reactance
A psychological response in which being threatened or pressured triggers oppositional behavior—threatening back rather than complying.
As defined in Michele Gelfand
Where it comes up · 2
- David McRaney on How Minds Change5 claims
- Michele Gelfand1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “reactance” →
- Reactance is a universal human response in which a person feels motivationally aroused to remove an influence because their agency or autonomy feels threatened ('Unhand me, you fools'); crucially it is the WANT in 'I want you to think this' that triggers it—advice feels coercive, like a knife at your back, so people push away regardless of the advice's quality.David McRaney on How Minds Change
- In early therapeutic practice, telling clients what they ought to do triggered a reactance feedback loop in which clients generated counter-arguments defending the very behavior they came to extinguish, so they left therapy MORE likely to engage in the behavior than if they had never come—a backfire that drove the development of non-directive techniques like motivational interviewing.David McRaney on How Minds Change
- The most powerful way to change a mind even when you are correct is to exit the debate frame—instead of 'I'm right, you're wrong,' express genuine curiosity about why you disagree and propose collaborating—so that, rather than facing each other as obstacles, both turn shoulder to shoulder to face the problem together, which avoids reactance and is far more fruitful.David McRaney on How Minds Change
- By asking someone why they didn't rate their certainty higher (e.g. 'how come not an eight or nine?'), you prompt them to generate their own counter-arguments against their position; because the counter-arguments are theirs and not yours, no reactance is triggered, and these fresh self-generated counter-arguments durably affect how they see the issue going forward.David McRaney on How Minds Change
- Insistently telling someone how great a book or movie is triggers reactance that lowers their enjoyment, and additionally puts them in a state where they spend the whole experience building arguments to report back to you—stealing their ability to reach narrative immersion because part of their mind is preoccupied with you.David McRaney on How Minds Change
- Trump uses a classic distributive (win-lose) negotiation style with threats that works only in single-issue contexts with little expected future interaction; applied to international politics—which involves many issues and ongoing interaction—it backfires because threats provoke reactance (counter-threats), and he lacks the cultural intelligence to avoid violating others' honor.Michele Gelfand