positional goods
Goods whose value depends largely on how they compare to what others have, so satisfaction comes from relative standing rather than absolute quantity.
As defined in Robert Frank on Success and Luck
Other definitions
Goods whose value depends on relative standing against others, such as house size in a neighborhood, rather than on absolute quantity.
Robert Frank on Economics Education and the Economic Naturalist 10/15/2007
Where it comes up · 4
- Robert Frank on Success and Luck4 claims
- Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/20104 claims
- Robert Frank on Economics Education and the Economic Naturalist 10/15/20073 claims
- 468 - More From Sam Gratitude Bad Conversations Conspiracy Addiction Waffle House Teleportation1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “positional goods” →
- Beyond a certain level, further consumption increases in many categories achieve little for anyone when everyone does them, because standards shift: CEOs given bigger mansions in a decade would not be happier, and the resources freed could buy goods with greater value.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- When a rich person and others like them all have less money, there is almost no consequence because most of what they buy at high levels is positional: extra dollars taken in tax simply lower the auction price of scarce goods like a Central Park penthouse, which still ends up in exactly the same hands as before, so taxes hurt far less than people cognitively assume.Robert Frank on Success and Luck
- Many wonderful and special things in life are not limited in supply, so more and more people having them is a genuine good rather than a wasteful zero-sum competition; cellphones, for example, get better and reach far beyond the top few percent, so not all consumption is a positional arms race.Robert Frank on Success and Luck
- Context shapes evaluation of consumption: a fast mile time or a fast car is judged by its era, but a house's satisfaction is largely driven by its relative size among neighbors, while leisure is judged in absolute terms, so distortions arise where context matters more in some domains than others.Robert Frank on Economics Education and the Economic Naturalist 10/15/2007
- People care about absolute levels of some goods and relative standing in others: a house matters largely through its size relative to neighbors, whereas leisure is valued in absolute terms, and people would not trade half their leisure for a higher relative standing, but many would accept a smaller house in a more advantaged neighborhood.Robert Frank on Economics Education and the Economic Naturalist 10/15/2007
- What counts as 'special' is purely a relative concept defined against the prevailing norm, so as people spend more the standards defining adequate inexorably escalate; for example, the average American wedding now costs $31,000, roughly three times the 1980 level, not because people want to lord it over others but because the standards have escalated.Robert Frank on Success and Luck
- In a world where all rich people have 100,000 square-foot mansions versus a world where they all have 50,000 square-foot mansions, the rich would be happier with the smaller ones, because running a huge mansion is burdensome and the only reason to have one that big is that people like you have them.Robert Frank on Success and Luck
- Beyond a certain level, further increases in consumption in many categories do not raise happiness for anyone when everyone does them, because the standard shifts; a CEO given a bigger mansion next decade would not be happier because the reference point has risen.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- Consumption-based status competition cannot be eliminated because people will always compete for status, so the realistic goal is to change the cost of competition, as with engine displacement limits in racing classes, rather than eliminate competition.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- Roberts counters that absolute living standards have risen steadily since 25, 50, and 100 years ago, so relative competition is not obviously harmful, since people value both absolute and relative consumption.Robert Frank on Economics Education and the Economic Naturalist 10/15/2007