factual

Tumor response cut-offs come from a 1970s marble study

The cut-offs defining tumor 'response' (a 30%+ shrinkage in the sum of tumor diameters) derive not from evidence that they predict longer or better life, but from a 1970s Charles Moertel study in which 16 oncologists measured marbles through foam rubber with calipers; the cut-offs reflect the smallest change two oncologists could reliably discriminate and have simply been codified and passed forward through historical accident.

factualpending

Speaker

Vinay Prasad

Evidence Quote

“They are not cut-offs that have been selected because they are telling us people live longer or live better when you have this amount of tumor shrinkage”

Source

Vinay Prasad on Cancer Drugs, Medical Ethics, and Malignant— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:28:36 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...