causal

Counter-Arguing Backfire In Therapy

In early therapeutic practice, telling clients what they ought to do triggered a reactance feedback loop in which clients generated counter-arguments defending the very behavior they came to extinguish, so they left therapy MORE likely to engage in the behavior than if they had never come—a backfire that drove the development of non-directive techniques like motivational interviewing.

causalpending

Speaker

David McRaney

Evidence Quote

“they had these arguments for and arguments against. So, they were at a state of ambivalence when they arrived... But, because of that, they counter-argued with the therapist. They generated counter-arguments inside of them that put more weight on the side of continuing to do the thing. So, they walked away with more arguments for than against than when they walked in.”

Source

David McRaney on How Minds Change— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 3:32:01 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...