James Bessen on Learning by Doing
What this covers
Russ Roberts interviews James Bessen, author of Learning by Doing, about why workers' wages lag behind productivity gains when new technology arrives. The core argument unfolds across textile history and the present-day IT economy: productivity can soar for decades while workers see no wage growth if their skills remain firm-specific human capital—locked to individual firms and worthless elsewhere. Only when skills become standardized and portable do workers gain bargaining power to claim their share of the gains. The conversation moves from 19th-century mills, where productivity rose roughly fifty years while wages flatlined, through the Civil War era when standardization finally opened a competitive labor market and sent wages upward, to today's technology-driven turbulence affecting far more of the workforce than earlier mechanization ever did.
The discussion ranges widely across how standardization actually works. Standardization Enables Skill Portability emerges as the hidden engine behind prosperity: government procurement of interchangeable parts and shared knowledge at armories seeded the American machinery industry; NASA and defense spending later did the same for computing and the Internet. Bessen distinguishes Certification vs Licensing, arguing that occupational licensing—now covering nearly 30 percent of workers versus 5 percent in the 1950s—often restricts entry and hurts consumers rather than protecting them. The conversation also covers non-compete agreements and how Knowledge Spillovers via Labor Mobility drove Silicon Valley's rise over Boston's Route 128. Throughout, Bessen stresses that the path forward is not universal college degrees or coding boot camps, but cultivating lifelong learning skills—comfort with systems, quantitative thinking, and the ability to learn how to learn as technology continually shifts.
Bessen argues that workers share in productivity gains only after new technology skills become standardized and portable across firms; until then, firm-specific human capital keeps wages stagnant even as productivity soars, which explains both 19th-century textile history and today's technology-driven labor turbulence.
- During the Industrial Revolution textile productivity rose for ~50 years while wages stayed flat because skills were firm-specific and non-portable
- Wages rose only after standardization created a robust labor market where workers could be bid away by other employers
- Today's IT revolution affects a far larger share of workers and similarly requires hard-to-acquire, continually changing skills
Worker wages reflect their productivity combined with the availability of alternative employment options.
- What sets a worker's wages is their next-best alternative combined with their productivity; in 1870 a weaver was paid what they were worth because another mill would hire them away, whereas in 1830 leaving a job meant likely no comparable alternative, so wages stayed low regardless of productivity.
“what sets your wages is your next best alternative, combined with your productivity.”
Productivity gains benefit consumers broadly even when they displace workers from traditional sectors.
- Agricultural productivity has risen dramatically so that fewer farmers are needed and farm employment continues to fall, which is beneficial for consumers (shifting America's problem from poverty to obesity) even if disappointing for those who dream of generational farming.
“agricultural productivity is going through the roof. And after a while we don't need as many farmers, and it just continues to fall and fall and fall.”
Adaptability—learning how to learn—matters more than mastery of specific tools in changing labor markets.
- The most valuable skill in a world of constantly changing software is not mastery of any particular tool but the ability to learn how to learn new software; teaching people how to teach themselves gives them the greatest gift, yet we do not know how to do this at large scale.
“If you can teach somebody how to learn, you've really given them the greatest gift.”