causal

Value-Added Teacher Scores Are Statistical Noise

The teacher value-added model scores teachers 0-100 by comparing students' actual test results to a background model's expected scores; but because that underlying expectation model is inaccurate, the teacher is effectively held accountable for the average error term—the noise—of a bad model, producing scores so inconsistent (one teacher scored 6 then 96 in consecutive years) that they are meaningless yet used for high-stakes tenure and firing decisions.

causalpending

Speaker

Cathy O'Neil

Evidence Quote

“He got a 6 out of 100... the first time he got a value added model. Terrible score. He got a 96 the next year.”

Source

Cathy O'Neil on Weapons of Math Destruction— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:25:42 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...