transformative experience
An experience whose value cannot be known in advance because undergoing it changes you and your preferences; coined by philosopher L.A. Paul.
As defined in 94 | Stuart Russell on Making Artificial Intelligence Compatible with Humans
Where it comes up · 6
- 327 - Transformative Experiences8 claims
- L.A. Paul on Vampires, Life Choices, and Transformation7 claims
- Emily Oster on the Pandemic1 claim
- Dwayne Betts on Ellison, Levi, and Human Suffering1 claim
- 350 | J. Eric Oliver on the Self and How to Know It1 claim
- 94 | Stuart Russell on Making Artificial Intelligence Compatible with Humans1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 19Search all claims for “transformative experience” →
- Humans have genuine epistemic uncertainty about their own preferences that no amount of thinking can resolve—only actual experience can—exemplified by the durian fruit (which people either love or despise but cannot know without tasting) and by a 16-year-old choosing between being a coal miner or a librarian, so an AI system can never reach perfect knowledge of human preferences in any finite time.94 | Stuart Russell on Making Artificial Intelligence Compatible with Humans
- Deciding whether to become a vampire is intractable because the value of the choice turns on what it would be like to live as a vampire, yet that experience can only be known once you become one and the choice is irreversible, so you lack the information needed to make an informed decision and your preferences remain incomplete.L.A. Paul on Vampires, Life Choices, and Transformation
- Normally we fine-grain average-value evidence by imaginatively projecting how we would respond to a situation, but in transformative experiences this is impossible because we lack the experiential information needed to perform that projection, so we cannot fix the reference class or individualize the data.L.A. Paul on Vampires, Life Choices, and Transformation
- Transformative choices like becoming a vampire change you in a deep and fundamental way—altering core desires, tastes, and how much you care about others—so even unanimously positive testimony from those who made the choice is hard to evaluate because it reflects the preferences of the changed self, not the self deciding.L.A. Paul on Vampires, Life Choices, and Transformation
- When parents choose whether to give a deaf child cochlear implants versus raising them in the deaf community, making the choice by imaginatively comparing the child's life at 15 or 25 under each option is impossible, because each parent can experientially access only one of the two future lives, so the expected-value comparison the decision seems to require cannot actually be performed.L.A. Paul on Vampires, Life Choices, and Transformation
- The increasingly common cultural message that a young person should map out their optimal life path and execute it is a horrible way to think about life, because at 17 you know little about how to get from A to B and, more importantly, you will discover halfway there that you no longer want to reach B—since growing up is itself the most transformative experience.L.A. Paul on Vampires, Life Choices, and Transformation
- Historically, the angst of transformative choices was avoided because religion, tradition, and social norms answered these unanswerable questions for people, so no one agonized over them; modernity's move away from these institutions expanded choices and their cultural acceptability but introduced the angst of having to write one's life from a blank slate.L.A. Paul on Vampires, Life Choices, and Transformation
- There is no data of the conventional sort about what it is like to become a parent—only information from literature, film, and others—because parenthood is uncharted, transformative territory that cannot be fully understood until experienced, a point connected to L.A. Paul's work on transformative experiences and Agnes Callard's work on aspiration.Emily Oster on the Pandemic
- For some life-changing decisions with incompatible selves—like getting a frontal lobotomy—culture supplies a dominant rule that resolves the choice, but for others like having a child there is no dominant cultural narrative, so the decision is left to the individual, who then faces a genuine decision problem with no rule to follow and inadequate tools to decide.L.A. Paul on Vampires, Life Choices, and Transformation
- If a future completed science of the mind let us directly choose to change our values—e.g., installing more or less compassion—we would face a paradox: we must judge in advance whether making the change is good, while knowing the standard by which we judge goodness is itself one of the things that would be changed, an endogenous change where the change is the very thing at issue.327 - Transformative Experiences