standpoint epistemology
The philosophical view that people coming from different social positions know and justify knowledge differently, picking out different things as important even toward the same truth
As defined in ms_35
Where it comes up · 3
- 95 | Liam Kofi Bright on Knowledge, Truth, and Science5 claims
- 336 - The Roots Of Identity Politics2 claims
- Rebecca Kukla1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “standpoint epistemology” →
- The Me Too slogan 'believe women' can be given a standpoint-epistemology rationale: to learn reliably who is a sexual predator in a workplace, you consider who has the authority to get away with things and the distribution of sexuality, and since power in offices is mostly held by heterosexual men, women are mostly the ones with relevant knowledge—giving strong reason to believe and trust them as the ones who know.95 | Liam Kofi Bright on Knowledge, Truth, and Science
- In public discourse intersectionality has mutated in two troubling ways: merging with standpoint epistemology so that people at different identity intersections supposedly cannot understand each other and must simply defer to one another's political claims, and becoming a litmus test in which joining a movement on one issue (e.g. feminism) requires adopting prescribed views on unrelated issues like the Israeli-Palestinian conflict or trans rights.336 - The Roots Of Identity Politics
- The early, unsophisticated form of standpoint epistemology held that women share a common perspective by virtue of being women, but this idea has been increasingly debunked — including among feminists — because every woman's experience is inflected by race, class, body, ability, age, and region, so there is no single 'women's perspective.'Rebecca Kukla
- The stronger version of standpoint epistemology—'a standpoint is an achievement,' where occupying e.g. the proletariat's or oppressed women's worldview yields a more accurate, more informed perspective—is philosophically much more difficult, because spelling out the content of such a standpoint (what the 'true woman's standpoint' is) is hard, and any empirical test of its superiority risks being circular or biased if the standpoints disagree about what counts as valid methods of validating knowledge.95 | Liam Kofi Bright on Knowledge, Truth, and Science
- The core postmodernist contribution is a rejection of universalism: any truth claim, scientific or otherwise, is treated as at bottom an expression of power, leaving only texts and interpretations with no grounding of human knowledge except the assertion of power over others—reducing 'all men are equal' to ideological claptrap with no objective foundation.336 - The Roots Of Identity Politics
- Standpoint epistemology does not claim that who you are (race, gender, cis/trans) affects the physical truth about the world (e.g., whether the universe is expanding); the crucial distinction is between claims about how you know and claims about what is true. The plausible thesis—that social position affects what you can know—is structurally identical to saying a physics PhD knows more about cosmic expansion without that expansion depending on having a PhD; the implausible thesis that identity changes the truth is a different and far less defensible claim often wrongly attributed to standpoint theorists.95 | Liam Kofi Bright on Knowledge, Truth, and Science
- The 'what you can know' version of standpoint epistemology is the easier to defend: since the experiences your life affords make a difference to what you can be a reliable informant about, social position correlates with knowledge (e.g., in a segregated 1950s town, black domestic workers would know both the black and white quarters while white residents wouldn't), so with limited resources, demographics and social position are reasonable correlates for choosing informants—a point with real implications for research design that has historically been forgotten in ways that over-trusted those atop social hierarchies.95 | Liam Kofi Bright on Knowledge, Truth, and Science
- Standpoint epistemology, originating in Marxist theory and taken up in late-20th-century feminist theory, holds (stated generally) that who you are and what social position you occupy makes a difference to what you can know and how reliable you are at certain kinds of reasoning tasks; depending on formulation it concerns what you can know, how you know it, or both.95 | Liam Kofi Bright on Knowledge, Truth, and Science