second face of power
Power exercised invisibly: when would-be reformers anticipate defeat and therefore do nothing, so the principal consequence of power is inaction rather than visible conflict.
As defined in Terry Moe on Educational Reform, Katrina, and Hidden Power
Other definitions
The sociological concept that power includes the ability to keep certain ideas or alternatives off the agenda entirely, so they are never even considered, not just the power to win explicit decisions.
Brink Lindsey and Steven Teles on the Captured Economy
Where it comes up · 2
- Terry Moe on Educational Reform, Katrina, and Hidden Power3 claims
- Brink Lindsey and Steven Teles on the Captured Economy1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “second face of power” →
- Beyond the observable 'First Face of Power' (winning open political conflicts), there is a 'Second Face of Power': when one side knows it has superior power, would-be reformers, anticipating defeat and its costs, voluntarily do nothing, so the great consequence of power is not winning fights but that nothing happens at all—an effect that is invisible because its principal product is the absence of action.Terry Moe on Educational Reform, Katrina, and Hidden Power
- Organized interests exert influence not just through coercive money in lobbying but through a 'second face of power'—controlling whether ideas are even considered legitimate; occupational licensing is protected most durably not by defending its merits but by making any alternative seem nuts, so incumbents never have to defend their policy on substance.Brink Lindsey and Steven Teles on the Captured Economy
- The Second Face of Power can lead observers to mistakenly conclude that because people are not working hard to change a system, the system must be acceptable, when in fact reformers have simply given up after anticipating defeat.Terry Moe on Educational Reform, Katrina, and Hidden Power
- The New Orleans success is unlikely to spread to other cities because, absent a catastrophe like Katrina that destroys vested-interest power, the incentives are not there: under normal conditions schools remain protected by vested interests and the Second Face of Power continues to suppress major reforms, so the heroic-replication 'movie version' does not happen.Terry Moe on Educational Reform, Katrina, and Hidden Power