socialist calculation debate
The 20th-century economic argument over whether a centrally planned economy can rationally allocate resources without market prices, which free-market economists are said to have won.
As defined in Robert Chitester on Milton Friedman and Free to Choose
Other definitions
The early-20th-century debate over whether a centrally planned economy could rationally allocate resources without market prices, associated with Mises and Hayek.
Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the GoodThe interwar debate over whether a socialist economy could allocate resources efficiently by simulating market outcomes without real markets, with Hayek arguing it could not because knowledge is dispersed and tacit.
Stephen Marglin on Markets and Community 03/10/2008
Where it comes up · 8
- Robert Chitester on Milton Friedman and Free to Choose2 claims
- Michael Munger on Free Markets2 claims
- Bruce Caldwell on Hayek1 claim
- Larry White on the Clash of Economic Ideas1 claim
- Don Boudreaux on Reading Hayek1 claim
- Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion1 claim
- Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good1 claim
- Arnold Kling on Knowledge, Power, and Unchecked and Unbalanced 09/06/20101 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “socialist calculation debate” →
- Prices enable many individuals, none of whom has complete knowledge of the economy, to act as if they know enough about what others are doing so that their actions become coordinated and produce productive economic activity rather than chaos.Don Boudreaux on Reading Hayek
- The Hayekian socialist calculation insight—that dispersed knowledge cannot be aggregated into a central computer—means a competent 'super regulator' who knows whom to ask and obtains the right information is fundamentally elusive, a conclusion people find counterintuitive and prefer not to be true.Arnold Kling on Knowledge, Power, and Unchecked and Unbalanced 09/06/2010
- Mises, not Hayek, was the central figure in the socialist calculation debate: he pointed out in his 1920 article that under state ownership of the means of production there are no prices for factors of production, making rational production decisions impossible; Hayek is better known largely because The Road to Serfdom was popular in the American context and because he wrote in English during the formative 1930s debate.Bruce Caldwell on Hayek
- The economists' view of property rights is Humean—a useful convention that helps societies that adopt it—while the Lockean moral argument for property as inviolable or inalienable is taught almost nowhere in philosophy classes, where Nozick is presented mainly as a foil to Rawls believed to be decisively refuted, leaving the moral case for property without authority.Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good
- Conflating the Soviet Union and Sweden as 'socialist' is a fundamental abuse of the word: in the Soviet Union the means of production, allocation of workers, salaries, and even where people lived were controlled by a centralized state that was fundamentally corrupt because it had no competition, whereas Sweden is a market economy with a large safety net.Robert Chitester on Milton Friedman and Free to Choose
- The case for giving locally is not that you care more about your own child than a distant one, but that local knowledge lets you actually observe and verify the effect of your money—you can see whether your community center functions—whereas distant interventions by well-funded outsiders often fail with unintended consequences, echoing the socialist calculation debate's point that the top can never access the dispersed information needed.Erik Hoel on Effective Altruism, Utilitarianism, and the Repugnant Conclusion
- Friedman, Hayek, and von Mises won both the intellectual argument (the socialist calculation debate, that markets allocate resources better than top-down planning) and the practical argument (the people of the Soviet Union simply didn't live well), as Friedman emphasized when he credited New Zealand's experience, not his own persuasion, for discrediting inflationary money printing.Robert Chitester on Milton Friedman and Free to Choose
- The debate Keynes and Hayek began in the 1930s recurs in different forms across time and place—Germany's price controls after the war, India's five-year planning after independence, post-war Britain's nationalizations, and the present—always centering on whether there should be more or less government rather than more or less bottom-up emergent decision-making, though the specific forms of intervention differ.Larry White on the Clash of Economic Ideas
- Every flaw that afflicts consumers (ignorance, susceptibility to fraud) is worse in voters, with the added problem that a consumer who buys bad cornflakes learns and switches while a voter's single vote has no effect on the outcome and is merely expressive, so democracy is not a reliable substitute for market allocation.Michael Munger on Free Markets
- Anyone claiming to do better than market allocation must propose an institution, and there are only two candidates: an unaccountable priesthood of experts who lack information and tend to protect their own privileges (the Hayekian socialist-calculation problem), or democracy, which merely returns to rationally ignorant voters.Michael Munger on Free Markets