Jessica Todd Harper on Beauty, Family, and Photography
What this covers
Jessica Todd Harper, an award-winning portrait photographer, joins Russ Roberts to argue that fine art photography—as distinct from the casual snapshots now universal on phones—demands a deliberate mindset, exacting technique, and sustained pursuit of timeless beauty. The conversation moves across the mechanics of the craft: the brief windows of ideal light that may last only fifteen minutes, the planning required to compose precisely around that light, and the learned ability to see like a trained artist sees. But Harper's central concern reaches beyond technique into philosophy. She contends that beauty remains essential to human flourishing, even though contemporary art has largely displaced it in favor of justice and shock value. Family and domestic life serve as her primary subjects and as a route to eternal human themes—the sacred and mundane coexisting in motherhood, the transformative violence of becoming a parent, the truth that humans are made for relationship.
The discussion ranges across several overlapping territories. Harper traces the deliberate compositional devices she uses—backlighting descended from medieval halos, the direct gaze that arrests the viewer—back through Johannes Vermeer and other masters, arguing that You Are Your Habits of looking, lodged in memory through years of museum visits and art-historical study. Roberts pushes on whether parenthood can be reconciled with happiness through a Utilitarian Calculus, drawing on L. A. Paul's Vampire Problem to capture how becoming a parent rewires what one cares about. The pair spar gently over whether Human Flourishing vs Happiness are the same thing, and whether societies should make room for beauty and art for their own sake even when they offend no one and grab no attention. Harper sketches the recurring historical tension between valuing beauty and valuing justice—from Savonarola onward—and argues that beauty is the best path into the Beauty, Truth, and Goodness Trifecta.
Harper argues that fine art photography is distinguished from snapshots by a deliberate mindset, careful technique, and a pursuit of timeless beauty, and that beauty—alongside family and relationship—remains essential to human flourishing even though contemporary art has displaced it in favor of justice and truth.
- Fine art photography requires planning, precise composition, and a different mindset than casual phone photography
- Family relationships are a durable, universal subject through which artists access eternal human themes
- Beauty is a route to the good and the true, and is worth pursuing for its own sake despite being unfashionable
Fine art photography distinguishes itself through deliberate artistic construction deployed to arrest viewers and convey meaning beyond casual documentation.
- Because anyone can press a shutter and produce an image—even a monkey could eventually get a beautiful picture, whereas a monkey could never sculpt David—people perceive a low hurdle to photography that obscures the deliberate artistic construction behind a fine art photograph.
“I could take a picture. Right?... maybe even a monkey if given enough opportunities with a camera could get a really beautiful picture--whereas a monkey is just never going to sculpt David.”
- Placing one figure who looks directly out at the viewer amid a busy domestic scene—a device used by Holbein and Vermeer—arrests and 'calls' the viewer, creating an intimacy that makes the onlooker feel part of the scene and even exposed and vulnerable, despite consciously knowing it is only a photograph.
“there's this quiet, intimate relationship happening between the viewer and one figure in the frame, which is intriguing. I'm thinking Vermeer is another good example... you feel drawn in and you feel this sense of intimacy, which as human beings we respond to.”
- Fine art photography is distinguished from ubiquitous casual family photography by its aim to belong in the art category—something people might find in a museum like a painting or sculpture—rather than serving as a casual document of family moments or practical record-keeping.
“fine art photography seeks to be in the art category. So, not just for a casual pleasure or to make documents of family moments or copies of receipts, the way that we use our phones every day, but it seeks to be something that people might find in a museum like a painting or a sculpture.”
- The cover image deploys classical compositional and art-historical techniques—a triangular composition from head to elbow to baby's head, a star in the window referencing hope, and backlighting that descends from the medieval halo—to direct the viewer's eye, signal that something important and holy is happening, and convey multiple simultaneous emotions of tenderness and isolation.
“if your eye goes from the head down to the elbow and then across to the baby's head and then the baby's arm gestures back up again, it forms this triangle shape, which is a very classical compositional technique... that backlight is worth it because it helps contribute to this feeling of etherealness. And, I think we get that in the Western tradition from the use of the halo.”
- A photographer's relationship to imagery is like a writer's to words: a writer composes many emails and texts daily but with a different mindset than when writing a novel, just as a photographer uses imagery every day but shifts to a distinct mindset when composing for fine art.
“a writer uses email all the time. Probably composes many, many emails or even texts every day. But, that's not necessarily what he's going to put into his novel... when I'm composing for fine art purposes, it's with a different mindset.”
- The cover photo deliberately captures a duality of motherhood—the awe-inspiring, transcendent sense of new life alongside the mundane reality of exhaustion, diapers, and crying—because to be alive is to navigate both our eternal selves and the quotidian, akin to Augustine's City of God and City of Man.
“ideally, we remember our eternal selves, our immortal selves, the part that can be much bigger than ourselves. But, we also are rooted in the quotidian... isn't it St. Augustine who talks about the City of God and the City of man--this idea that you have to navigate both.”
Human beings are fundamentally relational creatures made for connection, a truth Harper's intergenerational work captures across the full cycle of life.
- Harper's body of work spans the full cycle of life—births of children alongside images of grandparents on their deathbeds—reflecting an upbringing in which death and dying were openly discussed, and aims to build an intergenerational, Tolstoy-like narrative whose meaning will outlast her own lifetime.
“there's a picture of my grandmother within 24 hours of her dying, and my children are standing at her bed. So, there are these incredible life passages that are happening, not just births of children, but the end of life is referenced, too.”
- Drawing on Genesis—where the only thing called 'not good' in creation is for Adam to be alone—Harper argues that human beings are made for relationship, a truth felt acutely during the pandemic when isolation cut people off from family and the casual interactions that form the fabric of life.
“the only thing that wasn't good in all of creation and that whole narrative is when, after He creates Adam, He says, 'It is not good for Adam to be alone.'... during the pandemic, I think we really felt that acutely it wasn't good for us to be isolated, to be alone.”
- Storytelling is a fundamental way humans understand their own existence—from The Odyssey onward—and narrative shapes the way we perceive reality, which is why Harper, raised among family storytellers, is drawn to capturing the relationships that bind families.
“I was always very interested in the way that narrative shaped the way that we perceived reality... back to The Odyssey and forward, humans love storytelling as a way to understand their own existence.”
- Harper deliberately captures the theme of being 'together but alone'—as in a birthday party where children are in close proximity yet each absorbed in their own thoughts—because human beings, including children, are ultimately creatures of their own minds, a subject rarely considered when photographing children.
“that is a theme that has always interested me: the sense of being together, but alone... they're in close proximity with each other, but at the end of the day, we're all alone with our own thoughts. We're creatures of our minds.”
- Like marriage, parenthood is best understood not through a utilitarian opportunity-set frame as enslavement but as a liberation: institutions society wisely built to check humanity's strongest impulse—selfishness—because focusing first on another's needs, rather than on getting what we want, counterintuitively produces human flourishing.
“society over the years, in its wisdom, has constructed a lot of institutions which check those impulses. Marriage, I would say being one of them. It helps you to be less selfish. And parenthood just continues in that same vein... It forces you to think about somebody else's needs first. And I believe, fundamentally, that makes you happier. It contributes to human flourishing”
Beauty is the highest route to truth and goodness; art for art's sake and beauty itself deserve space in society regardless of utility or justice outcomes.
- Humanity yearns for the eternal, and when art works it references that yearning—remaining relevant and moving even 500 years later to people who don't know the artist—which is what gives fine art its timelessness, captured in the maxim 'ars longa, vita brevis.'
“I think that humanity leans toward a yearning for the eternal. And, when art works, it references that: It's relevant even 500 years later. It's moving to people who don't know the artist.”
- Among the trifecta of beauty, truth, and goodness, beauty is the best route to knowing the other two—'if you know what is beautiful, then you can define what is good and true'—so judging art solely by whether it advances justice or societal goodness wrongly excludes nourishing, inspiring work, like a Klimt or Vermeer, that is simply beautiful.
“the best way to know about what is good and what is true is actually to get sorted what is beautiful. Because if you know what is beautiful, then you can define what is good and true.”
- Meeting everyone's material needs does not by itself produce human flourishing—the Soviet Union housed and fed everyone yet was not an environment of flourishing—so societies must leave room for art for art's sake and beauty for beauty's sake, even at the risk that such work offends or fails to grab attention.
“If you think of the Soviet Union, everybody is fed, everybody is housed. But it's not an environment of human flourishing... it's not enough, somehow, for human flourishing--for what we really need as human beings.”
- The present devaluation of beauty is not unprecedented: history shows recurring tension between valuing the beautiful and valuing justice, truth, or goodness—exemplified by Savonarola's bonfire of the vanities and the Reformation's stripping of church ornament, both reactions against beauty's entanglement with concentrated wealth and power.
“this isn't the first time that there's been a tension between valuing things that are beautiful and valuing other concerns of justice or truth or what is good... we know it as the bonfire of the vanities... in the Reformation this emphasis on holy spaces: churches were meant to not have any ornament.”
A photographer's visual literacy and compositional skill derive from lifelong exposure to images and disciplined training in art history and medium constraints.
- Growing up in the film era—where each shot was expensive and a good medium-format camera gave only 12 exposures—trains a photographer to compose the picture beforehand, shoot full frame without planning to crop, and be very precise, a discipline that carries over even into digital work.
“I grew up in the film era when that would've been very expensive and you had to train your eye to be very precise and careful. My early teachers were always emphasizing to compose the picture beforehand: Shoot full frame, which means you don't plan on cropping it afterward.”
- Because, as Aristotle held, you are your habits and become what you do, a lifetime of looking at images—dragged to museums as a child, majoring in art history—lodges those images in the brain and informs how an artist sees, allowing Harper to compose quickly with art-historical precedents like Modigliani or Wyeth at her fingertips.
“I just always think of Aristotle, who says, 'You are your habits.'... So, these images that I've been looking at for years and years and years are just lodged in my brain and they informed the way that I see things.”
- Americans spend twelve years learning to decode text and detect an author's slant and bias, but receive almost no art education or instruction in reading images and visual language, which makes it alien for people to recognize that an image is a construction with a particular agenda and slant.
“in America in particular, in our education, we have 12 years devoted to how to interpret texts. We call it reading... Photography is the same way. And, we don't have any art education. There's no art history in schools, in mainstream education. There is no careful instruction on how to read images”
- Photography was invented in 1839 simultaneously in England, by aristocrat William Henry Fox Talbot who presented it scientifically as the 'Pencil of Nature,' and in France, by Daguerre, whose daguerreotype was a unique silvery image viewed at an angle and who approached it with a commercial mindset.
“It was invented in 1839, both in France and England at the same time. The English gentleman who invented it was William Henry Fox Talbot... in France, Daguerre invented the daguerreotype”
Capturing fine art photography requires extensive logistical planning, rapport with subjects, and quick execution within narrow windows of ideal light.
- Backlighting is technically difficult to expose correctly because it requires capturing very bright and very dark areas simultaneously; film could do this for a long time while early digital photography could not, forcing a choice between highlights and shadows—a limitation now overcome by shooting multiple exposures and combining them in Photoshop.
“film is able to expose very bright areas and very dark areas at the same time. And for a long time, digital photography couldn't do that. You had to choose one or the other... I took multiple exposures that I could sew together in Photoshop afterwards”
- Most adults being photographed are anxious about their appearance, so the photographer's job is to make them feel comfortable and safe—akin to being a good hostess or leader—because only when subjects feel taken care of and confident in the photographer do they open up and reveal themselves.
“my job is to make them feel comfortable. It's akin to being a good hostess, a good leader. If you're confident and you set the tone that you know what you're doing and that they're in good hands and that they're safe, then they open up to you.”
- When commissioned to photograph a family, Harper finds that about 90% of people—even curators and art-world professionals—do not know when the light is good in their own home, so she has them photograph the light with smartphones over time and maps out furniture, outfits, and timing in advance.
“I'd say 90% of the time, people don't know when the light is good in their house. Even curators--even art world people who have hired me to take pictures of their family don't know.”
- A photographer must work quickly and efficiently because subjects—especially children—can only sustain a moment for so long, and taking too long causes the loss of the moment's veracity, just as a child taken shopping reaches a limit and is done.
“you lose the veracity of the moment if you take too long. As any parent who's taken a child shopping for shoes or anything would know. You only have a limited time, and then they're done.”
- Capturing a fine art photograph requires extensive logistical planning around a brief window of good light—checking weather forecasts, setting the camera on a tripod with a timer, framing precisely, removing distracting clutter, and timing a subject's schedule—because the ideal light may last only about 15 minutes.
“I noticed the light in my bedroom was really good at 2:30 in the afternoon in January... it was gone within 15 minutes. And so, I knew that I had to plan for this picture to happen... by the third day, I had my camera on a tripod, and I had the framing set up”
- When given only 10-15 minutes at 6 AM with no advance access to photograph Sheryl Sandberg, Harper improvised with her assistant and lights, and the published image captured Sandberg on her laptop emailing—using the lines of her fingers, the chair's shape, and the background to create a working synergy—illustrating that each constrained opportunity is a new problem to solve.
“I was hired to photograph Sheryl Sandberg and I had about 10, 15 minutes in her home at 6:00 AM... the way that the lines were with her fingers and the shape of the chair and the background, there was a synergy that worked.”
Unfamiliar genres of art appear empty or simple until repeated exposure and discussion reveal their depth and meaning.
- Like poetry, classical music, jazz, or hip hop, a genre of art one is unfamiliar with at first seems boring or simplistic ('I don't get it'), but repeated exposure, discussion with others, and practice progressively reveal more meaning—so the perceived emptiness reflects the viewer's inexperience rather than the work's lack of depth.
“the more practice I have in being familiar with reading poems, the better I understand them. And, it's true of classical music, too... any genre that you're not familiar with at first might just sound boring.”
- Even a precise photographer who does not shoot hundreds of frames produces many bad pictures nobody sees; the public only consumes the best ones, so apparent consistent excellence partly reflects selection.
“the pictures that the public consumes are the best ones, and there are many bad ones that nobody sees.”