steelmanning
The practice of constructing the strongest possible version of an opposing argument (the opposite of strawmanning), used by Cowen to maintain epistemic humility.
As defined in Rob Wiblin interviews Tyler
Where it comes up · 5
- 41 - Faith In Reason4 claims
- How Great Founders Tell Their Story1 claim
- Rob Wiblin interviews Tyler1 claim
- 128 - Transformations Of Mind1 claim
- Greg Lukianoff1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “steelmanning” →
- Intellectual honesty requires steelmanning: being able to summarize your opponent's view in a way they would not object to, and ideally in a stronger form than they themselves could produce, and then arguing against that strongest version—this is how any civil and productive debate should operate.41 - Faith In Reason
- The best way to keep epistemic humility (and the most important trait for accurate forecasting) is to write out or present the arguments of the side you disagree with, because your ego forces you to produce the strongest version and you become invested in it, setting one passion against another to counter your irrational dislike—i.e., always steelman and try to pass the ideological Turing test rather than strawman.Rob Wiblin interviews Tyler
- Critics permit criticism of religion only if all religions are treated as equally good or bad; breaking that equality—asserting that some religions are worse on specific points (e.g., Islam's current connection to terror versus Christianity's)—causes the critic to be presumed to harbor a secret moral failing such as bigotry, regardless of evidence.41 - Faith In Reason
- It is prima facie obvious from statistics that as of 2016 there is more of a connection between Islam and terror than between Christianity and terror, and claims that right-wing Christian terrorism in the US is the bigger problem are constructed by manipulating the count—starting body counts after September 11th and folding in attempted and eco-terror attacks against the Islamic side.41 - Faith In Reason
- The key test for productive thinking is whether a person can 'camp and decamp'—fully inhabit a belief or ideology and then switch hats to steelman the counter-argument—because people who cannot move between these modules rarely solve problems, while the productive tension between modules is the most generative cognitive state.41 - Faith In Reason
- Strawmanning misrepresents the opposing perspective, while steelmanning—stating the opponent's view at its strongest—requires empathy, eloquence, and research; the related 'star-manning' technique reframes a position by detaching from it and recognizing how typical it actually is (e.g., 'hating Kansas' reframed as hating your dominant religious minority).Greg Lukianoff
- The philosophical layer should be built by steelmanning how people currently believe the world works and why it is good, since most people believe they are doing the right thing for a reason and are mostly not wrong; then you juxtapose that with your own philosophy that the dominant worldview is wrong, ideally in four or five explicit points made on a direct reputational basis.How Great Founders Tell Their Story
- Because it is very hard to predict which job-related knowledge will be useful in 20-30 years, K-12 education should focus on durable, transferable capacities—civics and free-speech rights, meditation, emotion management, conflict resolution, active listening, steelmanning opponents' arguments, and game-theory basics like the prisoner's dilemma—rather than specific vocational skills.128 - Transformations Of Mind