self-sufficient
Being able to run one's own life and sustain one's principles without the help of others; Callard argues anger reveals that we have lost this self-sufficiency.
As defined in Agnes Callard on Anger
Where it comes up · 1
- Agnes Callard on Anger5 claims
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “self-sufficient” →
- Every moment of choice depends on a value-understructure: we cannot physically move ourselves forward by choice without a thought-structure that sees what we're doing as worth doing. We hold onto these principles not alone but with the help of other people, co-valuing things with them, so when others defect or behave in ways that make us lose grip on our principles, we are no longer self-sufficient and we get angry.Agnes Callard on Anger
- There is something paradoxical about advising someone to forgive: you can forgive when you can sustain the violated norm self-sufficiently without the other person's help, but the very act of advising forgiveness presupposes the person is not self-sufficient, which undermines their being in a position to forgive. A wronged spouse who 'desperately wants to forgive' cannot if she is not self-sufficient; the wrongdoer's demand that she forgive on her own is itself a refusal to participate in the repair.Agnes Callard on Anger
- Anger can be met three ways: revenge (taking matters into your own hands by removing the threat), detachment (stepping back, de-emotionalizing, and reasserting self-sufficiency), or asking for help. Revenge is destructive and detachment is usually better, but both insist on a self-sufficiency you lack; since anger means you genuinely need something from another person, the right response is to ask for the help you obviously need—even though the one person who can help is the person you least want to ask.Agnes Callard on Anger
- Anger is a sign that a person is no longer self-sufficient: they have lost the ability to run their own life by themselves and need others' help to sustain their principles. The standard advice to control or eradicate anger is good advice only for someone fully self-sufficient who needs no humility or moral education from others, which most people are not.Agnes Callard on Anger
- Anger can be heard as a cry for help: it tends to make itself visible to the person you're angry at, signaling that they should attend to and engage with you in something you cannot do by yourself. The intractability of anger lies in the fact that you typically need help precisely from the one person you least want to accept or request help from, and within a given situation, set of people, and time frame it is often impossible to work through alone.Agnes Callard on Anger