sentience
The capacity to have subjective experiences, especially to feel pleasure and pain; in Singer's ethics, the property that gives a being moral status.
As defined in Peter Singer
Other definitions
The quality of being conscious and able to feel things; often conflated with intelligence but are distinct properties.
Our AI Future Is WAY WORSE Than You Think | Yuval Noah Harari
Where it comes up · 11
- 309 - Vulnerability Politics And Moral Worth3 claims
- Micheal Pollan On The Mystery Of Consciousness.2 claims
- Animal Minds & Moral Truths: A Conversation with Peter Singer (Episode #342)2 claims
- Peter Singer2 claims
- What Venus Flytraps, ChatGPT, and LSD reveal about consciousness | Michael Pollan2 claims
- 475 - The Hard Problem Of Consciousness2 claims
- 292 | Jonathan Birch on Animal Sentience2 claims
- 311 | Annaka Harris on Whether Consciousness is Fundamental2 claims
and 3 more
Most important claims · 10 of 20Search all claims for “sentience” →
- Current large language models are not sentient and so do not count morally; sentience is essential for a being to count, and although the science of consciousness is incomplete and badly understood, Singer is not convinced that this incompleteness would lead us astray in making moral decisions based on sentience.Peter Singer
- Sentience is basic awareness of environment and the ability to find valence (positive or negative) in environmental changes and to move toward or away from those changes; this may be a property of life itself, including unicellular organisms and possibly plants.Micheal Pollan On The Mystery Of Consciousness.
- Plants make fruits and seeds meant to be eaten by mammals and birds, and grasses benefit from being grazed by ruminants; this suggests that eating plants is morally acceptable despite evidence of plant sentience.Micheal Pollan On The Mystery Of Consciousness.
- Plants are best described as sentient rather than conscious: they can learn and remember (retaining a conditioned response to ignore a stressor for up to 30 days, far longer than fruit flies' 24 hours), detect caterpillar chewing sounds and mount chemical defenses, navigate mazes toward fertilizer, and grow directionally toward supports—and the same anesthetics that put humans out also immobilize a Venus flytrap—yet there is no evidence they have anything resembling interiority.475 - The Hard Problem Of Consciousness
- If welfare and moral patienthood rest on rationality, agency, or functional representational states rather than only sentience, and if consciousness is functional rather than substrate-dependent, then LLMs' functional states may make a stronger case for moral consideration.363 | Chandra Sripada on How LLMs and Humans are Cognitive Cousins
- Plant biologist Daniel Chamovitz found that anesthesia blocks the flow of information in a Venus fly trap in the same way it does in a human brain, and that plants process light and mechanical stimuli through sense-like modalities at the molecular level, leading him to think plants likely have some short-lived form of sentience though not human-like consciousness.311 | Annaka Harris on Whether Consciousness is Fundamental
- Sentience is defined as the ability to sense what's going on in one's environment and assess what's good and bad for oneself and act appropriately; this may be a universal quality of life that applies even to bacteria through chemotaxis.What Venus Flytraps, ChatGPT, and LSD reveal about consciousness | Michael Pollan
- Sentience and consciousness are distinct: sentience is the basic, possibly life-pervading ability to sense changes in one's environment, assess them as good or bad, and move toward or away from them (e.g., bacterial chemotaxis), whereas consciousness is a more elaborate form of sensation involving awareness, feelings, and—in humans—awareness that one is aware.475 - The Hard Problem Of Consciousness
- Following Jonathan Birch's approach to animal sentience, the word 'sentience' is preferable to 'consciousness' because it sounds more scientific and less fraught; moreover, one can hold the logically coherent position that even if it is acceptable to kill and eat animals, it is not acceptable to cause them pain.311 | Annaka Harris on Whether Consciousness is Fundamental
- A rich and fulfilling human life can reasonably be said to contain more happiness than the life of a cow or sheep; animals are not 'equal' in the sense of their lives containing equal value with humans, even though their interests deserve consideration.Peter Singer