second best
In economics, the principle that when an ideal (first-best) condition cannot be met, the optimal achievable policy may differ from naively approximating the ideal.
As defined in Tyler Cowen on the Pandemic, Revisited
Where it comes up · 3
- How neoliberalism broke economics | Dr Abby Innes2 claims
- Tyler Cowen on the Pandemic, Revisited1 claim
- Dani Rodrik on Globalization, Development, and Employment 04/11/20111 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “second best” →
- Neoclassical reasoning is institutionalized across virtually every British and international economic agent: the Treasury Green Book is a neoclassical second-best framework defining decision-making across all government departments, international financial institutions use neoclassical reasoning, and central banks rely on dynamic stochastic general equilibrium models built on a 'representative agent' and rational-expectations models.How neoliberalism broke economics | Dr Abby Innes
- Pharmaceutical subsidies and interventions like Operation Warp Speed are best understood as a second-best approach: selling vaccines at market-clearing prices (e.g., at a refrigerated 7-Eleven) would likely have produced better incentives and faster distribution, but since society won't tolerate price mechanisms (imposing price controls, IP confiscation, and norms against buying one's way into line), subsidies substitute for the commodification we're unwilling to allow.Tyler Cowen on the Pandemic, Revisited
- The mainstream (Blairite) economic tradition treats neoclassical economics not as literal description but as a 'second best' scientific heuristic for diagnosing and mending market failures — fixing monopoly, asymmetric contracting, or pricing nature to solve climate — but the idea that you can mend market failures is a fallacy and a category error: it confuses a logically valid model with something reproducible in the social world, falsely assuming each fix moves society toward a horizon of perfectly competitive markets.How neoliberalism broke economics | Dr Abby Innes
- In developing-country policy one is always in a second-best world where multiple distortions are entangled, so insisting on first-best reforms is often escapism; the reforms that work best are pragmatic second-best reforms that isolate and target the specific interacting distortions.Dani Rodrik on Globalization, Development, and Employment 04/11/2011