survivorship bias
The error of drawing conclusions only from cases that survived a selection process while ignoring the many that didn't, leading to overly optimistic or distorted inferences.
As defined in Megan McArdle on Failure, Success, and the Up Side of Down
Other definitions
Cognitive bias resulting from concentrating on entities that survived a selection process while overlooking those that did not, leading to skewed conclusions about causation and success patterns.
The 8 Greatest Philosophical Theories You Need to KnowThe error of drawing conclusions from successful cases while ignoring the much larger number of similar attempts that failed, which makes success look more replicable than it is.
From Obsession to Profession
Where it comes up · 28
- The Merge: Ep. 03 | The past is not gone; it lives on in the future5 claims
- Investors Made These 9 Costly Mistakes in 2024 | Larry Swedroe Explains How to Fix Them4 claims
- Why Money Isn't What You Think: Barry Ritholtz on the Meaning of Money and How NOT to Invest It3 claims
- Cliff Asness: A Brief and Biased Survey of Quantitative Investing3 claims
- Cliff Sosin - Owning the Complements to Intelligence - [Invest Like the Best, EP.497]3 claims
- From Obsession to Profession2 claims
- Luca Dellanna on Risk, Ruin, and Ergodicity2 claims
- Rick Buhrman & Paul Buser - Find Your X, Nurture Your N - [Invest Like the Best, EP.346]2 claims
and 20 more
Most important claims · 10 of 45Search all claims for “survivorship bias” →
- Stories celebrating the virtues of failure suffer from survivorship bias: we romanticize the rare people like Colonel Sanders and Steve Jobs who eventually succeeded, while ignoring the many who fail, give up, and never learn enough to succeed, making such stories unrepresentative of what failure actually does.Megan McArdle on Failure, Success, and the Up Side of Down
- Learning from people four or more standard deviations from the mean, such as Taylor Swift or Oprah, is dangerous because survivorship bias means someone can always be cherry-picked to support a strategy, and copying an outlier's approach does not guarantee the same result.From Obsession to Profession
- There is no complete way to remove survivorship bias from a study of great investment managers, since many firms that had similar skill failed due to luck, team changes, or macro headwinds, and the sample of cases is what was available.Rick Buhrman & Paul Buser - Find Your X, Nurture Your N - [Invest Like the Best, EP.346]
- In a Morningstar study following a group of funds from 2006 for ten years, about 20 percent of surviving funds outperformed their reference benchmark, but only 8 percent did so on a dollar-weighted basis, and accounting for investor timing brings the figure to about one in 12.The Prospects for Active Management
- Managers facing the Shleifer-Vishny problem can launch many funds with varied strategies, market the surviving track records, and shut down the rest, a strategy Gray calls the black crow model.Compound Your Face Off
- Winning masks systemic deficiencies because winning produces positive emotions and narratives that overshadow underlying problems, while losing over-amplifies the visibility of problems and can obscure good processes that happened to lose, making survivorship bias a critical analytical trap when studying success.How to Achieve Peak Mental Performance | Justin Su'a | Knowledge Project 137
- The concept of anachronism—projecting modern ideas and categories backward in time—is a fundamental source of error in historical analysis, comparable to survivorship bias in its severity and ubiquity.The Merge: Ep. 03 | The past is not gone; it lives on in the future
- Acquired's podcasting success is a single path through the multiverse and survivorship bias makes it dangerous to infer that passionate pursuit of a nerdy niche will lead to a job or large market, since many similarly passionate people never succeed.From Obsession to Profession
- We only see the successful egomaniacs and never know how many failed because they couldn't restrain their ego; Steve Jobs is read as proof ego serves you, but he came very close to becoming a totally ignored figure, and his improbable return to Apple obscures how unlikely such a second chance is.Ryan Holiday on Ego is the Enemy
- In AQR's first year of business (1999), they correctly identified the technology bubble using their value and momentum models and shorted tech stocks, but the strategy suffered significantly that year until tech collapsed, creating a difficult early track record that felt personally devastating but ultimately validated the approach.Cliff Asness: A Brief and Biased Survey of Quantitative Investing