principle of least action
A principle stating that physical trajectories are those that minimize a quantity called the action, used to derive equations of motion including Einstein's.
As defined in AMA | June 2022
Where it comes up · 9
- AMA | June 20222 claims
- Part One: Complex World1 claim
- 115 | Netta Engelhardt on Black Hole Information, Wormholes, and Quantum Gravity1 claim
- 211 | Solo: Secrets of Einstein's Equation1 claim
- AMA | August 20241 claim
- AMA | March 20241 claim
- AMA | May 20231 claim
- AMA | May 20251 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “principle of least action” →
- While Einstein conceived that gravity is spacetime curvature and stated the final equation publicly first, the mathematician David Hilbert independently derived the correct left-hand side using the principle of least action while Einstein was still struggling, and because surviving letters and papers were revised, it is genuinely uncertain who obtained the correct equation first—though Einstein deserves credit since the underlying ideas were his.211 | Solo: Secrets of Einstein's Equation
- Feynman's path integral reformulates quantum mechanics by having a particle take every possible path—not just the classical least-action path—and summing the quantum contributions from all of them; contributions near the classical path reinforce while those far away cancel, recovering standard quantum mechanics without introducing a new theory.115 | Netta Engelhardt on Black Hole Information, Wormholes, and Quantum Gravity
- The Lagrangian being kinetic minus potential energy (rather than the more intuitive total energy KE+PE) is not arbitrary: the principle of least action with L = KE - PE reproduces Newton's laws, and the minus sign reflects how the action functional must be structured so its stationary path yields the correct equations of motion, connecting to deeper principles like the path integral in quantum mechanics.AMA | March 2024
- Carroll claims that neither Newton's classical mechanics nor the principle of least action is 'correct' about what nature is doing because 'nature is just nature', yet he appears to hold that physics tells us something deep about reality rather than being merely instrumental models; the questioner asks why Carroll treats this local-vs-global (least action) aspect differently from quantum field theory.AMA | May 2023
- The principle of least action states that among all possible trajectories a system could take between two points in time, the actual trajectory is the one that minimizes (or more precisely, has a stationary value of) the action—a quantity computed by integrating the Lagrangian over time.Sean Carroll on the Biggest Ideas in the Universe | Closer To Truth Chats
- The high efficiency of photosynthesis may be due to quantum effects—specifically an electron hole existing in superposition, spreading wave-like through chlorophyll to the reaction center—though this might be better understood as a principle of least action rather than genuine quantum superposition.AMA | May 2025
- The principle of optimization (that of all possible paths, the path that minimizes some quantity like time, distance, or energy is taken) is one of the most powerful concepts in mathematical physics, generalized in the 19th century to Hamilton's principle or the principle of stationary action (also called the principle of least action), and is probably the most important idea in physics.Part One: Complex World
- In physics, equality signs mean two differently-defined quantities are numerically equal in valid solutions, not that they are the same concept — F=ma, Newton's gravity law, the Schrödinger equation, and Einstein's equation all equate conceptually distinct things (force vs mass-times-acceleration, curvature vs energy-momentum); in mathematics equality can mean various things because math is about syntax more than semantics, but in neither case does equality mean identity of concepts.AMA | June 2022
- Within poetic naturalism, vocabulary like 'decisions' and 'choices' is clearly appropriate for humans, but it is unclear at which levels of emergence such language remains sensible—whether cells make choices, collections of people in elections do, fluids 'decide' to flow from high to low pressure, or particles 'choose' trajectories that minimize the action.AMA | August 2024
- That mass and energy warp spacetime can be taken as a postulate of general relativity or derived from the principle of least action, which selects the trajectory minimizing the action (kinetic minus potential energy for simple systems) subject to boundary conditions; in general relativity this manifests as a trade-off between the amount of stuff and the curvature of spacetime, with spacetime curving as little as it can to accommodate its energy.AMA | June 2022