settler colonialism
A theory holding that countries founded by European settlement remain permanently shaped by the original sin of colonization, so present-day problems are explained by reference to that founding and the society is treated as fundamentally illegitimate.
As defined in Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch)
Other definitions
Academic framework that categorizes modern nation-states established by European settlement as oppressive, analogous to colonialism; used in universities to frame Israel-Palestine conflict and Western history
“The Treason of the Intellectuals,” with Niall Ferguson | Uncommon Knowledge
Where it comes up · 9
- Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch)17 claims
- 393 - Is History Repeating Itself3 claims
- 340 - The Bright Line Between Good And Evil2 claims
- Israel, Islam & the New Cold War | Niall Ferguson1 claim
- 357 - America World Order1 claim
- Douglas Murray1 claim
- “The Treason of the Intellectuals,” with Niall Ferguson | Uncommon Knowledge1 claim
- Ilan Pappé on Israel and Epstein and Why Zionism has No Moral Limits1 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 28Search all claims for “settler colonialism” →
- In settler colonial ideology there are only two categories—settler or indigenous—so anyone not indigenous occupies the position of settler regardless of when they arrived or their history, including recent immigrants from East Asia and even descendants of enslaved Africans, who are still classed as settlers because they live on land that 'doesn't belong' to them.Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch)
- Settler colonialism treats colonization as 'a structure, not an event'—not a past historical sin but one living in the present—so that disavowing one's settler status is itself taken as proof of being a settler with an incorrect mindset, making the framework self-sealing against disagreement.Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch)
- The original post-WWII concept of a 'settler colony' (e.g., Algeria, Rhodesia) referred to colonies where Europeans settled as a distinct minority class but did not replace the native population, so decolonization meant removing the settlers—fundamentally different from administrative colonies like India where there was little settlement.Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch)
- Settler colonialism as a theory does not assert any new facts about American, Australian, or Canadian history—the conquest and displacement of Native peoples has always been known—rather it makes moral and theoretical claims about present obligations: how we should remember those events, analyze them, and think of ourselves as inheriting them.Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch)
- Although Israel has defeated every attempt to destroy it and emerged as the region's strongest country, this never changes how it is discussed by critics: for them it is perpetually 1948, with everything since treated as a temporary injustice destined to be wiped out—structurally identical to the way settler colonialists say North America will one day revert to Native land.Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch)
- Actual Native American advocacy groups do not use the language of settler colonialism or see themselves as fighting a decolonization struggle; they pursue legal means to hold the US government to treaties and agreements—indicating that the ideology is really a conversation among settlers about themselves rather than a practical program for indigenous people.Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch)
- Israel's founding does not fit the colonial model of the Belgian Congo or British India because the Jews who arrived were mostly refugees fleeing Arab and European Jew-hatred and the Holocaust, and Zionism understood itself as returning a persecuted, never-fully-accepted people to their indigenous homeland—so the Jews regard themselves, not only Palestinians, as the indigenous people of the land.Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch)
- Actual historians of Native America have mixed feelings about settler colonialism: it draws attention to indigenous suffering, but it is fundamentally unhistorical because expansion often involved wars between two powerful peoples over territory, and calling that a 'genocide' falsely implies a Holocaust-style deliberate extermination that does not describe North American history.Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch)
- For the purpose of understanding why the conflict is intractable, historical context is a distraction because any group can arbitrarily decide where to set the dial on its time machine; the absence of suicide bombers among oppressed peoples like Native Americans, Tibetan Buddhists, and Palestinian Christians proves that a history of land theft and oppression is not sufficient to produce genocidal terrorism — ideas matter.340 - The Bright Line Between Good And Evil
- Settler colonialism is a critical theory in which settlement and colonialism serve as the master term for understanding a society's problems, analogous to how earlier critical theories used race and slavery, or before that property and capitalist exploitation, as the central explanatory frame—so it has little to do with practical issues affecting living Native communities.Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch)