species
A group of organisms capable of interbreeding and producing fertile offspring, reproductively isolated from other groups
As defined in Freeman Dyson: Heretical Thoughts About Science and Society
Where it comes up · 3
- Freeman Dyson: Heretical Thoughts About Science and Society7 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 23 Problem of Universals6 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 12 Aristotle's God3 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 16Search all claims for “species” →
- Knowledge of the essential nature (differentia) of a genus or species is foundational to logical argument: one cannot infer anything about things in a genus or species unless one knows something true about their nature; one cannot argue about being without knowing the nature of being, nor about human nature without knowing what makes humans human.A History of Philosophy | 12 Aristotle's God
- Conceptualism, represented by Abelard, holds a compromise position: unlike nominalism, it affirms that universal concepts exist in the mind and that we think universal concepts separately from particulars, developing abstract general ideas. Unlike realism, however, it denies that real universals exist outside the mind in either transcendent or immanent form.A History of Philosophy | 23 Problem of Universals
- Boethius formulated the problem of universals in three primary questions: (1) Do genera and species really exist in nature outside the mind or are they merely mental constructs? (2) If they are realities, are they material or immaterial (transcendent in a Platonic sense or materialized in particulars)? (3) Do they exist apart from particulars or within them? A fourth question was added: Are universal concepts thought separately from particulars?A History of Philosophy | 23 Problem of Universals
- Extreme or exaggerated realism, ascribed to John Scotus Eriugena and sometimes to Anselm, holds that forms of species and genera exist in reality separately from particulars while each particular participates in that one and the same form, and these forms exist both transcendently and in particulars such that there is a numerically identical form recurring in every particular case. Individuals are differentiated only by their degree of privation—their degree of non-participation in the full form.A History of Philosophy | 23 Problem of Universals
- William of Champeaux initially advocated exaggerated realism but came under criticism from Roscelin and Abelard, causing him to retreat to a position known as indifferentism, in which forms exist only in the reality of particulars (not in a transcendent sense), with all members of a species indifferently participating in that one and the same form.A History of Philosophy | 23 Problem of Universals
- Bonaventure's response to Averroism posits that archetypal forms (exemplars) exist in the mind of God, such that God is thinking not merely on his own thinking but on archetypal ideas. Since God's mind contains archetypes of all individual qualities and possible combinations thereof, God can think every particular combination of qualities and thus know and create individuals, making God an efficient cause rather than merely a final cause.A History of Philosophy | 23 Problem of Universals
- Aquinas uses the language of 'natures' rather than 'forms of individuals' to describe the particular essential properties of individual creatures, but these individual natures include the essence of the whole species. In knowing all forms (universals), God thereby knows all individuals within each species, including every particular individual nature.A History of Philosophy | 23 Problem of Universals
- Aristotle introduces the terms 'species,' 'genera' (singular: genus), and 'differentia' as a system of classification: species are classified into larger genera and families, and differentia are the essential properties that distinguish one species or genus from another.A History of Philosophy | 12 Aristotle's God
- There was a golden age of pre-Darwinian life when horizontal gene transfer was universal and separate species did not exist; life was a community of cells sharing genetic information, allowing clever chemical tricks invented by one cell to be inherited by all, enabling rapid communal evolution.Freeman Dyson: Heretical Thoughts About Science and Society
- Carl Woese discovered the large-scale Tree of Life structure with all creatures descended from three primordial branches; he recently published work showing that Darwinian evolution based on non-interbreeding species did not begin at the origin of life.Freeman Dyson: Heretical Thoughts About Science and Society