit of understanding that serves no external credential, career advancement, or demonstrable return. Against the modern treatment of education as a tool for achievement and status, Hitz argues that real learning is fundamentally an inner, hidden life of inquiry that retains its value only when separated from institutional pressures and measurable outcomes. She contends that this inward practice has always been available to ordinary people, as evidenced by grassroots movements like the Mechanics' institutes, and that it remains essential to human flourishing because it equips people not just to succeed, but to endure failure and suffering with dignity.
The conversation ranges across how spectacle versus learning compete for human attention—drawing on Pascal and Augustine to explain distraction as avoidance of loneliness—and why universities, as nonprofit institutions, should protect inquiry versus opinionating rather than serve activism or political performance. Hitz argues that debate as rationalization entrenches existing views, whereas genuine conversation remains open-ended. She examines how learning as human development requires communal discipline and practice, exemplified by St. John's College's Great Books program, where tutors teach outside their expertise to sustain collaborative discovery. The discussion also explores how the particular expressing the universal in literature and autobiography enables real connection across social distance, and how seemingly unrelated pursuits—birdwatching, deep relationships, history—embody the contemplative contact with meaning that Hitz describes.
Hitz argues that learning for its own sake—open-ended inquiry into fundamental questions, pursued inwardly and often with others—is an essential, universally accessible source of human flourishing that has been corrupted by being treated as a tool for achievement, status, and political activism.
- Real learning is hidden inner inquiry whose value does not depend on visible results like money, power, or prestige
- Learning provides resources for enduring failure and suffering, not just for success
- Education focused on opinion-airing and activism crowds out the disciplined inquiry that institutions uniquely exist to protect
Being truly present and hearing another person is a powerful path to human connection and bridging division.
- Genuinely hearing someone—being present and processing rather than just taking in sounds—is a hard but powerful path to human connection, potentially a solution to a divided American moment of anger and yelling, as illustrated by Marina Abramovic's silent performance where strangers cried simply from being beheld.
“one way to get at that human connection, that's very powerful when you can find it, is just to be better at listening... I do think it is a potential solution to our current moment in America, which is a world of no listening--just anger and yelling at the other side.”
Economic thinking requires active grappling with others, not passive reception of wisdom.
- The essence of the economic way of thinking cannot be imparted as wisdom to be written down; it requires the learner to grapple, usually with other people, toward effects and consequences they won't see on their own, eventually achieving some mastery, which distinguishes classroom education from passive listening.
“The essence of the economic way of thinking requires you to grapple, usually with other people, toward answers and effects and consequences that you won't see on your own.”
Storytelling across all media forms matters more than distinguishing between media types themselves.
- What is in our actual biological DNA is storytelling, which is told across all media—books, audio, and increasingly visual forms like the Netflix mini-series—and a meaningful distinction should be drawn between surface distraction and immersive storytelling rather than between media types themselves.
“what's in our actual DNA is storytelling. And, storytelling is--we're off on a tangent here... I mean, stories are told in all kinds of ways. They're told in books. They're told in audio form”
Zena Hitz is welcomed as a guest on EconTalk.
- Zena Hitz is welcomed as a guest on EconTalk.
“Zena, welcome to EconTalk.”