preventive war
A war launched now to stop an opponent from becoming much stronger in the future; the most intuitive example of the commitment problem.
As defined in Chris Blattman on Why We Fight
Other definitions
Military conflict initiated proactively to prevent a perceived future threat from materializing, rather than in response to an actual attack
Artificial General Intelligence's Five Hard National Security Problems
Where it comes up · 4
- What Everyone Gets Wrong about China Invading Taiwan3 claims
- Chris Blattman on Why We Fight1 claim
- What Are the Real Rules of International Relations?1 claim
- 108 - Defending The Experts1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “preventive war” →
- The North Korea 'crisis' is largely self-generated, since a nuclear-armed North Korea was an inexorable, long-predicted development, and the realistic options are to live with deterrence and containment as in the Cold War or to launch a catastrophic preventive war; only an assembled, fueled ICBM during high tension would justify a conventional strike.108 - Defending The Experts
- Power transition theory has an underexplored flip side: declining powers may start wars to prevent further decline (preventive war theory), which Jack Levy developed, and this may partially explain Russia's invasion of Ukraine.What Are the Real Rules of International Relations?
- The commitment problem—best understood through preventive war—occurs when an opponent will be much stronger in the future and you could head that off now by attacking; even though the rising power could promise a good deal later or give up something now, when they cannot credibly commit to honor that promise (because there's no enforcement architecture), the bargain breaks down and war becomes attractive, as seen in WWI (Russia's rise vis-a-vis Germany), the Iraq invasion (Saddam's potential WMD), and Russia's fear of a Western-armed Ukraine.Chris Blattman on Why We Fight
- The discussion of preventive war has become more focused within U.S. policymaking circles, with a leaked memo from Air Force General Mike Minihan in January 2023 warning that his gut told him there would be war with China by 2025, and other reports focusing on 2027 as the 100th anniversary of the founding of the People's Liberation Army.What Everyone Gets Wrong about China Invading Taiwan
- Whether it is Japan, Vietnam, or otherwise, the timing of enhanced relationships with potential coalition partners matters critically: if partners suddenly join or strengthen commitment once Taiwan threat emerges, expectations about outcomes today versus later get squeezed together; if Beijing anticipates relationships won't fully form until years later, preventive war incentives reemerge.What Everyone Gets Wrong about China Invading Taiwan
- At some point it became fashionable to pretend that we have not learned anything about preventive wars over 2,500 years, suggesting that policymakers are repeating historical patterns rather than learning from them.What Everyone Gets Wrong about China Invading Taiwan