vampire problem
L.A. Paul's concept that some decisions are transformative: once made, you enter a radically different state with different preferences, so your current self cannot rationally evaluate the choice in advance.
As defined in Russ Roberts and Mike Munger on Wild Problems
Other definitions
Philosopher L.A. Paul's concept that certain transformative experiences (like becoming a parent) change you in ways—including what you care about—that you cannot fully understand or evaluate beforehand.
Jessica Todd Harper on Beauty, Family, and Photography
Where it comes up · 3
- Russ Roberts and Mike Munger on Wild Problems2 claims
- Jessica Todd Harper on Beauty, Family, and Photography1 claim
- 89 - On Becoming A Better Person1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “vampire problem” →
- Some decisions are transformative in that the very act of making them changes who you are and cannot be reversed—illustrated by the 'vampire problem' of being offered immortality you can't undo—so for life-altering choices like having children, marrying, or joining the marine corps, you have no data about who your future self will be or what it will want, making such decisions genuinely hard.89 - On Becoming A Better Person
- Becoming a parent thrusts you into 'an alternate and strange world entirely predicated by your children,' transforming not just daily circumstances but what you care about and how you experience life—an instance of L.A. Paul's 'Vampire Problem' in which an experience changes the self in ways one cannot anticipate beforehand.Jessica Todd Harper on Beauty, Family, and Photography
- For transformative decisions, once you make the choice you enter a radically different state—your preferences or utility function change—so you cannot rationally evaluate the choice beforehand from your current self's perspective, which makes defining rationality very difficult.Russ Roberts and Mike Munger on Wild Problems
- The vampire problem applies to self-examination itself: once you begin contemplating how meaningless utilitarian pleasures are or how inadequate you are, you cannot return to unreflective contentment, so prescribing the examined life risks ruining the lives of those not equipped to handle it, and you can't tell who they are until after it's too late.Russ Roberts and Mike Munger on Wild Problems