simultaneity
The notion of two events happening 'at the same time'; special relativity shows there is no unique cross-space simultaneity.
As defined in 140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain
Where it comes up · 8
- 140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain2 claims
- Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Adam Brown – A deep but accessible introduction to general relativity1 claim
- 318 - Physics Philosophy1 claim
- 115 - Sam Harris Lawrence Krauss And Matt Dillahunty 11 claim
- AMA | Feb 20261 claim
- AMA | March 20211 claim
- AMA | September 20241 claim
- Sean Carroll: Einstein’s most radical thought1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “simultaneity” →
- In special relativity there is no objective fact about whether a distant event (like a Mars landing) has 'already happened,' because observers moving at different speeds disagree; the only physically real notion is whether the event is in your past light cone, not whether it is simultaneous with 'now.'AMA | March 2021
- Relativity shows you cannot uniquely slice the universe into a single present moment—there is infinite freedom in defining 'now' for events far from you—so a presentist claiming only the present is real must either accept that the simultaneity question (what is happening now on Alpha Centauri) is a bad question, or adopt a more radical fully-local definition of the present.140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain
- Because faster-than-light travel creates problems with simultaneity and causality, it is safer for both physics and fiction to exclude faster-than-light travel entirely.AMA | September 2024
- Our intuition of a universal 'now' is wrong; because light and sound take time to travel and one can never be in two places at once as a classical being, simultaneity is relative—different observers, especially those moving fast, can have different nows and even reversed event sequences—yet the universe permits this only by an amount that never lets cause and effect be reversed for any observer.115 - Sam Harris Lawrence Krauss And Matt Dillahunty 1
- Relativity replaces Newton's universal global simultaneity (a stack of cosmic instants) with an objective light-cone structure: events in your future light cone are objectively later, events in your past cone objectively earlier, and space-like-separated events have no definite temporal order—yet none of this removes the fundamental directedness of time.318 - Physics Philosophy
- Describing the universe as a vector in Hilbert space evolving through time seems to assume a Newtonian universal time line where each moment maps to a single state of the whole universe, which contradicts relativity's lack of simultaneity across distances, creating a tension that needs reconciling.AMA | Feb 2026
- The brain evolved to rely heavily on simultaneity between sensory modalities to make sense of the world—e.g., seeing lips move while hearing a voice leads the brain to attribute the sound to the speaker (or to a ventriloquist's dummy)—and this built-in addiction to simultaneity may bias and confuse our interpretation of physics, where special relativity teaches that cross-space simultaneity is an unhelpful concept.140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain
- In spacetime, different observers moving at different velocities through the universe will divide spacetime into space and time components differently; there is no objective absolute fact about what is happening at a distant location at a given moment—simultaneity is relative to the observer.Sean Carroll: Einstein’s most radical thought
- General relativity could in principle be reconstructed from a few inputs, namely the finiteness of light speed, the relativity symmetry from special relativity, and the equivalence principle, and a finite tree of options could be explored systematically by many large language models.Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Adam Brown – A deep but accessible introduction to general relativity