forecast

Birefringence claim has theory but weak evidence

The cosmic birefringence claim occupies an intermediate epistemic position: it is easy to explain theoretically (Carroll's own pseudo-Goldstone quintessence model predicts the effect to within an order of magnitude in both existence and magnitude) but the evidence is very tentative—only one group, 2.4 sigma—so Carroll, while rooting for it, would bet at even money that it will go away.

forecastpending

Speaker

Sean Carroll

Evidence Quote

“I am very, very, very much rooting for this to be true... and therefore I need to correct for that, I need to be careful not to let my enthusiasm get the better of me, and I should adopt a proper skeptical posture”

Source

Holiday Message 2020 | The Screwy Universe— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:30:05 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...