scientific consensus
The collective judgment of experts in a field about what is well-established, used as an epistemic anchor for non-experts.
As defined in AMA | November 2025
Where it comes up · 3
- AMA | November 20252 claims
- Megan McArdle on the Oedipus Trap1 claim
- 302 - Science Civilization1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “scientific consensus” →
- The slogan 'follow the science' is unscientific because it obscures the question 'which scientist?'—scientific consensus is a reasonable Bayesian prior but not infallible, and treating dissent as prima facie evidence of lunacy contradicts the scientific method; the proper response to an open question is a careful evidence-weighing deep dive, not demanding that society accept claims on faith because of scientific credentials.Megan McArdle on the Oedipus Trap
- Because laypeople lack the expertise to evaluate technical claims directly, they should rely on a combination of the speaker's reputation and how far the claim deviates from scientific consensus, recognizing that deviation from consensus must be earned through evidence rather than asserted.AMA | November 2025
- In science the word 'consensus' does not mean a gathering of opinions as the public hears it, but rather what the body of research papers shows from displayed data; thus if 97 papers show one thing and one person dissents, you should bet on the consensus because the dissenter typically cherry-picks to fit a worldview.302 - Science Civilization
- Hypotheses that fail to meet scientific consensus, such as intelligent-design critiques of evolution, should be clearly distinguished from established science (e.g., not shelved alongside biology textbooks), because misrepresenting their epistemic status to the public misleads non-experts even if free speech permits their publication.AMA | November 2025