What this covers

Jessica Yellin, a veteran correspondent who has worked for MSNBC, ABC, and CNN and now runs an Instagram-based news project, sits down with Sean Carroll to diagnose what has gone wrong with television news and sketch where journalism might go next. The conversation moves from the structural incentives that shaped network newsrooms over decades—how the shift from news-as-loss-leader to profit center remade editorial decisions—to the specific editorial choices that now dominate coverage. Yellin argues that news executives have optimized for conflict in a sports-like format, favoring guests willing to yell and steering coverage toward horse-race narratives and spectacle rather than explanation, which has alienated a large audience, particularly women, who experience this tone as anxiety-inducing noise rather than information.

The discussion spans several distinct territories. One concerns standpoint epistemology in newsrooms: when men run the editorial decisions, coverage tilts toward theoretical and competitive framings; when women do, stories incorporate more human impact and empathy. Another explores why a significant portion of the population practices news avoidance—not apathy, but rejection of a delivery mode that triggers stress. A third examines the mechanics of control: how keeping reporters in the studio rather than in the field lets executives "produce the news" in real time, and how embedded coverage during the Iraq War became a produced television event. Yellin proposes that the remedy lies in individual credible journalists publishing directly on social platforms, adopting a slow news ethos, and explaining rather than performing—reaching audiences that mainstream outlets have abandoned. The conversation also touches on media literacy as a consumer skill and the likelihood that like-minded clustering will make future news increasingly partisan, requiring outlets to be transparent about perspective while keeping facts non-negotiable.

Sharpest takeaway

Yellin argues that TV news has been distorted by short-term profit pressures into a sports-like conflict format that alienates a large audience, and that the future of trustworthy news lies in individual credible journalists who explain rather than shout, reaching underserved audiences through new platforms like Instagram.

  • News executives optimize for conflict and a narrow young-male demographic, leaving a large audience (heavily female) alienated and engaging in 'news avoidance'
  • Explaining the basics and connecting stories to people's lives, rather than horse-race coverage, actually grows and engages audiences
  • The future is credible individual reporters trusted on social platforms rather than the closed network 'studio system'

The argument · threads9 threads · 39 claims
0.85

Profit motive transformed news from loss leader into entertainment, making conflict and combat the deliberate format of coverage.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Network news began as a loss leader tied to airwave access with no pressure to monetize, but once 60 Minutes proved news could make money, executives realized they could profit from it, leading to entertainment-driven morning shows while evening news remained sacrosanct.

    “When news first came along at the network level, it was a loss leader... when 60 Minutes came along and actually made money, it was the first time network executives realized, "We can make a profit off of this."”

  • The reporter on the ground witnessing events has too little influence over whether and how a story is covered, a function of how news organizations changed as they became extremely profitable and profit became the priority.

    “the reporter who's on the ground witnessing the events has too little influence in deciding the story... And that's a function of how our organizations have changed, news organizations have changed, as profit became accessible, as they became extremely profitable, and as that became the priority.”

  • Networks deliberately cast TV guests for their willingness to yell and hold their ground rather than for expertise — when a smart, clear-speaking expert was suggested, the producer's response was 'Will they bring the heat?' — so the combative quality of pundits is by design, not incidental.

    “I'd find this expert... say "This person's so smart, they know their stuff, and they speak clearly, let's get them on." And the response would be, "Will they bring the heat?"... we literally cast for people who will yell at each other, hold their ground.”

  • The conflict-driven news format emerged because in the late 1990s/early 2000s the ad-dollar model prized car dealers who wanted the hard-to-reach 18-to-35-year-old man as the most desirable eyeball, and since that demographic prefers conflict, executives told news like conflict — even though the underlying demographic assumptions (men make car decisions, brand loyalty for life) have since proven untrue.

    “PS, we've now found that's untrue, women make the car purchase decision, and this generation isn't buying cars.”

  • Management increasingly tells reporters what the story is, and when a reporter pushes back that the real story is something else, management insists on its framing — not by fabricating facts, but by deciding how to frame the story to serve programming needs (eyeballs and ratings).

    “management would tell us what the story is. And you'd say back, "Actually, it's this," and they would say, "Did you not hear me? I'm telling you, this is the story."... it's a, "This is how we've decided is best to frame it, for our programming needs, AKA eyeballs, AKA ratings."”

  • Because news companies were bought by publicly traded corporations that needed to show profit growth over the prior year to shareholders, short-term profit thinking penetrated the newsroom to the point that reporters were explicitly told their job was to increase profit 10% over last year.

    “all of these companies were bought by publicly traded corporations... Where it was important to show profit growth over last year to the shareholders all the time... to the point that I was told it is your guys's job to increase our profit 10% over last year.”

0.66

News coverage of Iraq War and politics as 'horse race' demonstrates editorial framing serves popularity and narrative control, not significance.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Embedding reporters with military units turned Iraq war coverage into a produced TV show — marching in with cameras rolling rather than air-dropping in to cover events as they happened — revealing that the networks were 'producing the war' rather than neutrally covering it.

    “it was very much like a TV show. There were vans with reporters on them and cameras as they marched into... They're driving to Baghdad with the troops. It was a show and that kind of opened my eyes to, "Oh, we're producing the war."”

  • Political coverage that is all 'horse race' — who's up, who's down, the poll numbers — without telling people how it affects them at home is eroding democracy, because it is the news's job to inform the public and it is failing to do so by covering politics as a game rather than connecting it to people's lives.

    “the problem with it is that's it's all horse race. It's literally, "This one's up, this one's down. What are the poll numbers?" And I think this is eroding our democracy. Nothing short of that, because it is the news's job to inform the public and we are failing to do that by constantly covering this game.”

  • Coverage of the 2003 Iraq War was crafted to be consistent with the patriotic fever in the nation to attract viewers, was 'rah rah' while the war was popular, and became increasingly critical as poll numbers fell — demonstrating coverage tone was tied to popularity rather than significance.

    “as the war was popular with the American people, we covered it in a way that was "rah, rah;" as the poll numbers started to fall, we began increasingly critical.”

  • Keeping reporters in the studio rather than out in the field is partly cost-cutting (a satellite truck and crew of five is far more expensive than people on set), but also lets news executives 'produce the news' — rapidly switching topics and speaking into the reporter's ear to control the story, which they cannot do when a reporter is deployed in the field.

    “It's way cheaper to have people on set, than to send a satellite truck, a producer, a cameraman, a sound person and a reporter... when everyone's in studio, they can rapidly decide what... They can control the story much more effectively, and they can also get in the person's ear and tell them, "No, no, stay on Russia, stay on Russia."”

  • What happens in the White House press briefing room is usually the least relevant thing — it is 'Kabuki theater' where reporters ask three-part, conflict-seeking questions designed to make themselves look tough on camera rather than to elicit substantive answers, because TV news is structured around conflict.

    “what happens in the briefing room is usually the least relevant thing. It's Kabuki theater... the way TV news is structured now, it's all about conflict... So the goal is, in that scenario, how do I get that me acting tough on camera?”

0.57

Future news must embrace transparent partisan framing with non-negotiable facts as audiences cluster ideologically, and subscriptions fund quality journalism.

6 pointscentrality 3/5
  • People are increasingly willing to pay for content and subscriptions are way up, reflecting a growing consciousness that you must support credible news sources financially or they will disappear, leaving people dependent on unreliable sources like 'uncle Fred on Facebook.'

    “the numbers show people are more and more willing to pay for their content. And subscriptions are way up... there's an increasing consciousness that you gotta support these sources... Or you end up with your uncle Fred giving you the news on Facebook.”

  • In the novel Savage News, drawn from real experience, a female reporter nails a scoop and runs to tell her boss, but by the time she gets on camera her male competitor reports the scoop she got — because the boss gave it to the guy — a 'cartoonishly evil' event that Yellin's reporter friends confirm happens 'all day, every day.'

    “she finally nails this one scoop... by the time she gets on the camera, she goes up live just as she watches her male competition report that scoop she got. And so the boss gave it to the guy... "No, no. It happened to me a minute ago."”

  • Yellin chose Instagram to deliver news because it lacks the 'fake news' patina, skews female (her first target audience), is a comparatively non-nasty environment, and nobody else was doing news there — making it a distinctive testing ground for a calmer format.

    “it doesn't have that same patina of, like, "Is there a fake news here?"... it's very female... People aren't nasty to each other on Instagram as much as they are on the other platforms... nobody was really doing the news there.”

  • Traditional TV news offers few real choices — like the old studio system, there are essentially six outlets (three networks and three cable channels) that all compete by the same rules, with CBS being the exception in trying to differentiate by being calmer and more substantive.

    “It's much more like the old studio system. You've three networks, and you've three cable channels, you've six outlets for TV news... And they all compete with each other and they play by the same rules. The exception is CBS, which has tried to differentiate itself by being calmer, more substantive.”

  • The future of news is increasingly partisan because consumers are clustering into red and blue like-minded communities — not just in news but in how they shop and live — and this cannot be reversed, so networks should respond by being transparent about their point of view while keeping facts non-negotiable.

    “I kind of think that's our future. We're dividing into red and blue as consumers. It's not just in news... we're clustering into communities of like-minded people... What's important is to now be transparent... And facts aren't negotiable, whatever your point of view.”

  • On Fox News the reporters were sourced, researched and professional, while the bias comes from the prime-time and later-afternoon opinion anchors who are 'untethered' from sourcing — a distinction hard for viewers to make, compounded because the majority of the audience comes from the opinion shows, giving incentive toward greater extremism.

    “the reporters were always kick-ass... The bias comes in the night time... the prime time shows... The reporters are reporting information, sourced, researched information. They sometimes have to report into anchors who are untethered from those things.”

0.56

Newsroom leadership homogeneity—predominantly white male executives from identical backgrounds—narrows what counts as news and alienates audiences.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Until recently the people running news divisions shared nearly identical backgrounds — mostly white men in their 50s from the Upper West Side of New York who went to the same schools and hold the same values — and this homogeneity shapes what they think 'works' as news, narrowing coverage.

    “the background of everybody who's a news president until recently has been the same. They're all, mostly all, white guys in their 50s, who grew up in Upper Westside of New York, and they have the same values and the same backgrounds, they all went to the same schools.”

  • More diversity (not just gender) at the highest levels of news companies is essential because who decides what counts as news is completely limited by one's own experience — a black woman from Ohio will consider different things newsworthy than someone from the Upper West Side of New York.

    “the background of everybody who's a news president until recently has been the same. They're all, mostly all, white guys in their 50s, who grew up in Upper Westside of New York, and they have the same values and the same backgrounds, they all went to the same schools.”

  • Because news executives operate within a framework that news must be told like sports — with conflict, jargon, competition, and outrage — they program everything through that filter, which alienates a huge audience who turn it off, thereby limiting the audience to people who want sports-like news and missing a massive unaddressed audience.

    “news needs to be told like sports. Viewers want news that feels like ESPN. So it has to be all that conflict jargon competition and outrage... so many people feel alienated by that sports-like coverage, they just turn it off... I believe that there's a massive unaddressed audience out there, and they're just missing the opportunity.”

0.56

Journalists have power to define what matters and should exercise editorial judgment rather than follow trending topics or false balance.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Journalists have more power than they use: a Chief White House Correspondent can make a story trend by deciding it is important, so reporters should run a vibrant editorial debate, choose the most important stories, and ignore what is trending on the website, because 'you are the media, you say what matters' — there is too much following and not enough defining of the conversation.

    “if you decide this is a big story, you can make that story trend... We follow too much, we forget the power we have. You are the media, you say what matters... not enough, "We define the conversation."”

  • There is nothing wrong with journalists choosing what to cover from the infinite set of facts, because you become a journalist precisely because the public trusts you to research and decide what matters; the cop-out 'we have to give both sides equal weight' (e.g., pro- and anti-climate change) is wrong because the journalist's job is to tell the public what is true.

    “You become a journalist because we're saying you're the one we trust to help decide what we're talking about. And what bothers me is when journalists say... "You gotta give both sides. We don't have a choice of pro-climate change and anti with equal weight"... you're there because we asked you to do the research and tell us what you think is true.”

  • It is effective and legitimate to state the same non-negotiable facts of an event and then allow a Democratic and a Republican interpretation of why it is at stalemate, showing the difference in viewpoint while keeping the underlying facts constant.

    “"Here are the facts of the shut down." If you're a Democrat, you'll make the case that the shut down is at stalemate for this reason. If you're a Republican, you'll make the case that it's at stalemate for this reason. So you're showing the difference but the facts of the shut down remain the same.”

0.53

Media literacy, explaining basic terms, breaking down candidate impact on voters' lives, and distinguishing news from noise are essential.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Since different outlets like Fox and MSNBC will marshal different facts on a topic, it is also the consumer's job to be news savvy — media literacy is a critical thinking skill, and journalists should help train people to evaluate sources (e.g., trusting a reported investigative story even from an outlet with an evident frame).

    “It's also the job of the consumer to be a little news savvy... it's just a critical thinking skill. And it's our job to help train people, maybe, "Here's some media literacy."”

  • Yellin's editorial method is to explicitly label coverage as either 'news' (information that matters and you should pay attention to) or 'noise' (stories getting attention that you can safely ignore, like celebrity gossip), teaching the audience to distinguish the two so they become better news consumers.

    “I say it's news, not noise... "This is news." And then I'll say, "Here's another story that got a ton of attention today in the news business. But it's noise."... it doesn't matter," so that's noise.”

  • Against the muscle-memory of racing to be first when news breaks, Yellin's project adopts a 'slow news' ethos — letting a story unfold and breathe before reporting it, then distilling it succinctly — and notes it is very hard to fully understand a complex situation and break it down in a short, accurate, clear way.

    “it's more important to process and distill a thing and then make it as succinct as possible for the viewer. And that means letting the story unfold, letting it breathe.”

  • Taking a minute to explain basic terms (like what 'closed session' or a 'tariff' means) and checking one's assumptions about audience understanding is, though it doesn't seem revolutionary, actually transformative because it picks up people who feel left out by the news and gets them to engage — which is literally how you inform the electorate in a democracy.

    “I know that doesn't seem revolutionary, but it is, because when you start to do that, you pick up people who feel left out by the news and they start to engage and care, and literally that's how you inform the electorate in a democracy.”

  • Many undecided voters, who are disproportionately women, are not actually inattentive; when probed they say they read and watch the news but it doesn't speak to them because coverage fails to break down how each candidate's win would concretely change their lives, and fails to explain basic terms like tariffs or tax reform.

    “what they say is, "No, no, I'm reading things, I'm watching the news, it doesn't speak to me."... what they're literally saying is, "If this candidate wins, how will it change my life?"... We're not breaking it down in a way that connects on a level that's personal.”

0.51

Better formats exist: presenting agreements first before disputes, interviewing single guests deeply, and delivering solutions alongside hard stories.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Opinionated TV voices have become so extreme that there is no real conversation, just talking points flung back and forth, which prevents any learning; better formats would be the Dutch 'hot tub' (experts first submit their area of agreement, then testify to differences) or the British model of going deep with one guest at a time rather than two heads shouting.

    “the opinionated voices have become so extreme, there's no conversation anymore, it's just talking points being flung back and forth, and that's why you never get learning.”

  • Audiences want solutions and a reason to feel good about the world: even when a hard story like a government shutdown has no resolution, pairing it with a story of a problem being solved (e.g., a company rescuing garbage from the ocean) reminds people that over history humans have solved hard problems, giving optimism that current problems can be solved too.

    “people want solutions... here's a story about a company that's rescuing garbage out of the ocean and they've had enormous success. As long as you're reminding people that over the course of history we've found ways to solve the hard problems, it gives them the optimism to feel this too can be solved.”

0.51

Individual trusted voices publishing directly on platforms will replace the studio system as audiences follow credible journalists they trust.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The future of news will move away from the network 'studio system' (where reporters are bound to one outlet) toward individual credible reporters publishing their well-sourced, well-researched information directly on platforms like Facebook and Instagram, with audiences following the individuals they trust — because getting news on social media does not mean people don't want credible journalism.

    “I think the future is all of that is gonna be... People will leave and you'll be seeing individual reporters on Facebook and Instagram... people will start to follow the individuals they trust... it is a mistake to assume that because you're getting your news on social people don't want credible journalism.”

  • A single trusted voice with the size of following Walter Cronkite once had will never exist again, but the future will instead have many individual trusted voices, each with a large following in their own space.

    “It's like the Walter Cronkite effect. He'll never exist again with that size of a following, but you'll have individuals who are trusted voices in different spaces.”

0.43

Women's engagement with news improves when coverage emphasizes human impact and empathy rather than theoretical game-like conflict.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Research shows coverage differs by the gender of who runs the newsroom: when a woman runs it, stories feature more humans describing personal impact and are more empathic and connected to the human level, whereas men's coverage is more theoretical, focused on the game and the fight — which Yellin's thesis says explains why women engage less with political and foreign coverage that isn't connected to 'the you.'

    “when you have a woman running a newsroom versus a man running a newsroom, the way the coverage is done is very different... much more about... "It impacted me this way."... when the guys are doing it, it's much more theoretical, the game, the fight. And this is my thesis on why they say women like political and foreign coverage less, because we don't take the time to connect it to the you.”

  • Yellin's approach is not to cover 'women's news' (baking, fashion, home) but to cover the same hard topics — Syria, Yemen — while bringing feminine values into how she makes sense of them, deliberately countering her own hardwired training to cover news as sports.

    “people think, "Oh, you're doing girls news or women's news." No, no, no. I'm doing the news... Syria's there. What's the latest in Yemen... I try to think of the stories, and bring feminine values into the way I make sense of it.”

  • A significant, heavily female portion of the population engages in 'news avoidance' — wanting information but turning it off or not seeking it — not because bad news is scary or they don't care, but because the tone, negativity, and yelling triggers anxiety they cannot engage with given their busy lives.

    “I looked at something specifically called "news avoidance."... it is triggering so much anxiety in a part of the population. They just can't engage. It's heavily female but not exclusively... it's the tone and the negativity and that yelling.”