
“The Treason of the Intellectuals,” with Niall Ferguson | Uncommon Knowledge
What this covers
This is a conversation between Peter Robinson and Niall Ferguson, recorded in January 2024, about Ferguson's Free Press essay on the politicization of American universities. Ferguson builds the case around a historical analogy with Weimar-era Germany. German universities in 1924 were the best in the world, already conservative because they drew on the social elite, and the shock of defeat in 1918 pushed students and professors toward the Nazis. He leans on Max Weber's separation of Wissenschaft from Politik from Politik (Politics)) as the standard that professors betray when they use institutional privilege for political ends, whether on the right or the left.
The historical material is where the argument turns most contentious. Ferguson says Adolf Hitler's Mein Kampf offered no clear path to mass murder, and that the detailed justification and mechanisms came from university departments rather than Joseph Goebbels's propaganda ministry. He also describes antisemitism institutionalized at Marburg before 1933, and a flood of opportunists into the Nazi party only after the dictatorship was secure. He maps that believer-and-opportunist dynamic onto DEI bureaucracies, which he calls Newspeak and which he says offer careers to those who will enforce conformity.
The conversation then turns to the present. Ferguson covers the Harvard student groups' statements after October 7th, the Soviet roots of leftist anti-Zionism, and what he sees as an odd alliance of progressives and Islamists, which he links to the treatment of Ayaan Hirsi Ali. He also discusses the resignation of Claudine Gay, covering her plagiarism and her congressional testimony on speech versus conduct. On remedies, he rejects endowment taxes and warns that federal funding brings Title IX obligations. He argues instead for new institutions such as the University of Austin, which would pressure incumbents through competition.
Ferguson argues that American universities have undergone ideological capture by a progressive-left ideology (wokeism/DEI) similar to how German universities were captured by the radical right in the 1920s-30s, with both representing a betrayal of the fundamental academic principle separating scholarship from politics, and that this threatens democratic discourse and minority rights—specifically evidenced by widespread anti-Semitism on campuses post-October 7th.
- German universities' pre-Nazi ideological rightward shift and subsequent capture created intellectual infrastructure for Nazi ideology and Holocaust planning; American universities' leftward capture through DEI is creating similar intellectual justification for anti-Semitism and anti-Israel positions.
- The speed and totality of ideological uniformity in American academia—where 60% of students fear speaking freely—mirrors the rapid institutional capture in Weimar Germany, showing how universities become instruments of ideology rather than truth-seeking.
- The solution is not regulatory reform of existing institutions but the creation of new institutions (University of Austin) that enforce the separation of scholarship from politics through constitutional governance protections.
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Ferguson argues a strong version of the comparison: the lesson of German history is that universities helped to produce the Holocaust, showing that universities provided the intellectual scaffolding and technocratic sophistication necessary for mass systematic murder.
“the lesson of German history for American Academia should now be clear in Germany to use the legalistic language of 2023 speech crossed into conduct the final solution of the Jewish question began as speech to be precise it began as lectures and monographs and scholarly articles”
Max Weber argued there should be a clear distinction between politics (politik) and science or scholarship (wissenschaft), and when professors forget this separation and use their institutional privilege to pursue political agendas—whether right or left—it constitutes a betrayal of the fundamental ideals of the university.
“Max vber uh perhaps the founder of Sociology a great German thinker uh gave a a memorable lecture more than a hundred years ago in which he argued that there should be a clear distinction between politi and visen shaft between politics and science or let's call it uh scholarship and that is the Betrayal when you forget about that separation and use your privilege which you have uh as a professor to pursue a political agenda and it doesn't matter whether you're leaning to the right in your politics or to the left it's treason to the ideals of the university”
Hitler's ideas in Mein Kampf about race and living space were borrowed from various quarters including the United States, and there was no very clear path in Mein Kampf to a solution of the Jewish question; in order to achieve the merger (sic—murder) of roughly six million Jews, you need some people to articulate the mechanisms, and what is striking about German Academia in the 1920s and 1930s is the amount of research produced to explain why you would want to annihilate the mentally ill, drive Jews out of Eastern Europe, and create living space—this production of detail is not the work of Goebbels's propaganda ministry but of people working in German university departments.
“Hitler was not uh a tremendously sophisticated thinker uh what's in M Camp is a rag bag of ideas about race uh about living space uh borrowed from various quarters including the United States a lot of Hitler's ideas about race actually come from the United States same goes for the Nazis Embrace of eugenics uh there's not a very clear path in mine Camp to uh a solution of quote unquote the Jewish question uh in order to achieve the merger of roughly six million Jews uh you need some people to uh articulate the mechanisms and what is very striking to me about German Academia uh in the 1920s and 1930s before the outbreak uh of World War II before the Holocaust in fact begins is the amount of research that's produced to for example explain why you would want uh to annihilate the mentally ill uh to explain why you would want to drive Jews and slaves out of Eastern Europe to create a new German living space uh and this production of the detail uh of what we have come to call the Holocaust uh is not the work of gbl's propaganda Ministry much of it is the work of people working in departments and German universities”
For nearly 10 years, Ferguson has observed treason among his fellow intellectuals in academia, defined as the betrayal of the fundamental academic role by pursuing specific political goals while pretending to engage in scholarship.
“for nearly 10 years I have marveled at the treason of my fellow intellectuals”
The Nazi party experienced massive membership increases after Hitler clearly established a dictatorship in 1933, not before—this occurred when it became risky to be a Nazi before 1933 when the party was oppositional and street fighting was part of politics, but once the Nazis won, opportunists flooded in; this distinction between 'believers' and 'opportunists' explains how ideologies capture institutions.
“it was risky be to be a Nazi before 1933 uh you were part of an oppositional movement and you were quite likely to be involved in violence because street fighting was part of of the name of the game in late viar Germany but after Hitler's clearly established a dictatorship and the Nazis have won the opportunists flock now you might think that this is an an allery to an analogy too far but I don't think it is because what's fascinating about academic life in America in the last 10 years is that the ideology of diversity equity and inclusion let's call it workism for sure has been a great career opportunity for some people”
If it becomes conventional wisdom on campus that 'from the river to the sea Palestine shall be free' and Israel should be wiped from the map and Hamas is engaged in a legitimate insurrection, then educated America is endorsing a second Holocaust because that is what Hamas explicitly intends—Iran and its proxies are explicit about wishing to wipe Israel from the map.
“if it becomes uh the conventional wisdom on uh campus uh that uh from uh The River To The Sea Palestine shall be free and Israel should be wiped from the map and that Hamas is legitimate as engaged in a legitimate uh Insurrection against the settler colonists then at the very least you have a significant proportion of educated America endorsing a second Holocaust because that's what Hamas had in mind that's what we saw a trailer for on October the 7th”
Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) is Newspeak in the Orwellian sense—it means the exact opposite of what it claims: 'diversity' actually means uniformity of ideological outlook, 'equity' means absence of due process when the DEI bureaucracy acts, and 'inclusion' actually means exclusion of those who don't conform to progressive left ideology.
“diversity Equity inclusion is a kind of newsp speaking or wels sense it actually means the exact opposite of what what it says the diversity the asart to is uniformity univers uniformity of ideological Outlook Equity is actually uh entirely absent because there's no due process when the Dei bureaucracy goes into action uh and as for inclusion the real objective is exclusion of those who are not conforming to the ideology of the progressive left”
The only solution to the problem of enormous non-academic bureaucracies is to start over with new institutions designed without these bureaucracies, because once bureaucracies exist, they are very hard to get rid of; if the University of Austin succeeds in creating a new model that actually believes what it says about pursuing truth, it will ideally force older institutions to change their ways.
“I think the only solution because it's very hard to get rid of these bureaucracies once they exist is start over and if we succeed in Austin if we can create a new model of University that doesn't work like the old ones but actually believes what it says about pursuing truth then ideally we'll Force these uh older institutions to change their ways the simplest way to win this fight is to create a better institution that attracts the smartest people as students and the smartest people as professors once you start attracting those people the Money Follows and pretty quickly people have to shape up and they have to change their ways”
German universities in 1924 were the greatest universities in the world, dominant in almost every field, while American universities by comparison were 'country clubs'; if you wanted to be taken seriously as an ambitious scientist or classicist, you had to get your PhD from Germany even if your first degree was from Oxford or Cambridge.
“it's 1924 and the greatest universities in the world and not Harvard and Stanford and Yale the greatest universities are Heidelberg and marberg tuban kbur the great German universities they were really dominant in almost every Field 100 years ago uh by comparison the American universities were country clubs the Nobel prizes were won by German professors if you were an ambitious scientist or classicist and you had your first degree from Oxford Cambridge you had to get your PhD from Germany if you wanted to be taken seriously”
At Marburg University, the student association for Jewish students was effectively prescribed (banned) long before Hitler came to power, demonstrating how anti-Semitism became institutionalized within universities before the Nazi regime formalized it.
“in marberg the the student uh Association for Jewish students was effectively prescribed long before Hitler came to power”
Claudine Gay's testimony before Congress drew a distinction between speech (mere words) and conduct, claiming that speech alone would not result in disciplinary action but conduct violating policies against bullying, harassment, or intimidation would—but this position contradicted her own record as dean of the faculty, where she actively went after those who spoke in ways considered unacceptable by progressive academics.
“the only thing wrong with it was that that had not been her position prior to those hearings and we know this because uh in her time as a dean of the faculty of Arts and Sciences Claudine gay was quite active in going after those who spoke in ways that were considered uh by her and other uh Progressive uh academic administrators to be unacceptable”
Claudine Gay's plagiarism was serial and obvious, involving repeated instances that any professional academic would recognize at a glance, including even plagiarism of the acknowledgement section—something Ferguson claims he had never seen before—and Harvard students were severely disciplined for far less plagiarism during Ferguson's time at Harvard.
“it was serial plagiarism and uh the things that claudi and gay did were things that Harvard students were severely disciplined for uh during the time that I was at and any professional academic knew it at a glance isn't that right yes this was not controversial and it was of course bizarre that anybody should have tried to rationalize what was clearly very extreme and obvious and repeated plagiarism plagiarism even of the acknowledgement section which I'd never seen before quite remarkable”
The proper constitutional protection of free speech and academic freedom within universities needs to be actually enforced; merely adopting principles like the 'Chicago Principles' is insufficient if undergraduates feel they cannot speak freely due to fear of consequences.
“it's all very well having the Chicago principles and they sound Grand but if they're not enforced uh if undergraduates don't feel free to speak because they may be consequences then what use are they so the University of Austin will be quite unique in that it will Model A New Kind kind of academic governance in which the freedom of students and professors alike will be protected and that freedom will be enforced”
The United States offers really quite terrific protections from state interference in speech—you are allowed to say really obnoxious things; however, if you engage in violence or explicitly threaten violent acts based on hateful statements, you come out from under the protection of the First Amendment; this distinction between protected speech and unprotected incitement to violence is clarified in a very clear body of US law going back many decades.
“actually the United States offers really quite terrific protections at least from the states uh in interference in speech you are allowed to say really obnoxious things in this country uh that that's the nature of freedom but if you were to start uh acting on the basis of your hateful statements uh engaging in violence against minorities or explicitly threatening to do uh violent acts then you would have actually uh come out from under the protection of the First Amendment there's a very clear body of law uh in the United States that goes back many decades that clarifies what Free Speech means here”
The unholy alliance between radical leftists, gay rights activists, and Islamists opposed to Ayaan Hirsi Ali—who mystified Ferguson at the time—shows how different ideological factions can unite around opposition to a common enemy (or target) despite their actual values being incompatible.
“being kind of mystified by this Unholy alliance between uh radical leftists uh gay rights activists and islamists who thought that somebody uh like my wife should be publicly uh humiliated as of course she was to be disinvited publicly uh in that way”
German universities were already right-leaning before World War I, not because of any special German characteristic but because the social elite attended universities, making them inherently conservative; the trauma of military defeat in 1918 then created a backlash that made students and professors highly attracted to Hitler and the Nazi Party.
“if you look at these institutions is that they were already right leaning even before World War I now we we we tend to assume universities role was liberal but that's not right it's just that historically universities tend to have a leaning and the leaning in Germany prior to 1914 was conservative uh and perhaps that shouldn't surprise us because it was the social Elite that went to University uh it was a much narrower section of society then than today the trauma of defeat uh in 1918 uh led to a tremendous backlash a backlash not only uh against the viar Republic the successor to the Imperial regime uh but I think broadly a a backlash against many other things associated with defeat a backlash against uh the Anglo-Saxon powers that had won the war uh and it was in this context that many students and professors were highly attracted by an exciting new demagogic figure Adolf Hitler”
Congress could address the problem through tax policy changes to limit university endowments, but Ferguson opposes this approach as incompatible with America's private philanthropic model and warns that federal funding brings Title IX and other government obligations that contribute to the problems.
“I I would say the the solution to the problem of the excessive wealth of Harvard uh is for donors to stop giving it money that it clearly doesn't need and wasts uh I would rather they gave the money uh to a new institution...the American solution shouldn't be government needs to fix this the American solution should be let's stop giving money to these institutions they're not fit for purpose”
The American solution to institutional failure has historically been to create new institutions rather than reform old ones, as exemplified by the University of Chicago and Stanford, and this approach is preferable to government involvement.
“the American solution to the problem of the excessive wealth of Harvard uh is for donors to stop giving it money that it clearly doesn't need and wasts uh I would rather they gave the money uh to a new institution that would make much better use of it and that's why I prefer an authentically American solution to this problem which is these universities don't work very well let's create some new ones that was the spirit that produced the University of Chicago and the university that we're sitting in today at Stanford”
Oxford and Cambridge did not worry about doctorates until German universities started awarding them and gained prestige, forcing English universities to adapt their practices in response to competitive pressure—demonstrating that institutions do change in response to competition.
“Oxford and Cambridge didn't worry about doctorates until the German University started to and in many ways the American universities were modeled off the German universities in their Heyday nothing stays the same oddly enough Academia for all that it appears unworldly is a very competitive place and there really is still in the end a market for genius and a market for new ideas”
Anti-Zionism was part of late Cold War Soviet propaganda strategy when the Soviets were losing in the Middle East and being squeezed out, making hostility to Israel and support for Arab nationalism part of leftist ideology as early as the 1980s.
“this had always been a part of the leftist propaganda of the late Cold War anti-zionism was part of what the Soviets did when they found that they were really badly losing in the Middle East and were gradually being uh squeezed out uh hostility uh to Israel support for Arab nationalists was part and parcel of Soviet strategy hence anti-zionism was a part of the left's propaganda uh when I was a student in the 1980s”
Hitler's anti-Semitism functioned as a career opportunity for non-Jewish professors: Jewish professors were removed from their jobs (as civil servants they could be purged), creating openings for Gentile professors—this self-interested mechanism for adopting an ideology is similar to how DEI in American universities functions as a career opportunity for those willing to enforce it against ideological opponents.
“in the case of uh Germany in the 1930s who whom was that uh the Gentile professors could screw over the Jewish ones Jewish professors were removed from their jobs because professors were civil servants in effect in the German system uh they were kicked out of their jobs it's one of the earliest things that the Nazis actually do when they come to Paris to purge the Civil Service of Jews uh that's a terrific career opportunity uh if you're not Jewish and you can avoid the purge uh and so you see the self-interest that motivated certain people to become Nazis”
More than 30 Harvard student groups issued a statement condoning Hamas's behavior and the atrocities of October 7th, after which university authorities were unable to express anything beyond 'lame bromides'.
“more than 30 Harvard student groups issue a statement condoning hamas's atrocious uh Behaviour the violence the rape the uh the atrocities of October the 7th 1200 slaughtered and that in the wake of those public statements the university authorities at Harvard and elsewhere seemed unable to uh Express anything uh Beyond uh lame Bromides”
The most direct way to win the institutional competition is to create a better university that attracts the smartest students and professors; once people flock to the new institution, money follows and established universities are forced to change their ways to remain competitive.
“the simplest way to win this fight is to create a better institution that attracts the smartest people as students and the smartest people as professors once you start attracting those people the Money Follows and pretty quickly people have to shape up and they have to change their ways”
In the span of approximately 10 years, wokeism has transitioned from being a fringe fashion to becoming the dominant ideology of major American universities, with sufficient power to determine who becomes university president.
“in the space of about 10 years that what you might call wokeism has gone from being a fringe fashion to being the dominant ideology of the major universities so dominant that it has led to appointments like the now former president of Harvard Claudine gay”
The Harvard Corporation should never have appointed Claudine Gay president in the first place, and if Harvard simply appoints a new president chosen by the same Corporation, nothing fundamentally will change because the problem is not personnel but the entire system of university governance.
“har Corporation should never have appointed claan gay president in the first place I mean and if thing predictably followed from that decision if all that happens at Harvard is that there's a new president chosen by the same Corporation nothing fundamentally will change and one must understand Peter and I don't want to make this all about Harvard this is a problem for all universities it's a problem also for Stanford”
Part of the problem at universities is that government got too involved in their finances and then started getting involved in their governance; Title IX officers are an example of government-mandated bureaucracy; there are almost as many Title IX officers as DEI officers at universities, and both are part of the problem because these universities are rich and allowed to grow enormous bureaucracies of non-academics not engaged in research or teaching but purely in administration.
“because remember part of the problem here Peter is that the government got too involved in the universities it got too involved in their finances and then it started getting involved in their governance and Title 9 is a good example of the problem there are almost as many Title 9 officers I would guess at this University as Dei officers and they're all part of the problem these universities are rich because they're rich they were allowed to have they are allowed to grow these enormous bureaucracies of non-academics people not engaged in research or in teaching purely engaged in administration they're a huge part of the problem”
The Third Reich is distinctive and different from the Soviet Union because of the extreme sophistication with which its program of mass systematic murder was carried out—it was a more sophisticated operation than any other genocide or democide in history because it had at its disposal the most sophisticated technocratic elite that the world then had: the German technocratic elite.
“what makes the Third Reich distinctive makes it different the from the Soviet Union is the extreme sophistication with which a program of mass systematic murder is carried out uh it is a very much more sophisticated operation than any other genocide or democide if you want to use that term in history and that's because it had at its disposal the most sophisticated technocratic Elite that the world then had and that was the the German technocratic Elite”
The problem of ideological capture, politicization, and perversion of the university's pursuit of truth exists throughout American Academia, not just at Harvard—around 60% of students across the country (even at Chicago, which prides itself on free speech culture) say they feel uncomfortable speaking their minds in class because of potential consequences.
“it's a problem throughout American Academia it's a problem of ideological capture of politicization of the perversion of the institution its deviation from The Pursuit Of Truth and the pursuit of of of thinking that is truly free uh in order to fix this we need more than a new Harvard President We need a fundamental change in in the nature of University governance uh from top to bottom okay two quotations both posts from Twitter quotation number one from a post by Constantine kissen if I'm pronouncing his name correctly quote one of the biggest benefits of Bill amman's successful campaign to dismantle discriminatory practices at Elite colleges is that it proves something that many of us have been saying for a long time all it takes is for a few people with power money and influence to start standing up to this crap and it'll be over... around 60% of students across the country say they feel uncomfortable speaking their minds in class uh because of the consequences that might follow uh this is even true at Chicago which Prides itself on on its uh Free Speech culture”
The only good thing that came out of October 7th was that it made people in the United States, Britain, and the anglosphere realize that there is a major problem with a new kind of anti-Semitism that is entrenched among young people because universities have been teaching a particular brand of politics and history depicting Israel as settler colonialism and Palestinians as victims of white supremacy, with Jews portrayed as the leading exponents of that oppression.
“and the only good thing that came of October the 7th the only good thing was that it made people in the United States and elsewhere in Britain too realize that the anglosphere as a whole has a major problem with a new kind of anti-Semitism and it is entrenched amongst young people and it's entrenched because the universal ities have been teaching a particular brand of of politics and history uh that depict Israel as just the latest manifestation of settler colonialism and portrays the Palestinians as the latest victims of uh white supremacy of which somehow the Jews have become the leading exponents”
Setting aside academic standards to pursue DEI creates a correlation between DEI-based hiring and plagiarism in university leadership, because inferior scholars gain positions through non-merit criteria and plagiarism is one of the ways inferior scholars attempt to succeed despite lacking genuine accomplishment.
“when you set aside academic standards to pursue diversity equity and inclusion in other words you start making appointments not on the basis of ability and performance and achievement but on the basis of other criter plagiarism that is not a random that's not just a correlation of course because you're essentially going to start giving promotion and preferment to inferior Scholars and how do inferior Scholars get by uh plagiar plagiarism is one of the ways that uh that people get by who are not really up to it”
Wealthy donors should redirect their contributions away from Harvard, Yale, Stanford, and Princeton—which don't need more money and waste it—toward new institutions that would make better use of the funds.
“the solution to the problem of the excessive wealth of Harvard uh is for donors to stop giving it money that it clearly doesn't need and wasts uh I would rather they gave the money uh to a new institution that would make much better use of it”
Bill Ackman, a Harvard alumnus and major donor ($50 million), has investigated the prevailing ethic at Harvard and has become famous for publicly articulating what DEI actually means in practice, bringing attention to the problem.
“Bill Amman has become famous I have to say three weeks ago I didn't know who he was today I'm tempted to write him in for president um he's been investigating the prevailing ethic at his Elma mater Harvard where he was not only an undergraduate but to which he's given some $50 million”
The market for genius and new ideas still exists in academia, and it is 'moving'—leaving Harvard and heading toward Austin, Texas—suggesting that University of Austin represents a real competitive alternative.
“and the trouble is that Market's moving it's leaving Harvard uh and oddly enough it's heading for Austin Texas see you there”
Claudine Gay resigned as Harvard president on January 2 after the Harvard Corporation initially stood behind her following Congressional testimony, but withdrew support only when plagiarism charges emerged.
“claudian gay resigned as president of Harvard on January 2nd according to press accounts the Harvard Corporation the body that holds ultimate Authority at Harvard the Harvard Corporation stood behind gay after her testimony before Congress that we just heard withdrawing its support for her only after charges of plagiarism emerged”
Identity politics is designed to be hostile to individual liberty by insisting that nobody is an individual but rather belongs to some identity category (ethnic, sexual, gender, racial, or religious), and once an individual's identity category is identified they can be ranked according to their level of victimhood, with white males at the bottom and women of color at the top of the ranking.
“identity politics is designed to be hostile to individual liberty by insisting that nobody is an individual every Liberty belongs to some category or other uh of identity ethnic uh sexual gender uh racial religious you name it and once you've identified uh the uh identity category to which an individual belongs they can then be ranked uh according to the uh level of victimhood uh and if you are white male and I'm afraid we're both nearly dead white males we're right at the bottom of the rankings and if we were women of color who'd consistently voted Democrat and perhaps if we were uh also uh uh of a certain sexual orientation we'd be near the top”
To fix the problems of ideological capture in universities, we need a fundamental change in university governance from top to bottom, not just new leadership; universities are not public institutions (as they were in Germany) but substantial private institutions, which is a good thing that should be preserved; the philanthropic culture of the United States is one of its glories.
“I think the the philanthropic culture of the United States is one is one of its glories uh the fact that uh the the universities are not public institutions as they were in Germany but are in a substantial measure private institutions is a good good thing and we should be wary of breaking that unique model which really doesn't have a counterpart elsewhere”
Constantine Kissin argues that the big lesson of Bill Ackman's campaign against discriminatory DEI practices is that it proves all that's needed is for a few people with power, money, and influence to stand up to the problem, and then it will be over.
“Constantine kissen if I'm pronouncing his name correctly quote one of the biggest benefits of Bill amman's successful campaign to dismantle discriminatory practices at Elite colleges is that it proves something that many of us have been saying for a long time all it takes is for a few people with power money and influence to start standing up to this crap and it'll be over”
Jordan Peterson argues that while Bill Ackman has done good work, he appears to have no real idea how far down the rabbit hole universities have gone, suggesting that plagiarism is not the least of their problems but only a small part of a much deeper institutional dysfunction.
“Jordan Peterson bill akman for all his good work appears to have no real idea how far down the rabbit hole the universities have gone plagarism might not be the least of their problems but it's a long way down the list”
Universities in the 1960s were already liberal; in the 1970s and 1980s, liberals had a tendency to hire Marxists over other liberals; then Marxists hired cultural Marxists (the post-1989 version of Marxism which switched economics out in favor of identity politics) after the left lost the class war in the 1980s and lost the Cold War in 1989.
“at the universities in the 1960s already lent liberal uh you mentioned the late Henry kissi he was already unusual in the 1960s to be a Conservative Republican Professor uh the problem in the 1970s and 80s was that the Liberals had a tendency to hire marxists uh over other liberals and then due course the marxists uh would hire cultural marxists the post 1989 version of Marxism which switched uh economics out in favor of identity politics when you lost the class war as the left did spectacularly in the 1980s and you lost the Cold War”
The Hoover Institution is a semi-autonomous republic within Stanford University; there is no Hoover Institution equivalent at Harvard or Yale, though these places could use one; Ferguson believes passionately in what Hoover does because it serves as the counterculture to DEI by showing it is possible to engage in scholarship in a way that is not politicized and that liberals and conservatives can work together on academic problems leaving politics at the threshold.
“You and I are fellows at the Hoover institution the Hoover institution is a rather unique institution uh in the it's a semi-autonomous republic uh and within uh Stanford University why is there no Hoover institution at Harvard ever wondered or at Yale well they could use a Hoover institution in those places uh one of the reasons that I believe passionately in what we do here at Hoover is that we are the counterculture to Dei uh and if we can continue to show that it's possible to engage in scholarship in a way that is not politicized uh if we can be an institution that shows that liberals and conservatives can work together on academic problems leaving politics at the threshold then we'll also be acting as Role Models”
The University of Austin only recently became accredited despite being situated in Texas where bureaucratic requirements are less onerous; the university's first students will be admitted in Fall 2024, demonstrating it is the 'classic American solution' to the problem of ideologically captured universities.
“we only became accredited because you know have to go through bureaucratic Hoops even in Texas uh just last year uh our first students will be admitted uh will start studying in the fall of 2024 and I think it's the classic American solution to a problem don't leave it to the government do it yourself build something new”
When Niall Ferguson and his wife Ayaan Hirsi Ali came into contact with cancel culture nearly 10 years ago, Ali was invited to give a commencement address at Brandeis University but was disinvited because a coalition of progressive and Islamist elements had signed a petition demanding she not speak, and her public disinvitation was a turning point that made Ferguson begin to understand and worry about the illiberal turn in universities.
“well it was almost 10 years ago that I think my wife and I aan hery Ali and I came into contact with councel culture for the first time and that was when she was invited to give uh a commencement address at brandies University and then shortly before the event was told that she was disinvited because a strange Coalition of progressive uh and islamist uh elements at brandise had signed a petition uh demanding that she be disinvited uh and it was at that stage that cancel culture began to be something of a recurrent phenomenon in universities in the United States people were being disinvited”
The odd phenomenon of 'Queers for Palestine' makes sense in the weird parallel world of the American campus despite not making sense in reality—gay men would not be tolerated in Gaza under Hamas control—which shows that different elements of the woke movement have coalesced despite their obvious mutual incompatibility into a great realignment on campus, and only after October 7 did people realize Jews had been major losers in this realignment.
“why on Earth would you have queers for Palestine uh to give just one example of the strange phenomena we've seen since October the 7th how long would a group of young gay men last in Gaza if they proclaimed their sexual orientation not long because that's not really hamas's bag but in the weird parallel world of the American campus quer for Palestine makes perfect sense uh and so we have a great realignment on campus uh and it was only really after October the 7th that people like Bill akman realized that in that great realignment uh their people uh their group uh a Jews had been major losers”
Skeptics argue that German and American universities are nearly opposite cases—German universities glorified the state and ethnic group while American universities criticize America and promote internationalism—therefore the parallel Ferguson draws is invalid.
“by now I feel certain some of our listeners will be agreeing with your friends they'll be saying this is all fascinating as a matter of history but there Neil Ferguson goes again exaggerating away what happened there could not happen here because the cases are virtually opposite the German universities glorify ify the German State and the dominant ethnic group the so-called Aryan race American universities don't glorify America they're very happy to have the borders erased they're one worlders they're internationalists they're not committed to glorifying the dominant wasp the old wasp ascendancy on the contrary they're committed to humiliating it on behalf of other ethnic groups”
The probability of there being Hoover-like institutions at other universities just went up from 0% to perhaps 5% due to the wake-up call of October 7th and its aftermath creating openness to alternatives to DEI-captured universities.
“so I'm kind of hopeful just a little bit hopeful Peter that the probability of there being Hoover institutions at other universities just went up from 0% to I don't know maybe five maybe 5%”
Ferguson is habitually not optimistic, having grown up in Scotland, but he is a little more optimistic now because it is being brought home to trustees across the country—not just at Harvard—that they have to change the way they go about things and can no longer allow ideologues and progressives to call the shots.
“well I'm habitually not optimistic as you know Peter having having grown up in Scotland uh but I'm a little bit more optimistic because I think it's being brought home forcibly uh to trustees uh uh all across the country not just at at Harvard uh that they have to change uh the way they go about things that they can no longer allow the ideologues uh the progressives uh to call the shots and that that has to be a step in the right direction”