public use
The constitutional requirement (Takings Clause) that government may only take private property for public use; in Kelo read so broadly as to permit private-to-private transfers.
As defined in Richard Epstein on the Constitution
Where it comes up · 3
- Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/20065 claims
- Richard Epstein on Property Rights, Zoning and Kelo 9/17/20073 claims
- Richard Epstein on the Constitution1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “public use” →
- The erosion of property rights began with the New Deal court, which upheld slum-clearance takings as 'public use' even when property passed from one private owner to another, starting a slippery slope that by a 1984 case (Hawaii) allowed the largest expropriation of property in U.S. history, upheld unanimously with Justice O'Connor in the majority.Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/2006
- It would be an act of judicial activism to strike down the Kelo law, and that is exactly what justices' oath to uphold the Constitution requires; if people prefer 'public benefit' over 'public use' they must amend the Constitution—which the founders deliberately made difficult—rather than have courts rewrite it.Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/2006
- The Kelo decision, allowing New London to seize private property and transfer it to developers for economic 'public benefit,' represents judicial lawlessness because it effectively wrote the words 'public use' out of the Constitution and substituted the courts' preferred 'public benefit'; justices' oath obligates them to enforce the Constitution's actual words.Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/2006
- In Kelo v. New London the Supreme Court (5-4) allowed government to seize property and transfer it to private developers for economic development, effectively writing the words 'public use' out of the Constitution and substituting the broader 'public benefit'—which Bolick calls judicial lawlessness rather than activism.Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/2006
- The Supreme Court in Kelo was willing to accept any project labeled comprehensive planning, and Justice Stevens could never articulate what counts as private use inappropriate for the eminent domain power.Richard Epstein on Property Rights, Zoning and Kelo 9/17/2007
- The erosion of property and economic liberty protections began with the New Deal Court, which, in upholding slum clearance for public housing, started down a slippery slope from literal 'public use' to 'compelling public benefit,' culminating in a 1984 unanimous decision upholding mass expropriation of property in Hawaii.Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/2006
- The Takings Clause's public use requirement historically allowed takings for holdout problems, such as a landowner blocking a railroad's right of way, but Kelo shows how zoning prevents assembly, so developers must go to the city to condemn property.Richard Epstein on Property Rights, Zoning and Kelo 9/17/2007
- Kelo, widely condemned as outrageous judicial activism, was actually the opposite—judicial passivity: the Court knew the taking was not a genuine public-use transfer (private party to private party) yet deferred to the state, and because every transfer has some indirect public benefit, the public-use limitation was de facto read out of the Constitution; people wrongly call decisions they dislike 'activism' even when they are cases of complete judicial passivity.Richard Epstein on the Constitution
- The Constitution's Takings Clause says private property shall not be taken for public use without just compensation, and the central question is what counts as public use; Kelo turned on that ambiguity.Richard Epstein on Property Rights, Zoning and Kelo 9/17/2007