quintessence
A hypothesized dynamical scalar field providing time-varying dark energy, as opposed to a fixed cosmological constant.
As defined in AMA | February 2024
Where it comes up · 9
- Holiday Message 2020 | The Screwy Universe5 claims
- 359 | Solo: Theories of Dark Energy3 claims
- AMA | February 20242 claims
- Holiday Message | Hits and Misses2 claims
- Lex Fridman Podcast #428 - Sean Carroll1 claim
- 310 | Marc Kamionkowski on Dark Energy and Cosmic Anomalies1 claim
- 331 | Solo: Fine-Tuning, God, and the Multiverse1 claim
- AMA | October 20211 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 17Search all claims for “quintessence” →
- For a slowly rolling quintessence field to produce today's dark energy, its mass must be roughly 10 to the minus 33 electron volts, which is the Hubble constant expressed in energy units and is vastly smaller than any known particle mass, so the tiny value demands explanation.359 | Solo: Theories of Dark Energy
- The mass of a scalar particle is the square root of the second derivative (curvature) of the potential near its minimum; for a quintessence dark-energy field that is still slowly rolling and has not reached its minimum, quoting 'the mass' at the minimum is technically cheating—one should evaluate the second derivative at the field's current location—though for a generic untuned potential the order of magnitude is comparable, so the mass serves as a quick-and-dirty proxy for how strongly the potential changes.AMA | September 2021
- A quintessence scalar field proposed as dynamical dark energy must have a mass around 10^-33 electron volts — vastly smaller than the electron (~half a million eV) or the lightest neutrinos (~10^-3 eV) — and in quantum field theory such tiny masses normally require a protecting symmetry, so simply writing one down to fit the data, without explaining the smallness or why the field has not already been detected through its couplings, is theoretically unsatisfying.Holiday Message | Hits and Misses
- Instead of a constant vector field (which is ill-defined in curved spacetime), a slowly-changing scalar field whose gradient is a vector can violate Lorentz invariance and serve as dark energy; if it is a pseudo-scalar with a symmetry that keeps its mass low and forbids couplings to other fields, it can naturally couple only to electromagnetism, producing observable cosmic birefringence of about one degree — below existing limits but reachable by improved data such as the cosmic microwave background.Holiday Message | Hits and Misses
- If dark energy is a dynamical field (quintessence) rather than a cosmological constant, its mass must be about 10⁻³³ eV—roughly 10⁻⁶⁰ of the Planck mass—to evolve slowly enough to fit data, and it must additionally avoid interacting with photons, electrons, and neutrons, requiring many further fine-tuned parameters; Carroll's own paper proposed a way out testable via cosmological birefringence.331 | Solo: Fine-Tuning, God, and the Multiverse
- If the birefringence effect turns out to be true, one should not simply believe the first available explanation (such as Carroll's own) but should keep an open mind for all possible explanations, including early-universe pseudoscalar fields rather than present-day quintessence.Holiday Message 2020 | The Screwy Universe
- A pseudo-Goldstone boson can naturally have a very low mass protected by an approximate symmetry (as worked out by 't Hooft), and Carroll's contribution was showing that this same symmetry also suppresses the dangerous couplings to matter and photons, freeing such a quintessence field from fifth-force and time-varying-constant constraints—except for one surviving interaction, the Chern-Simons coupling, which would produce cosmic birefringence.Holiday Message 2020 | The Screwy Universe
- The cosmic birefringence claim occupies an intermediate epistemic position: it is easy to explain theoretically (Carroll's own pseudo-Goldstone quintessence model predicts the effect to within an order of magnitude in both existence and magnitude) but the evidence is very tentative—only one group, 2.4 sigma—so Carroll, while rooting for it, would bet at even money that it will go away.Holiday Message 2020 | The Screwy Universe
- Quintessence models of dark energy are problematic because they require an extraordinarily fine-tuned scalar field with a mass around 10^-40 billion electron volts—vastly smaller than the natural Planck-scale value—analogous to but far more extreme than the hierarchy problem of the Higgs boson, and they predict observable fifth forces and time-dependent fundamental constants that are not seen.Holiday Message 2020 | The Screwy Universe
- Dark energy that pervades the universe and changes only over billions of years should set off alarm bells for particle physicists because particle physics deals in small length and time scales; any field evolving that slowly would, if it interacted with other particles, be sped up, so the only way to keep it slow and hard to detect is to impose a symmetry that protects it from interacting with other fields.Lex Fridman Podcast #428 - Sean Carroll