security guarantee
A formal commitment by states to defend or support another state's security, here structured in three layers (Ukrainian army, coalition of the willing, US element) to deter future Russian aggression.
As defined in Why Iran War Exposed Europe S Biggest Weakness Mujtaba Rahman
Where it comes up · 9
- Why Europe’s Security Strategy Is Failing & How the War in Ukraine Will End | Ep. 51 Anne Applebaum9 claims
- Europe S Security Order Is Breaking Down And It S Only The Beginning Olivier Schmitt2 claims
- Why Europe S Security Strategy Is Failing How The War In Ukraine Will End Ep. 51 Anne Applebaum2 claims
- Trump To Force Ukraine Peace on Europe - John Mearsheimer, Alexander Mercouris & Glenn Diesen2 claims
- The Future of Saudi Arabia || Peter Zeihan2 claims
- The Legacy of Stalin's Leadership During World War II and Its Relevance to Today's War in Ukraine2 claims
- Why Iran War Exposed Europe S Biggest Weakness Mujtaba Rahman1 claim
- Ben Hodges The Critical Decisions That Will Define Ukraine S War Ep. 46 Ben Hodges1 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 22Search all claims for “security guarantee” →
- During globalization, the United States needed oil from the Persian Gulf not for itself, but for its allies—Japan, China, Korea, Taiwan, France, Germany, Italy, and Britain—countries that lacked sufficient oil capacity and were induced to join the global order and Cold War against the Soviet Union by a US security guarantee to keep them fueled.The Future of Saudi Arabia || Peter Zeihan
- Hegseth explicitly stated that if Europeans provide security guarantees to Ukraine, the United States will not participate, and any European peacekeepers would not be covered under NATO Article 5, meaning the US would have no obligation to defend them if Russia attacks.Trump To Force Ukraine Peace on Europe - John Mearsheimer, Alexander Mercouris & Glenn Diesen
- A security guarantee must be at the center of any negotiated settlement for Ukraine, and the question is not whether one exists but what form it takes—including potential NATO membership triggers, automatic seizure of $300 billion in Russian assets, and military response architecture.General David Petraeus: Dispatches from Munich
- Negotiations with Russia require hard power commitments and security guarantees backing any agreement, because Russia has a poor record of keeping promises and deals, particularly for Eastern European countries with historical memory of broken Russian/Soviet commitments.Why Europe’s Security Strategy Is Failing & How the War in Ukraine Will End | Ep. 51 Anne Applebaum
- Because Russia has a history of not keeping to deals, the only viable way to negotiate is to have a security guarantee backed by hard power prepared to enforce whatever is agreed; absent a real visible change in Russia's goals and a hard-power enforcement mechanism, negotiations are not credible.Why Europe S Security Strategy Is Failing How The War In Ukraine Will End Ep. 51 Anne Applebaum
- Russia has neither stopped fighting nor formally or informally given up its goal of destroying Ukraine as a nation and removing Ukrainian sovereignty, so even an immediate ceasefire is dubious unless accompanied by evidence Russia has abandoned that goal or by a security presence preventing Russia from restarting the war in 18 months.Why Europe S Security Strategy Is Failing How The War In Ukraine Will End Ep. 51 Anne Applebaum
- A hegemon that trades for benefits rather than long-term interaction provides unreliable security guarantees, so even after extracting economic concessions the US could quickly abandon European security if Russia or another party offers it a better deal—making the Budapest Pact a terrible deal for Europe on both economic dependency and security reliability.Europe S Security Order Is Breaking Down And It S Only The Beginning Olivier Schmitt
- South Korea obtained an armistice (not a peace treaty) with a U.S. security guarantee without ending the war, and became one of the world's most successful countries through integration into a post-WWII Japanese economy and U.S. security umbrella, demonstrating an alternative model for UkraineThe Legacy of Stalin's Leadership During World War II and Its Relevance to Today's War in Ukraine
- The third 'ring' of any Ukraine security guarantee—the US element—is of doubtful credibility: if Trump won't stand up to Putin today, there is little reason to believe he would defend Ukraine in the future, especially after a ceasefire when US and Russian interests are intertwined through business deals, even though a paper detailing the US commitment now exists where none did under Biden.Why Iran War Exposed Europe S Biggest Weakness Mujtaba Rahman
- Negotiations with Russia require security guarantees or hard power commitment to enforce any agreement, because Russia has a demonstrated history of violating agreements and non-state actors cannot reliably monitor or enforce compliance.Why Europe’s Security Strategy Is Failing & How the War in Ukraine Will End | Ep. 51 Anne Applebaum