tribalism
The deep human desire to join together with others and belong to something larger than oneself, which in politics manifests as identifying strongly with one's own group and viewing opposing groups as wrong or evil
As defined in Russ Roberts on the Information Revolution, Politics, Yeats, and Yelling
Other definitions
Increasing orientation toward in-group identity and cohesion with reduced trust across group boundaries, occurring during Fourth Turning crisis eras as people organize into competing communities
Keeping it Simple | Ep.38: Are We Fourth Turning Japanese? Or Is It Different this Time?
Where it comes up · 12
- Russ Roberts on the Information Revolution, Politics, Yeats, and Yelling7 claims
- Arnold Kling on Morality, Culture, and Tribalism4 claims
- Keeping it Simple | Ep.38: Are We Fourth Turning Japanese? Or Is It Different this Time?3 claims
- Navigating Our Revolutionary Age: A Conversation with Fareed Zakaria and Eric Schmidt2 claims
- Michael Sandel & Yuval Noah Harari in conversation1 claim
- Paul Bloom on Cruelty1 claim
- Reclaiming Tribalism (with Michael Morris)1 claim
- 274 - The Future Of American Democracy1 claim
and 4 more
Most important claims · 10 of 24Search all claims for “tribalism” →
- Tribalism is natural to humans and imprinted by evolution, but nationalism—which requires loyalty to millions of strangers you've never met—is a cultural construction that required massive educational and propaganda efforts to establish, and therefore is not eternal or natural despite common claims that it is.TimesTalks | Yuval Noah Harari
- America has always been tribal, with whites in the South voting their ethnic identity (and being called racist) and Black Americans voting collectively to express their collective power, but the current tribalism is more accentuated and visible because when cultural identity is layered with class, geography, religion, and politics, these cross-cutting divisions disappear and create two separate nations.Navigating Our Revolutionary Age: A Conversation with Fareed Zakaria and Eric Schmidt
- The popular framing of tribalism as a new toxic virus destroying democracy is incoherent because group conflict is age-old, not new; what is actually new is the despair and the false belief that we are genetically predisposed to hate outsiders, which contradicts how humans evolved.Reclaiming Tribalism (with Michael Morris)
- The same favoritism toward one's own child is judged differently depending on the sphere: caring for your own sick child rather than someone else's is seen as perfectly moral, but giving your child a job in a large organization or government that you wouldn't give another is seen as deeply immoral—revealing that morality appropriate at the tribal/family level differs from that appropriate at the organizational level.Arnold Kling on Morality, Culture, and Tribalism
- Tribalism is a barrier to trading with people beyond one's group because you don't trust them; without either fundamental trust or an enforcement mechanism—usually the State, or violence—to coerce trust and make people comfortable with investment, delayed payment, or advance payment, large-scale trade cannot get off the ground.Arnold Kling on Morality, Culture, and Tribalism
- Tribalism is the first grave problem of humanity: humans are always on the verge of developing violent hatreds of foreigners and have shown strong ongoing tendencies to slaughter strangers in vast numbers, unable to reliably see the humanity in all members of their own kind.Why Humanity Destroyed Itself
- Because most of our moral norms arose when humans lived in small bands rather than large affluent societies, there are inherent conflicts between the moral norms that evolved at the tribal level and the norms that a modern large-scale society actually requires.Arnold Kling on Morality, Culture, and Tribalism
- Human beings have a tribal moral sense: we react far more strongly to threats or needs affecting close relatives and friends than to identical situations affecting strangers, primarily because we feel a stronger emotional pull toward those we are close to rather than for purely cognitive reasons.Arnold Kling on Morality, Culture, and Tribalism
- Every fourth turning climaxes in inflation because inflation is one of several means of burden-sharing (along with taxation and bond sales) that governments use to distribute the costs of mobilization, and this pattern extends back to the War of Spanish Succession in the 17th century.Keeping it Simple | Ep.38: Are We Fourth Turning Japanese? Or Is It Different this Time?
- Nationalism, properly understood, invokes a sense of shared community and fellow feeling across strangers unified by a common political project, distinct from tribalism or xenophobia, and is necessary for democracy because citizens must believe they share a common fate.Michael Sandel & Yuval Noah Harari in conversation