causal

Advising Forgiveness Is Often Incoherent

There is something paradoxical about advising someone to forgive: you can forgive when you can sustain the violated norm self-sufficiently without the other person's help, but the very act of advising forgiveness presupposes the person is not self-sufficient, which undermines their being in a position to forgive. A wronged spouse who 'desperately wants to forgive' cannot if she is not self-sufficient; the wrongdoer's demand that she forgive on her own is itself a refusal to participate in the repair.

causalpending

Speaker

Agnes Callard

Evidence Quote

“she desperately wants to forgive him. Probably there is nothing she wants more than to forgive him. But she's not self-sufficient. She wouldn't continue to be angry if she were self-sufficient... There's something that the husband needs to do, but he doesn't want to do it... ask for forgiveness... because that would require him facing his own sense of shame.”

Source

Agnes Callard on Anger— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:13:20 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...