technological unemployment
Joblessness caused by technology replacing human labor; phrase introduced by Keynes in his 1930 essay.
As defined in Andrew McAfee, Megan McArdle, and Lee Ohanian on the Future of Work
Where it comes up · 4
- Robert Shiller on Narrative Economics3 claims
- Andrew McAfee, Megan McArdle, and Lee Ohanian on the Future of Work1 claim
- James Bessen on Learning by Doing1 claim
- Nouriel Roubini Sees Global Debt Trap Driving Inflation1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “technological unemployment” →
- During the Industrial Revolution in both Britain and the US, textile mill productivity rose rapidly for roughly half a century while wages remained completely stagnant, leading thinkers like Marx to conclude capitalism extracts all profits to capitalists and to fear mass technological unemployment that never materialized.James Bessen on Learning by Doing
- AI, automation, and robotics will have negative spillover effects including increasing income and wealth inequality and leading to massive technological unemployment.Nouriel Roubini Sees Global Debt Trap Driving Inflation
- The fear of being replaced by machines is an ancient narrative (traceable to Aristotle and Homer's automato) that recurs under successive labels—Luddite 'neighbor-reducing machines,' technological unemployment, automation, and now artificial intelligence or machine learning—all referring to the same underlying fear, while the competing optimistic narrative that displaced workers find better jobs is less contagious.Robert Shiller on Narrative Economics
- For 200 years predictions of mass technological unemployment (Luddites, Marx, Keynes) have been wrong because innovators invented new wants and the engine of creative destruction tilted toward job creation; but it may genuinely be different this time because where previously only the 'power system' of organizations was automated, now the 'control system' (intelligence) is also being automated, raising the question of what human labor is needed for at all.Andrew McAfee, Megan McArdle, and Lee Ohanian on the Future of Work
- Even a false automation narrative can rationally affect economic decisions: if people interpret high unemployment as technological in origin, they will perceive a larger long-term risk and rationally save more and delay big purchases—so a prominent narrative plausibly influenced behavior during the Great Depression.Robert Shiller on Narrative Economics
- The narrative that automation reduces the total number of opportunities for human beings has historically been false—it has displaced particular skills but not net opportunities—and functions mostly as entertainment, like a horror movie, with little real impact on economic policy or on the unabated human impulse to create and advance technology.Robert Shiller on Narrative Economics