response rate
The proportion of patients whose tumors shrink by a defined amount (e.g., 30% or more); a measure of tumor shrinkage used to approve drugs, often in single-arm trials with no control.
As defined in Vinay Prasad on Cancer Drugs, Medical Ethics, and Malignant
Where it comes up · 2
- New Data Suggest Interest Rates Could Explode Lower2 claims
- Vinay Prasad on Cancer Drugs, Medical Ethics, and Malignant2 claims
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “response rate” →
- The cut-offs defining tumor 'response' (a 30%+ shrinkage in the sum of tumor diameters) derive not from evidence that they predict longer or better life, but from a 1970s Charles Moertel study in which 16 oncologists measured marbles through foam rubber with calipers; the cut-offs reflect the smallest change two oncologists could reliably discriminate and have simply been codified and passed forward through historical accident.Vinay Prasad on Cancer Drugs, Medical Ethics, and Malignant
- Despite inaccuracy and noise in payroll reports, the BLS consistently biases data higher (in the optimistic direction), even with higher response ratesNew Data Suggest Interest Rates Could Explode Lower
- The nonfarm payroll response rate of 47.4% is so low that the report is largely constructed from incomplete data, making the entire report unreliable, and further downward revisions are likely as more responses are collected.New Data Suggest Interest Rates Could Explode Lower
- Of 100 consecutive oncology drug approvals, only about a third improve overall survival or quality of life; a third merely delay progression-free survival, which only gives the illusion of being meaningful because it rests on arbitrary radiographic cut-offs; and a third are approved on single-arm studies with no control arm using response rate—so approving drugs on these surrogate endpoints means many likely do not improve survival or quality of life.Vinay Prasad on Cancer Drugs, Medical Ethics, and Malignant