value-added model
A teacher-evaluation method that scores teachers by the difference between their students' actual test results and the scores a background model predicted those students should achieve.
As defined in Cathy O'Neil on Weapons of Math Destruction
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “value-added model” →
- The teacher value-added model scores teachers 0-100 by comparing students' actual test results to a background model's expected scores; but because that underlying expectation model is inaccurate, the teacher is effectively held accountable for the average error term—the noise—of a bad model, producing scores so inconsistent (one teacher scored 6 then 96 in consecutive years) that they are meaningless yet used for high-stakes tenure and firing decisions.Cathy O'Neil on Weapons of Math Destruction
- Sarah Wysocki, a Washington D.C. teacher, was fired over a bad value-added score that she had good reason to believe was caused by a previous teacher cheating to inflate her incoming students' test scores (driven by a bonus), illustrating how scores too inaccurate for high-stakes use can nonetheless end careers.Cathy O'Neil on Weapons of Math Destruction
- A Stuyvesant math teacher graphed the published value-added scores of hundreds of teachers who appeared twice (e.g., teaching 7th and 8th grade math) and found the correlation between a teacher's own two scores was only about 24%—a scatter resembling a uniform distribution rather than the y=x line you'd expect—demonstrating the scores carry little reliable information yet drive tenure decisions.Cathy O'Neil on Weapons of Math Destruction
- While the value-added model is a horrific, falsely-objective way to evaluate teachers, the entrenched public school system also makes it nearly impossible to fire genuinely bad teachers, so the tragedy is that there isn't a good alternative within the current system; we are stuck using objective, un-gameable-seeming things like test scores precisely because they can be defended.Cathy O'Neil on Weapons of Math Destruction