What this covers

This is a single-speaker interview in which Peter Singer, co-founder of the Journal of Controversial Ideas, explains the reasoning behind that project. He follows John Stewart Mill in holding that even a true view has to be open to challenge, or its holders forget why it is true and how objections are answered. He backs this with a historical pattern: societies once certain that one race was entitled to rule another, that same-sex relations were an abomination, or that the sun circles the earth persecuted dissenters, and those beliefs survived longer because they were shielded from criticism. He also takes up the argument for keeping some ideas hidden, and answers that suppression leaves the ideas in circulation without anyone learning how to rebut them.

The central case study is Jeremy Bentham. In the early nineteenth century the founder of utilitarianism wrote essays arguing that consensual same-sex relations harm no one and should not be criminal. He left them unpublished, fearing they would discredit his work on prison reform, ending the slave trade, and universal suffrage. They appeared only in this century. Singer suggests that open debate then could have spared gay people decades of repression.

The later sections turn contemporary and more contested. Singer says university administrations have been weak on academic freedom, tending to follow Twitter storms against professors. He also says that "gender critical" feminists raise concerns about women-only spaces that have some empirical basis. A segment on end-of-life choice includes his point that the Nazi "euthanasia" program was not genuine euthanasia, since it served a racial ideology and not suffering people.

Sharpest takeaway

Freedom of thought and expression is essential for discovering truth and improving society, and we must protect controversial ideas even when they cause discomfort, because suppressing debate prevents understanding of both false and true beliefs.

  • We can never know for certain when we are mistaken, so preventing critical examination of our beliefs blocks discovery of which are false
  • Even true beliefs lose their strength if not challenged, because we fail to understand why they are true and how to defend them against objections
  • Suppressing controversial ideas doesn't eliminate them—it prevents the open discourse needed to effectively refute bad arguments

The claims · ranked74 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

If society had been more open to controversial ideas about same-sex relationships and had debates about them in Bentham's time, many decades of repression and discrimination against gays could have been avoided.

forecasthigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“Maybe if they had been more open to controversial ideas and they'd had debates about that, then many decades of repression and discrimination against gays could have been avoided.”

0.80

Suppression of discussion of an issue does not make the issue disappear—people will still think these things and some people will say these things, and because there is no open discussion, there won't be any good understanding of how best to refute what people have said.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“the importance of the fact that an issue doesn't disappear if you suppress discussion about it, people will still think these things and some people will say these things and because there is no open discussion, there won't be any good understanding of how best to refute the things that people have said.”

0.80

We can never know for sure when we are mistaken, therefore if we prevent beliefs from being critically examined and scrutinized, we will not discover which of our beliefs are false and which are true.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“One is, we can never know for sure when we are mistaken. There have been such a lot of beliefs that people have been certain of and persecuted people who oppose them that we now regard as false.”

0.78

Jeremy Bentham never published his essays attacking the criminalization of same-sex relationships because he feared that publication would discredit him and damage other utilitarian causes he supported like prison reform, ending the slave trade, and universal suffrage.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“But Bentham never published those papers because he felt that to publish them at that time would've brought discredit on all of the other things that he and the early English utilitarians wanted to do. For example, prison reform, for example, ending the slave trade, for example, bringing about a universal suffrage so that instead of just wealthy property owners voting, everybody could vote. So those essays remain unpublished until this century.”

0.74

The Nazi euthanasia program was not genuine euthanasia because it was not for the benefit of people who were suffering or severely disabled, but rather to remove people seen as a blot on the Aryan folk.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“And the Nazis had a so-called euthanasia program for dealing with people who were mentally ill. But it wasn't really euthanasia. It wasn't for the benefit of people who were suffering or so severely disabled that they could not enjoy life at all. It was rather to remove people who were seen as a blot on the Aryan folk.”

0.74

Historically, there have been societies that believed the white race was entitled to rule over the black race, that sexual relations between people of the same sex were an abomination, that the earth is the center of the universe with the sun revolving around it, and these beliefs were persecuted against those who opposed them, but are now regarded as false.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“Obviously, there were societies that believed that the white race was entitled to rule over the black race. There've been societies that believed that sexual relations between people of the same sex were an abomination. And in fact, there still are some societies that believe that. And people who do practice that should be killed... There are times that have believed a whole lot of false factual information, such as the idea that the earth is the center of the universe and the sun revolves around the earth. And the Roman Catholic Church persecuted people for rejecting that belief.”

0.74

Freedom of thought and expression is a very important basic good for any society that hopes to progress, improve the world's situation, and progress in knowledge and understanding of what is true.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“I believe very strongly that freedom of thought and expression is a very important basic good for any society that hopes to progress, that hopes to improve the world's situation, and hopes also to progress in knowledge and understanding of what is true.”

0.74

We should try to make ourselves more comfortable with controversial ideas because it's important that those ideas be discussed, and it's important to be on the side of finding out the truth rather than protecting what we think is truth behind a shield so it can't be challenged.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“We should try to make ourselves more comfortable with controversial ideas because it's important that those ideas be discussed. It's important to be on the side of finding out the truth and not of protecting what we think is the truth behind some kind of shield so that it can't be challenged.”

0.74

In the early 19th century, Jeremy Bentham, the founder of the Utilitarian School, wrote essays strongly attacking the idea that it should be a crime for anyone to have sex with someone of their own sex, arguing as a utilitarian that this experience is enjoyable for consenting adults and does no harm to anyone else.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“Let's go back to the example of same-sex relationships In the early 19th century, Jeremy Bentham, the founder of the Utilitarian School, wrote essays strongly attacking the idea that it should be a crime for anyone to have sex with someone of their own sex. He argued as a utilitarian would that this experience is enjoyable for the consenting adult parties involved and does no harm to anyone else.”

0.74

Bentham's essays on same-sex relationships remained unpublished until this century.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“So those essays remain unpublished until this century.”

0.74

Freedom of thought and expression is a basic good necessary for any society that hopes to progress, improve the world's situation, and advance knowledge and understanding of what is true.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“I believe very strongly that freedom of thought and expression is a very important basic good for any society that hopes to progress, that hopes to improve the world's situation, and hopes also to progress in knowledge and understanding of what is true.”

0.74

We can never know for sure when we are mistaken, so if we prevent beliefs from being critically examined and scrutinized, we cannot discover which of our beliefs are false and which are true.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“One is, we can never know for sure when we are mistaken. There have been such a lot of beliefs that people have been certain of and persecuted people who oppose them that we now regard as false.”

0.73

Even if beliefs we hold are true, if we prevent people challenging those beliefs we will lose our understanding of why they are true and how they would meet objections, because by preventing objections we don't understand how the objections are refuted.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“Even if there are beliefs that we hold that are true, if we prevent people challenging those beliefs, we will lose our understanding of why they're true and how they would in fact meet objections that might be made to them. Because by preventing people making those objections, we don't understand how the objections are refuted.”

0.70

Looking at past history shows that many people have firmly believed ideas that turned out to be false, and they put up shields against anybody criticizing those ideas, causing those ideas to hang on much longer because they were unable to be criticized.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“Because again, looking at past history, we know that many people have very firmly believed ideas that have turned out to be false and they have put up shields against anybody criticizing those ideas. And those ideas hung on a lot longer because they were not able to be criticized.”

0.70

Bentham never published his essays attacking the criminalization of same-sex relationships because he felt that publishing them would bring discredit on all the other things he and early English utilitarians wanted to do, such as prison reform, ending the slave trade, and universal suffrage.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“But Bentham never published those papers because he felt that to publish them at that time would've brought discredit on all of the other things that he and the early English utilitarians wanted to do. For example, prison reform, for example, ending the slave trade, for example, bringing about a universal suffrage so that instead of just wealthy property owners voting, everybody could vote.”

0.68

University administrations have been weak in standing up to defend academic freedom, instead following Twitter storms of protest against their professors for controversial statements.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“It seems like university administrations have been very weak in standing up to defend academic freedom. And the idea of university administrations following a Twitter storm of protest against one of their professors having said something seemed to us to be completely wrong.”

0.68

Open debate about controversial issues is important and issues do not disappear through suppression—instead, suppressed issues persist among people without good understanding of how to refute the arguments, whereas open discussion allows for effective rebuttals.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“But against that, we weigh the importance of having an open debate on issues and the importance of the fact that an issue doesn't disappear if you suppress discussion about it, people will still think these things and some people will say these things and because there is no open discussion, there won't be any good understanding of how best to refute the things that people have said.”

0.68

Historical evidence shows that many people have firmly believed ideas that turned out to be false and put up shields against criticism, which caused those false ideas to persist longer than they would have if they had been openly criticized.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“Because again, looking at past history, we know that many people have very firmly believed ideas that have turned out to be false and they have put up shields against anybody criticizing those ideas. And those ideas hung on a lot longer because they were not able to be criticized.”

0.68

Jeremy Bentham, founder of Utilitarianism, wrote essays in the early 19th century strongly attacking the idea that sexual relations between people of the same sex should be a crime, arguing from utilitarian principles that consensual same-sex experience is enjoyable and harms no one.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“Let's go back to the example of same-sex relationships In the early 19th century, Jeremy Bentham, the founder of the Utilitarian School, wrote essays strongly attacking the idea that it should be a crime for anyone to have sex with someone of their own sex. He argued as a utilitarian would that this experience is enjoyable for the consenting adult parties involved and does no harm to anyone else.”

0.68

Even if a belief is true, if we prevent people from challenging it, we lose our understanding of why it is true and how it would meet and refute objections, making the belief fragile and less defensible.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“There's also a second reason why it's really important for us to allow freedom of thought and discussion. Even if there are beliefs that we hold that are true, if we prevent people challenging those beliefs, we will lose our understanding of why they're true and how they would in fact meet objections that might be made to them.”

0.68

Historically, societies have held beliefs they were certain of and persecuted those who opposed them, later recognizing those beliefs as false—including beliefs about racial hierarchy, same-sex relationships being immoral, and geocentrism.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“There have been such a lot of beliefs that people have been certain of and persecuted people who oppose them that we now regard as false. Obviously, there were societies that believed that the white race was entitled to rule over the black race. There've been societies that believed that sexual relations between people of the same sex were an abomination.”

0.66

Peter Singer and the Journal of Controversial Ideas adhere to John Stewart Mill's view that to understand a view, even if it's true, you must allow it to be challenged and know how those challenges should be met.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“We stick by the view that John Stewart Mill put forward, that, "If you want to understand a view, even if it's true, you have to allow it to be challenged and you have to know how those challenges should be met."”

0.62

Some women have feminist concerns about shared spaces with trans women who have not changed their biology, believing such individuals are more likely to sexually assault them based on concerns about male biology including testosterone levels, and this feminist case has some empirical basis.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“There are the concerns of some women, of... A feminist concern, if you like, that some women want to have spaces where there are only women, and by only women they mean people without a penis and testicles and people without that male biology, which they may have more testosterone circulating in their body, and they believe that such individuals are more likely to sexually assault them. And again, that's a claim that has some empirical basis.”

0.62

There are legitimate feminist concerns from 'gender critical' feminists about women having access to spaces designated for women, defined as spaces where only biological women (without male biology including testosterone-related advantages) are present, based on concerns about sexual assault by individuals with male biology.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“There are the concerns of some women, of... A feminist concern, if you like, that some women want to have spaces where there are only women, and by only women they mean people without a penis and testicles and people without that male biology, which they may have more testosterone circulating in their body, and they believe that such individuals are more likely to sexually assault them. And again, that's a claim that has some empirical basis.”

0.60

John Stuart Mill's principle is that to understand a view, even if it is true, you must allow it to be challenged and know how those challenges should be met.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“We stick by the view that John Stewart Mill put forward, that, 'If you want to understand a view, even if it's true, you have to allow it to be challenged and you have to know how those challenges should be met.'”

0.56

Critics of the Journal of Controversial Ideas argue that publishing certain articles will harm disadvantaged or marginalized groups, particularly in the case of transgender issues.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“The argument is mostly put against the controversial articles that we receive that they're going to harm disadvantaged or marginalized groups. And you know, there are a number of fields of articles that are controversial, but perhaps the one that we've received the most articles submitted to us has been about transgender issues.”

0.56

Critics argue that publishing articles emphasizing the significance of biological sex in the transgender debate—such as articles claiming someone is 'really' a woman only if their biological sex changes, not if they identify as a woman—is harmful to trans women because it attacks their self-identity and they are a vulnerable group with higher rates of depression and suicide.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“And the argument here is that if we publish articles which emphasize the significance of biological sex and which say, for example, that somebody is only really a woman if their biological sex changes and not if they identify as a woman, even though they are unchanged in terms of their male biology, that that is harmful to trans women who have chosen not to change their biology, that it attacks their self identity and self identity is very important and that they are very much a vulnerable group, both in terms of being discriminated against and attacked by many people, but also in terms of having a higher rate of depression and suicide than other groups.”

0.56

Trans people are vulnerable, discriminated against, have difficulty, and some will be upset reading articles in the Journal of Controversial Ideas that question transgender identities, though reading is not coerced.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“Now we take all of those concerns seriously. I think it's absolutely true that trans people are vulnerable, that they're discriminated against, that they have a hard time of it, and that they... Some of them will be upset if they read some of the articles in our journal. Now of course, there was no coercion to read any articles in our journal, but possibly simply knowing that such articles are published may disturb them.”

0.55

Gender-critical feminists argue that merely changing identification is not enough to make someone who is biologically male count as a woman in every respect, and this case should be heard even if it is contested.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“the so-called gender critical feminists who argue against the idea that merely changing your identification, I mean, the choice of identification is enough to make someone who is biologically male count as a woman in every respect, have some kind of case that... We think we're not saying that case is necessarily right, but we think it's better that that case be heard and that people who want to defend the idea of self-identification and the gender issue should then refute the arguments.”

0.54

In other countries, doctors treating severely ill newborns needing life support approach parents to discuss whether to continue treatment, describing the poor prognosis, offering the option to withdraw support and ensure comfortable death, and many parents exercise this choice.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Peter Singer

“In other countries, it's not exactly that that's happening. But on the other hand, doctors who are treating a baby who needs life support and who also has a very poor prognosis, will go to the parents and ask the parents if they wish to have life support continued. And they will describe the prognosis for the child and say, 'You might think it's better for your child that we withdraw treatment, the child will then die and we can make the child comfortable while the child dies.' And many parents given that choice, exercise it.”

0.52

Journal editors have rejected well-reviewed articles as 'too sensitive' after external events changed the political climate, such as when an article about blackface usage was nearly accepted but then rejected after George Floyd's murder because the issue became more politically sensitive.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“the journal editors discovered that they're too sensitive. In one case, there was an article which was about racial issues, which had been... Was very close to being accepted by a journal. It had good peer reviews and seemed well on the way to being accepted. And then George Floyd was murdered. And with the murder of George Floyd, of course, there was a whole lot more activity protesting against the murder of Floyd and also protesting against other police killings of blacks and in general, making the treatment of blacks much more sensitive. And the editor of this journal decided that even though the article had been well reviewed, they would not publish it because of the more sensitive climate.”

0.52

Peter Singer believes his views on end-of-life ethics may have had some influence in making doctors more willing to discuss withdrawal of life support with parents and ensure humane death for children with poor prognosis.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“And I think perhaps my views have had some influence in making doctors more willing to do that, more open to discussing it with the parents and then to removing life support and ensuring a humane death for a child whose future was going to be very bleak.”

0.52

The Journal of Controversial Ideas accepts peer-reviewed articles anonymously if authors do not want to publish under their own name, and will acknowledge them as authors later if the climate changes.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“we review the papers sent to us, we get them sent in an anonymous form and have them reviewed anonymously. So people are not biased in favor of, you know, people they who may have reputations they know, and then publish good articles. And if the authors did not want to put their name on it, usually authors do wanna put their names on articles and academic journals. And in fact, we didn't know of any academic journals that would allow people to publish anonymously. But we said if they didn't want to publish under their own name, we would accept anonymous publication.”

0.52

Multiple articles in the Journal of Controversial Ideas have been rejected by other journals not because they weren't well-argued, but because they were politically controversial.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“that's now happened with a number of articles in the Journal of Controversial Ideas that they had been rejected by other journals, not because they weren't well argued, but because they were politically controversial.”

0.52

The Journal of Controversial Ideas uses anonymous peer review, where papers are sent in anonymous form, reviewed anonymously, and published anonymously if the author wishes—an innovation designed to remove bias from the review process and protect authors from social backlash.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“So we thought it would be good to have a journal, which was an academic journal, which means that we review the papers sent to us, we get them sent in an anonymous form and have them reviewed anonymously. So people are not biased in favor of, you know, people they who may have reputations they know, and then publish good articles. And if the authors did not want to put their name on it, usually authors do wanna put their names on articles and academic journals.”

0.52

The Journal of Controversial Ideas has discovered that an important function beyond anonymity is publishing papers whose authors are happy to be named but which journal editors from other outlets reject as 'too sensitive,' even if the papers have been well peer-reviewed and accepted by reviewers.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“we've discovered that there's something else important that we're doing. And that is we're publishing papers where the author is quite happy to have their name attached to it, but the journal editors don't wanna publish them. The journal editors, even sometimes after they've been peer reviewed and have had good reviews, the journal editors discovered that they're too sensitive.”

0.52

We should try to make ourselves more comfortable with controversial ideas because it is important that those ideas be discussed openly and because finding out the truth is more important than protecting beliefs we think are true from challenge.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“We should try to make ourselves more comfortable with controversial ideas because it's important that those ideas be discussed. It's important to be on the side of finding out the truth and not of protecting what we think is the truth behind some kind of shield so that it can't be challenged.”

0.52

If the society had been more open to controversial ideas and debates about same-sex relationships in the 19th century, many decades of repression and discrimination against gays could have been avoided.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“And you know, that's an example of something that people firmly believed in and did not allow a real debate. Maybe if they had been more open to controversial ideas and they'd had debates about that, then many decades of repression and discrimination against gays could have been avoided.”

0.50

Discussion of end-of-life choice for severely disabled newborns is now more open in some countries, and in the Netherlands medical organizations have accepted protocols allowing doctors in carefully circumscribed cases to actively end the life of severely disabled newborns in pain with parental consent.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Peter Singer

“Now I think that discussion is a little more open now in that in some countries it is being discussed. And in fact, in the Netherlands there are protocols that medical organizations have accepted, which allow doctors in a very carefully circumscribed number of cases, and there've been only really a handful of cases, to do that, to actively end the life of a very severely disabled newborn, especially one who was in pain with the consent on the... With the wishes of the parents.”

0.48

The Journal of Controversial Ideas was founded by Peter Singer, Francesca Minerva, and Jeff McMahon because all three were troubled by the narrowing climate of ideas that could be openly and freely discussed.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“I founded the Journal of Controversial Ideas together with my co-editors, Francesca Minerva and Jeff McMahon, because all three of us were troubled by the narrowing climate of ideas that could be openly and freely discussed.”

0.48

When philosopher Rebecca Tuvel published an article asking if people who can identify as a gender different from their birth-assigned gender should also be able to identify as a race different from their ancestry, there was a petition calling for the article to be withdrawn from the journal Hypatia, even though the article raised an appropriate philosophical question.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“One of the early articles in philosophy that led to a reaction that we felt was unfortunate was when a young philosopher called Rebecca Tuvel published an article in which she accepted the idea that people who wish to be transgender should be able to identify as a gender different from that with which they were born. But she asked the question, if people can do that with gender, why can't they do that with regard to race?”

0.48

The Journal of Controversial Ideas published an article about when it is legitimate for non-Black people to use blackface, presenting a nuanced view on the issue that other journals had rejected.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“It was a paper about when it's legitimate to use blackface, when it's legitimate for people who are not black to put a black face on to act as if they are a person of African descent. And we put it through our review process, it had some interesting things to say. It had a more nuanced view on that issue than other discussions, and we thought it was worth publishing. We did publish it and the author put in a paragraph explaining why he was thankful to us for publishing it.”

0.48

The main criticism raised against the Journal of Controversial Ideas for publishing controversial articles is that they will harm disadvantaged or marginalized groups.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“The argument is mostly put against the controversial articles that we receive that they're going to harm disadvantaged or marginalized groups.”

0.48

Articles published in the Journal of Controversial Ideas that emphasize the significance of biological sex in the definition of woman are criticized as harmful to trans women because they attack self-identity, which is important to trans people who are a vulnerable group experiencing discrimination, higher rates of depression and suicide.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“the argument here is that if we publish articles which emphasize the significance of biological sex and which say, for example, that somebody is only really a woman if their biological sex changes and not if they identify as a woman, even though they are unchanged in terms of their male biology, that that is harmful to trans women who have chosen not to change their biology, that it attacks their self identity and self identity is very important and that they are very much a vulnerable group, both in terms of being discriminated against and attacked by many people, but also in terms of having a higher rate of depression and suicide than other groups. So people have said that it's therefore wrong of us to publish these articles.”

0.48

Peter Singer takes the concerns of trans people seriously, acknowledging they are vulnerable, discriminated against, and many will be upset by articles in the Journal, even though there is no coercion to read them.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“Now we take all of those concerns seriously. I think it's absolutely true that trans people are vulnerable, that they're discriminated against, that they have a hard time of it, and that they... Some of them will be upset if they read some of the articles in our journal. Now of course, there was no coercion to read any articles in our journal, but possibly simply knowing that such articles are published may disturb them.”

0.48

The Journal of Controversial Ideas is open to submissions of refutations of any articles it publishes and warmly welcomes controversy, as this is exactly what the Journal is trying to do.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“the Journal of Controversial Ideas, of course, is open to them to submit reputations of any articles they publish as anyone is to submit a counter argument against any of the articles we publish. We warmly welcome that kind of controversy. That's exactly what we're trying to do with the Journal of Controversial Ideas.”

0.48

Peter Singer was protested against in Germany for his position on ending the life of severely disabled newborns, and the protests were understandable given Germany's Nazi past and concern about anything resembling Nazi euthanasia programs.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“I was protested against in that issue initially in Germany, which understandably has a Nazi past and was very concerned about anything that looked like what the Nazis did.”

0.48

When Peter Singer came to Princeton in 1999, there were protests against his appointment because of his views on ending the life of severely disabled newborns.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“And when I came to Princeton in 1999, there were protests against my appointment at Princeton because of my views on that issue.”

0.48

Discussion of ending the life of severely disabled newborns is now more open in some countries, such as the Netherlands where medical organizations have accepted protocols allowing doctors in carefully circumscribed cases to actively end the life of very severely disabled newborns in pain with the wishes of parents.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“Now I think that discussion is a little more open now in that in some countries it is being discussed. And in fact, in the Netherlands there are protocols that medical organizations have accepted, which allow doctors in a very carefully circumscribed number of cases, and there've been only really a handful of cases, to do that, to actively end the life of a very severely disabled newborn, especially one who was in pain with the consent on the... With the wishes of the parents.”

0.48

Rebecca Tuvel published an article in the philosophy journal Hypatia arguing that if people can identify as a gender different from their birth sex, the logical question arises: why can't people identify as a different race, and presented the case of someone who identified as Black despite not having African ancestry.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“One of the early articles in philosophy that led to a reaction that we felt was unfortunate was when a young philosopher called Rebecca Tuvel published an article in which she accepted the idea that people who wish to be transgender should be able to identify as a gender different from that with which they were born. But she asked the question, if people can do that with gender, why can't they do that with regard to race?”

0.48

The appropriate response to an article one disagrees with is to show why the argument is wrong and present counter-arguments, not to petition for its withdrawal and attack the author.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“So we felt that the article was one that raised a good question and an appropriate response for those who disagreed would've been to show why they thought it was wrong, why they thought transracialism was different from transgenderism. But, you know, to attack the article and say, 'It ought to be withdrawn,' seemed to us to be completely the wrong reaction.”

0.48

The fear of social attack created by Twitter storms and campus protests is causing people to avoid publishing controversial ideas, which motivated the creation of the Journal of Controversial Ideas.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“And our concern was that people would stop publishing controversial ideas because they wouldn't want to be attacked in this way. So we thought it would be good to have a journal, which was an academic journal, which means that we review the papers sent to us, we get them sent in an anonymous form and have them reviewed anonymously.”

0.48

An article about when it is legitimate to use blackface was rejected by a journal after the murder of George Floyd and subsequent increased sensitivity around racial issues, despite having been well-reviewed and close to acceptance before Floyd's death, but was subsequently published in the Journal of Controversial Ideas.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“In one case, there was an article which was about racial issues, which had been... Was very close to being accepted by a journal. It had good peer reviews and seemed well on the way to being accepted. And then George Floyd was murdered. And with the murder of George Floyd, of course, there was a whole lot more activity protesting against the murder of Floyd and also protesting against other police killings of blacks and in general, making the treatment of blacks much more sensitive.”

0.48

Gender-critical feminists who argue that merely changing identification is not enough to make someone biologically male count as a woman in every respect have 'some kind of case' that is worth hearing, and advocates of self-identification should refute their arguments rather than suppress them.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“So it's not as if there's only one side to this issue, the so-called gender critical feminists who argue against the idea that merely changing your identification, I mean, the choice of identification is enough to make someone who is biologically male count as a woman in every respect, have some kind of case that... We think we're not saying that case is necessarily right, but we think it's better that that case be heard and that people who want to defend the idea of self-identification and the gender issue should then refute the arguments.”

0.48

Peter Singer has extended arguments about euthanasia to the possibility of parents choosing to end the life of a severely disabled newborn with a very poor prognosis when parents believe it is in the best interests of the child and family that the child not live, and faced significant protests against this position in multiple countries.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“But when I extended that to the possibility of parents choosing to end the life of a severely disabled newborn infant where the prognosis was very poor for the future of the child and the parents thought it was in the best interests of the child and of their family that the child not live, I was protested against on that issue in a number of countries.”

0.48

In Germany, Singer faced protests against his views on disabled newborns because of concerns they echoed Nazi euthanasia programs, though Singer's position differs in that Nazi euthanasia was not for the benefit of suffering individuals but to eliminate people deemed undesirable for eugenic/racial reasons.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“I was protested against in that issue initially in Germany, which understandably has a Nazi past and was very concerned about anything that looked like what the Nazis did. And the Nazis had a so-called euthanasia program for dealing with people who were mentally ill. But it wasn't really euthanasia. It wasn't for the benefit of people who were suffering or so severely disabled that they could not enjoy life at all. It was rather to remove people who were seen as a blot on the Aryan folk.”

0.46

About one-third of the papers published in the Journal of Controversial Ideas are anonymous, and the Journal also publishes papers where the author is happy to have their name attached but other journal editors don't want to publish them.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Peter Singer

“we have in fact published a number of papers anonymously, but not all the papers we publish are anonymous. Maybe about a third of them are, but we've discovered that there's something else important that we're doing. And that is we're publishing papers where the author is quite happy to have their name attached to it, but the journal editors don't wanna publish them.”

0.45

The Journal of Controversial Ideas was founded because its three editors (Peter Singer, Francesca Minerva, and Jeff McMahon) were troubled by the narrowing climate of ideas that could be openly and freely discussed.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“I founded the Journal of Controversial Ideas together with my co-editors, Francesca Minerva and Jeff McMahon, because all three of us were troubled by the narrowing climate of ideas that could be openly and freely discussed.”

0.45

University administrations have been weak in defending academic freedom, following Twitter storms of protest against professors who have said controversial things and allowing or enabling suspension and discipline.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Singer

“there have been a number of other instances since then where many people, some philosophers, but not all philosophers have gone into trouble on a range of different issues and in some cases have been suspended from their teaching and disciplined. And it seems like university administrations have been very weak in standing up to defend academic freedom. And the idea of university administrations following a Twitter storm of protest against one of their professors having said something seemed to us to be completely wrong.”

0.44

There was a petition to Hypatia journal calling for withdrawal of Tuvel's article and criticizing the editors for publishing it, with much of the petition coming from people who supported transgender identity rights—the same political position Tuvel herself appeared to support.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“there was a petition to the journal. It was a journal called Hypatia that Tuvel published that article in calling for it to be withdrawn and criticizing the editors for publishing it. And this was... As I say, a lot of it was coming from women who were supporting transgender... People who were trans women or trans men, but it was directed against a young woman who was an untenured philosophy professor at that time.”

0.44

Singer believes his views have had some influence in making doctors more willing to discuss and implement end-of-life choices with parents and ensure humane death for children with bleak futures.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“So that's not very different from what I've been advocating. And I think perhaps my views have had some influence in making doctors more willing to do that, more open to discussing it with the parents and then to removing life support and ensuring a humane death for a child whose future was going to be very bleak.”

0.43

Peter Singer extended his end-of-life argument to the possibility of parents choosing to end the life of a severely disabled newborn infant with a very poor prognosis where parents thought it was in the best interests of the child and family.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“But when I extended that to the possibility of parents choosing to end the life of a severely disabled newborn infant where the prognosis was very poor for the future of the child and the parents thought it was in the best interests of the child and of their family that the child not live, I was protested against on that issue in a number of countries.”

0.43

Peter Singer has argued for voluntary euthanasia for terminally ill and incurably ill people who want to die, and for physician-assisted dying, without facing protest against these positions.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“I've argued for voluntary euthanasia for people who are terminally ill and wanna die or incurably ill and wanna die. And similarly, physician assisted dying or voluntary assisted dying, which is similar. Now those arguments themselves were not protested against, I never lacked freedom of expression to argue for voluntary euthanasia or physician assisted dying.”

0.43

In other countries besides the Netherlands, doctors treating babies needing life support with poor prognosis ask parents if they wish to continue life support and will withdraw it if parents choose, allowing the child to die comfortably, which is not very different from what Peter Singer advocates.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“In other countries, it's not exactly that that's happening. But on the other hand, doctors who are treating a baby who needs life support and who also has a very poor prognosis, will go to the parents and ask the parents if they wish to have life support continued. And they will describe the prognosis for the child and say, "You might think it's better for your child that we withdraw treatment, the child will then die and we can make the child comfortable while the child dies." And many parents given that choice, exercise it.”

0.43

Many papers rejected by other journals and published in the Journal of Controversial Ideas were rejected not because they were poorly argued but because they were politically controversial.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“And that's now happened with a number of articles in the Journal of Controversial Ideas that they had been rejected by other journals, not because they weren't well argued, but because they were politically controversial.”

0.41

John Stuart Mill's 19th century essay On Liberty established that freedom of thought and expression is essential for progress in knowledge and truth.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“And this all goes back by the way to John Stewart Mill's famous 19th century essay on liberty.”

0.39

The Journal of Controversial Ideas has received more submissions on transgender issues than any other field of articles.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Peter Singer

“there are a number of fields of articles that are controversial, but perhaps the one that we've received the most articles submitted to us has been about transgender issues.”

0.39

Peter Singer faced protests against his appointment at Princeton in 1999 because of his views on parents' choice to end the life of severely disabled newborns.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“And when I came to Princeton in 1999, there were protests against my appointment at Princeton because of my views on that issue.”

0.34

This argument about the importance of freedom of thought goes back to John Stewart Mill's famous 19th century essay on liberty.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Peter Singer

“And this all goes back by the way to John Stewart Mill's famous 19th century essay on liberty.”

0.29

Peter Singer is a professor of bioethics who has worked for a long time on the question of choice in ending life.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“One area in which I've worked for a very long time as a professor of bioethics and previously as a... just a professor of philosophy is the question of choice in ending life.”

0.23

The Journal of Controversial Ideas welcomes controversy and counter-arguments against its published articles, and is open to submission of rebuttals by anyone disagreeing with articles published in the journal.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“And the Journal of Controversial Ideas, of course, is open to them to submit reputations of any articles they publish as anyone is to submit a counter argument against any of the articles we publish. We warmly welcome that kind of controversy. That's exactly what we're trying to do with the Journal of Controversial Ideas.”

0.20

Peter Singer has argued for voluntary euthanasia for people who are terminally ill or incurably ill and wish to die, as well as physician-assisted dying, without facing significant protests against these positions.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Peter Singer

“And I've argued for voluntary euthanasia for people who are terminally ill and wanna die or incurably ill and wanna die. And similarly, physician assisted dying or voluntary assisted dying, which is similar. Now those arguments themselves were not protested against, I never lacked freedom of expression to argue for voluntary euthanasia or physician assisted dying.”

0.17

Approximately one-third of papers published in the Journal of Controversial Ideas are published anonymously, while the rest are attributed to named authors.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Peter Singer

“And we have in fact published a number of papers anonymously, but not all the papers we publish are anonymous. Maybe about a third of them are, but we've discovered that there's something else important that we're doing.”

0.17

Peter Singer has worked for a very long time as a professor of bioethics and previously as a professor of philosophy on the question of choice in ending life.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Peter Singer

“One area in which I've worked for a very long time as a professor of bioethics and previously as a... just a professor of philosophy is the question of choice in ending life.”