twin studies
Research comparing identical and fraternal twins to estimate the relative contributions of genes and environment to traits.
As defined in Alison Gopnik
Where it comes up · 7
- Alison Gopnik2 claims
- 165 | Kathryn Paige Harden on Genetics, Luck, and Fairness2 claims
- Conversations with Tyler - Arthur Brooks1 claim
- Gregory Clark1 claim
- Morris Fiorina on Polarization, Stability, and the State of the Electorate1 claim
- Michael McCullough on the Kindness of Strangers1 claim
- 77 - The Moral Complexity Of Genetics1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “twin studies” →
- Heritability and inheritability are distinct: heritability asks whether a trait has a genetic component (measured via twin studies), while inheritability asks how likely a set of genes marches across generations in intact form; IQ is moderately-to-highly heritable but, because it is polygenic with gene-environment interactions and no single gene dominates, it is not easily inheritable.77 - The Moral Complexity Of Genetics
- Twin studies, including the Minnesota identical twins surveys by Lykken and Tellegen on identical twins raised in separate homes, robustly show that between 40 and 80 percent of personality characteristics are genetic.Conversations with Tyler - Arthur Brooks
- Parents have surprisingly little direct shared-environment influence on their children's values; much resemblance is genetic, and the apparent environmental effect (e.g., on religiosity) largely disappears once children leave home, so parents' most potent lever is engineering their children's social environments and peer influences.Michael McCullough on the Kindness of Strangers
- A frontier of political science research, once politically incorrect, now studies the biological and genetic bases of political attitudes—including a twin-studies claim that about half of one's ideology is inherited from parents—funded increasingly by NIH rather than NSF, which no longer funds political science unrelated to national security or economic growth.Morris Fiorina on Polarization, Stability, and the State of the Electorate
- For most of the history of behavioral genetics, researchers measured nothing about DNA at all; the field made inferences about genetic influence on life outcomes via twin and adoption studies before Watson and Crick, before the word 'gene,' and the opacity of that approach contributed to the work being controversial.165 | Kathryn Paige Harden on Genetics, Luck, and Fairness
- The nature-nurture dichotomy is the wrong framework, like the 19th-century quest to define 'life': a single trait can be simultaneously 100% genetic and 100% environmental (as with a metabolic disorder controlled by diet), and the correct approach is to track the complicated developmental interactions between genetics and environment that produce a specific outcome.Alison Gopnik
- The goal should be to make genetics 'boring'—a routine technique (using polygenic scores, sibling, or twin designs) incorporated into everyday developmental, clinical, and educational psychology research like propensity score matching or instrumental variables analysis, to refine the rigor of inferences and identify which environments are most efficacious at producing desired outcomes in children.165 | Kathryn Paige Harden on Genetics, Luck, and Fairness
- Genome-wide association studies, even with up to 4 million genotyped people and a thousand identified loci affecting educational outcomes, still cannot mechanically locate the genetic basis we know exists from twin studies; combinatoric effects appear largely ruled out (effects are mostly additive), implying you may need samples larger than all of humanity to identify the rare permutations involved, and small populations like Native Americans may never be studyable this way.Gregory Clark
- In Turkheimer's work, twin correlations converge more in upper-class than poorer families because small environmental differences matter more for poor children's life outcomes; similarly, as smoking became restricted the apparent genetic contribution to smoking rose because only those with strong predispositions still smoked—so observed heritability is a function of how much environmental variation a society permits.Alison Gopnik