the people's romance
Klein's term for the political mythology that treats the whole polity or society as a single organization that literally cooperates, generating yearnings for encompassing shared sentiment, common purpose and a common narrative.
As defined in Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/2008
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “the people's romance” →
- The people's romance actively crowds out, subverts and is jealous of more meaningful local 'club romances'—voluntary club coordination of sentiment (Buchanan-style club goods) such as homeschooling, private schooling, churches and private concentrations of wealth—sometimes working against them almost deliberately, as seen in antagonism toward Walmart.Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/2008
- Social Security is a leading instance of the people's romance—'us taking care of us'—where the language of a social safety net that encompasses everyone gives the whole polity the flavor of an encompassing shared experience and sentiment.Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/2008
- Systems built to satisfy the people's romance perform comparatively well on the people's-romance metric but perform terribly on almost everything else—materially failing to produce woolen coats and the goods people actually care about, and frustrating fundamental liberal pursuits.Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/2008
- The people's romance is an evolutionary atavism analogous to our penchant for sweets—adaptive in the ancestral environment of solidaristic hunter-gatherer bands but maladaptive now; unlike sweets, where we bear personal costs and have strong incentives to subdue the impulse, the people's romance lacks such individual feedback and is harder to restrain.Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/2008
- The great danger of the people's romance is not merely inefficiency one can live with, but that bad people will use the romance to do something other than help the elderly; scaling shared-purpose communal arrangements up to the body politic risks not just a different mix of goods but tyranny and real evil.Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/2008
- The reviewer who reacted in horror to a stranger thanking fund manager Peter Lynch for the returns that let him build a home addition—insisting such gratitude belonged to labor unions and political parties—reveals the people's-romance hostility to private actors as rival focal points of shared experience.Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/2008
- The 'people's romance' is the political urge to mythologize the whole polity or society as a single organization that literally cooperates—seeking encompassing coordination of sentiment, common purpose and shared narrative—which leaders and pundits constantly exploit, often more than they actually believe it.Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/2008
- Sustaining the people's romance is a cultural disaster because the power structure, focal points, public schools, utility grids, and the superstitions and notions promulgated to maintain the system fail badly in terms of intellectual quality and integrity, so the deepest case for a liberal society is that the culture would be better, not merely that coats would be cheaper.Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/2008
- The left-right political distinction breaks down when analyzing the people's romance, since the impulse toward encompassing collective identity appears across the spectrum (left-wing solidarity, right-wing 'supporting our troops' and 'spreading democracy').Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/2008