predestination
The doctrine that God has predetermined who will be saved; held without strict definition in Catholicism and more rigidly in Calvinism, but largely absent in Eastern theology.
As defined in David Bentley Hart
Where it comes up · 5
- Marilynne Robinson4 claims
- Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God2 claims
- 171 - Escaping A Christian Cult2 claims
- Free Will, Fundamental Agency, & Personal Responsibility | Existential Basics ep.41 claim
- David Bentley Hart1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “predestination” →
- The doctrine of double predestination—that God has predestined both the saved and the damned (90-95% of humans)—is logically implicit in Augustine but becomes explicit in Calvin; both Augustine and Calvin argue that human free will is not negated by predestination because humans will evil things and thereby justify their own damnation.Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God
- The greatest East-West difference is the theology of grace: in the West grace became an extraordinary gift treated as antithetical to nature and given by a predestining will of God, whereas in the East grace remained an ordinary reality continuous with nature, since humans are naturally oriented to union with God and an unnatural impediment, not the absence of super-elevating grace, separates us from him.David Bentley Hart
- Calvin never said that one can judge whether anyone is saved or damned; his cultures — Dutch, Protestant English-language, colonial America — were not marked by hierarchy by the standards of the period, and if any period had an egalitarian energy it was Calvinism, contrary to the worry that predestination sanctions extreme inequality.Marilynne Robinson
- Belief in predestination makes Westboro's demand that sinners repent internally incoherent, because if everything happens exactly as God set it up, then the unbelievers cannot repent and nothing could have been otherwise—yet the church still works itself into a rage at people for choices their own theology says were impossible to avoid.171 - Escaping A Christian Cult
- Protestant theologians (Luther, Calvin, Bullinger) respond to the free-will problem raised by predestination by pointing out that the objection itself—'that's not fair'—exemplifies sinful pride, placing human judgment above God's authority, just as Satan does.Dr. Darren Staloff, Augustine's City of God
- In the Hebrew Bible the younger brother is repeatedly chosen over the elder because human conventions like primogeniture have no necessity or causality in God's intentions; God is free to choose contrary to human social structures.Marilynne Robinson
- Predestination — God's choices working through human events — is general across Christian thought, not unique to Calvin; even Thomas Aquinas affirmed it in the Summa Contra Gentiles and Summa Theologica, because it is difficult to conceive of an omnipotent God who is powerless in the way human freedom would imply.Marilynne Robinson
- God actively restrains himself from intruding too far on human nature even as his intentions work their way through that nature; this self-restraint is what allows human freedom and is itself the godlike act.Marilynne Robinson
- After Megan left the church and began making scriptural arguments to her family, Westboro stopped holding signs praying for people to die (like 'pray for more dead soldiers'), though they retain the 'thank God' signs because predestination requires thanking God for all his righteous judgments.171 - Escaping A Christian Cult
- Biological determinism is the position that every decision humans make is a function of their base biological drives and imperatives, a position taken by nihilists and absurdists, while predestination is the position that cosmic will decides our fate, commonly taken by dogmatists.Free Will, Fundamental Agency, & Personal Responsibility | Existential Basics ep.4