rational psychology
The traditional metaphysical discipline that attempts to prove the existence and properties of the soul or mind as a thinking substance through rational argument; in Kant's critique, it commits paralogisms by improperly extending a priori categories to entities beyond possible experience
As defined in A History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “rational psychology” →
- In rational psychology, Kant's central objection to Cartesian arguments for the soul as a thinking substance is that they introduce the a priori category of substance, which itself depends on unknown relationships between accidents (properties) and their underlying substrates, making the logical inference invalidA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
- Kant does not deny the existence of soul substance in rational psychology; rather, he denies that there is a valid logical argument for it while acknowledging that practical considerations may justify belief in itA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
- In rational psychology, four paralogisms can be identified, each corresponding to the four types of categories (quantity, quality, relation, modality): arguments claiming the mind is simple/indivisible, numerically identical through time, related to extended objects in space, and existing with necessityA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
- Paralogism in logic is a step that goes beyond logic, where the argument's conclusion extends beyond what can be proven logically from the premises—this is the fundamental error structure Kant identifies in rational psychologyA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
- The rational psychology section is straightforward and simpler than the cosmological and theological sections, making it a good entry point into understanding Kant's dialectical methodA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics