poetic naturalism
Carroll's philosophical view that there is one natural world but many useful, valid vocabularies for describing it at different levels.
As defined in AMA | August 2024
Where it comes up · 12
- 124 - In Search Of Reality2 claims
- AMA | February 20252 claims
- Lex Fridman Podcast #428 - Sean Carroll1 claim
- 121 | Cornel West on What Democracy Is and Should Be1 claim
- 335 | Andrew Jaffe on Models, Probability, and the Universe1 claim
- 78 | Daniel Dennett on Minds, Patterns, and the Scientific Image1 claim
- AMA | August 20241 claim
- AMA | December 20211 claim
and 4 more
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “poetic naturalism” →
- Under poetic naturalism, emergent phenomena are still real even though they are not fundamental, so distinguishing genuine ontological disagreements from mere semantic ones requires asking whether 'real' has a definite, defensible meaning across levels of description.AMA | February 2025
- Radical skeptical scenarios like being a brain in a vat, a Cartesian dream, or a Boltzmann brain are logically possible and therefore have non-zero probability, but placing significant credence on them is cognitively unstable because it makes it impossible to act, so we must impose simple models that the world is intelligible.335 | Andrew Jaffe on Models, Probability, and the Universe
- Carroll argues on Bayesian grounds we should stop asking 'why' once additional hypotheses no longer improve explanatory or predictive power, even treating physical laws as brute facts; the question is whether the same stopping rule applies to the normativity of truth—whether 'correct reasoning ought to bind belief' can be a brute fact justified pragmatically by science's long-run success, or whether there is a principled distinction between accepting brute laws and accepting brute normativity, and ultimately what makes a belief wrong rather than merely less useful within poetic naturalism.AMA | Feb 2026
- Science, while indispensable and one of humanity's most fundamental tools, does not take us far enough because being human involves fears, anxieties, death, dread, despair, and betrayal, which require stories, narratives, symbols, and metaphors—the domain of poets and philosophers—rather than scientific frameworks.121 | Cornel West on What Democracy Is and Should Be
- There is only one world, the natural world, but there are many legitimate ways of talking about it, and each vocabulary can capture real elements of reality; it is a mistake to dismiss higher-level structures as illusions merely because they are not the most fundamental description.78 | Daniel Dennett on Minds, Patterns, and the Scientific Image
- Under poetic naturalism, both a scientific description of a sunset (Rayleigh scattering of short wavelengths) and a poetic description (light dancing, a fiery canvas) can be sufficiently accurate and useful vocabularies to count as 'real,' provided the levels of description remain compatible.AMA | February 2025
- Through language and technology humans have become part of an emergent information-processing superstructure (internet, AI, complex societal systems), and these emergent systems now dominate society's trajectory more than individual choices, diminishing the importance of the self and possibly placing societal coordination beyond human control.AMA | May 2023
- The 'poetic' element of poetic naturalism holds that there are many legitimate ways of talking about the one natural world—from particle physics up through biology, sociology, and psychology, and further into aesthetics, judgments, and values—where at the higher poetic levels the descriptions are not fixed by the facts of the universe themselves.124 - In Search Of Reality
- There is no a priori impossibility in deriving first-person experience from physics: under poetic naturalism, 'I am experiencing the redness of red' is a higher-level emergent way of talking about a collection of particles and fields behaving in certain ways, and one can readily imagine particles and fields that would exhibit all the behaviors associated with consciousness, so the hard problem will not be solved but will evaporate once we map experiences to brain states.AMA | November 2021
- When judging an unfamiliar source writing outside their credentialed expertise, you should not dismiss them but should assess their credibility through traits of the person: familiarity with the field, appropriate confidence, clarity about what is known versus speculative, willingness to be wrong (fallibilism), and good-faith versus contrarian/sensationalist motives — rather than relying on a simple algorithm or credentials alone.AMA | December 2021